How to set Araxis as diff / merge tool for MSYS git? - windows

Question

I'm trying to use Araxis Merge as my diff / merge tool for MSYSGit.
I found a few resources on the net:
On the Araxis site, they mention an "easy" way, but it implies a executables (araxisgitdiff.exe and araxisgitmerge.exe) that are not part of my distro.
I also found some info in gitguru, but the actual information re: Araxis is sparse at best, and I could not make anything out of that.
Finally, there was some info on an older stackoverflow post, but the suggested method doesn't work for me. That particular info was geared towards OS X. I "translated" to Windows as best as I could, but without success:
I created /bin/git-diff-driver.sh
#!/bin/sh
"/c/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe" -title1:"$1 (repo version)" -title2:"$1 " -max "$2" "$5"
and edited gitconfig
[merge]
tool = araxismerge
[mergetool "araxismerge"]
cmd = "/c/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe" -3 -merge -wait $LOCAL $BASE $REMOTE $MERGED
[diff]
external = "/bin/git-diff-driver.sh"
and the only result I get is:
$ git diff HEAD^ HEAD
external diff died, stopping at PowerEditor/src/Notepad_plus.cpp.
Edit:
I've also tried with the exe named as "c:/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe" as suggested by one of the answers, with the same results.
Edit:
I've found that it can easily be set if you use TortoiseGit, but it seems to handle diff by itself and no settings from TortoiseGit give any indication on how to set up Araxis as a merge tool when diff is invoked from the command line.
Edit:
So, the question is: Is there anybody who successfully uses Araxis Merge to diff and merge stuff with MSYSGit, and if so, how do you it?

Answer 1

If you want to have 'git diff' always use araxis you can use the instructions in the help file, but if you want to have control to use 'git diff' as you normally would from the command line and 'git difftool' to engage the Araxis GUI.
Try adding the following to your git config::
[difftool "araxis"]
path = "/c/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe"
renames = true
trustExitCode = true
[diff]
tool = araxis
stat = true
[mergetool "araxismergetool"]
cmd = 'C:\\Program Files\\Araxis\\Araxis Merge\\araxisgitmerge.exe' "$REMOTE" "$BASE" "$PWD/$LOCAL" "$PWD/$MERGED"
trustExitCode = false
[mergetool]
keepBackup = false
[merge]
tool = araxismergetool
stat = true

Answer 2

The documentation at araxis has been updated: http://www.araxis.com/merge/documentation-windows/integrating-with-other-applications#Git
I can use the configuration shown there without any modifications.

Answer 3

Right... I got it working, with msysgit version 1.6.3.2.1299.gee46c, under DOS or Git Bash, with an evaluation license for Araxis Merge 2009, v2009.3713:
The approach is to use the new git difftool and git mergetool, instead of plain diff.
First, let's setup some scripts for those diff and merge tool
C:\>git config --global diff.tool adifftool
C:\>git config --global diff.external git-difftool--helper
C:\>git config --global difftool.adifftool.cmd "difftool.sh \"$LOCAL\" \"$REMOTE\" \"$MERGED\""
C:\>git config --global difftool.prompt false
Notes:
by setting diff.external to the Git script git-difftool--helper, I will use difftool even when I will type 'git diff'.
do not forget to pass $MERGED to your difftool script: that is the only variable with the real name of the file being diff'ed. $LOCAL and $REMOTE are temporary names.
For the merge tool, you would set the following global values:
C:\>git config --global merge.tool amergetool
C:\>git config --global mergetool.amergetool.cmd "mergetool.sh \"$PWD/$LOCAL\" \"$PWD/$BASE\" \"$PWD/$REMOTE\" \"$PWD/$MERGED\""
C:\>git config --global mergetool.prompt false
By setting those tools to some shell scripts, you will be able to switch tools from within those scripts.
Another approach is to name your tools (mergetool.araxis.cmd, mergetool.winmerge.cmd, ...) and to specify the right tool in the diff.tool or merge.tool setting.
Create difftool.sh and mergetool.sh in a directory referenced by your global environment variable PATH. They will work even from DOS (and they are sh -- shell -- scripts)
difftool.sh
#!/bin/sh
echo Launching Araxis Merge.exe: $3
t1="'$3 (from)'"
t2="'(to)'"
"C:/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/Compare.exe" -max -nowait -2 -title1:${t1} -title2:${t2} "$1" "$2"
Notes:
Impossible to have -title1:"someTitle With Space"... only title without space does work..., so for now, try it without any 'titleN' option.
Got it! You cannot pass the title value directly to the -title option, you need to set it to a local variable, with "' '" quotes combinations (the double quotes will disappear during the shell script execution, leaving the simple quotes, allowing spaces within a title!)
$3 represent the real name and not some temporary file name for diff purpose. Hence the use of $3 within the title1 option, with space in it.
git diff HEAD^ HEAD would not work in DOS session: only git diff "HEAD^" HEAD would.
mergetool.sh
#!/bin/sh
# Passing the following parameters to mergetool:
# local base remote merge_result
alocal=$1
base=$2
remote=$3
result=$4
t1="'$4 (current branch)'"
t2="'(common ancestor)'"
t3="'(to be merged)'"
if [ -f $base ]
then
"C:/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/Compare.exe" -max -wait -merge -3 -a2 -title1:${t1} -title2:${t2} -title3:${t3} "$alocal" "$base" "$remote" "$result"
else
"C:/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/Compare.exe" -max -wait -merge -3 -a2 -title1:${t1} -title2:${t2} -title3:${t3} "$alocal" "$result" "$remote" "$result"
fi
I am not sure I those scripts do work properly when multiple files are involved (multiple diffs, multiple files to be merged).
Just tested it: it works, and Araxis compare.exe does open one tab per file to diff or merge.
Give it a try and let us know ;)

Answer 4

I think that you need to be a bit more careful with your escaping in your .gitconfig.
Unfortunately, due to the way the config variable is expanded and evaled, your string needs to be an valid shell command which is then 'git config' escaped.
Try something like this:
[mergetool "araxismerge"]
cmd = \"/c/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe\" -3 -merge -wait \"$LOCAL\" \"$BASE\" \"$REMOTE\" \"$MERGED\"
Yes, not very pretty, I know. It's one of the cases where using git config directly is actually easier.
git config --global mergetool.araxismerge.cmd '"/c/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe" -3 -merge -wait "$LOCAL" "$BASE" "$REMOTE" "$MERGED"'

Answer 5

I struggled with this problem for quite a while, and now I finally can say, that all suggested dirty hacks (like intermediate shell scripts) are rather unnecessary =D. Thing is, all of the latest versions of MSYSGit (I have 1.6.4) support Araxis Merge (I have 2008) out of the box. It comes at no surprise, that internally it's called "araxis". So, all that you need is to set
[merge]
tool = araxis
in your .gitconfig. Also you have to include Araxis folder into your PATH environment variable (MSYSGit looks for Compare.exe).
For a good measure, other Git settings related to "araxis" mergetool, that you could have configured (especially, if you happen to choose exactly that name, as did some people on this page), should all be removed. That includes everything under [mergetool "araxis"] section. Be sure to remove them from all configs (system, global, and repository), otherwise, they might interfere with normal "internal tool" behavior.
In any case, if you're interested in how MSYSGit will start your Araxis Merge, or wondering what other mergetools it supports out of the box, the place to look is \share\git-gui\lib\mergetool.tcl script in your MSYSGit installation folder.
PS. You might be able to avoid setting PATH environment variable, by configuring mergetool.araxis.path in .gitconfig. Personally, I never bothered to do so, since
I use Araxis Merge from command line anyway.
Specifying directory path in .gitconfig (especially the one like "C:\Program Files\Araxis\Araxis Merge\", which contains spaces) can prove hard to be done correctly, since it is prone to backslash/forwardslash issues, that plague MSYSGit.
PPS. All of the above applies to making Araxis your difftool, too. I.e, you need to add
[diff]
tool = araxis
and remove anything else in [difftool "araxis"] section, if you have it in your config (don't forget to set up PATH, though).

Answer 6

You could try to follow the script mentioned in my answer about diffMerge (for Windows) and see if it works.
The executable path could be better expressed with:
#!/bin/sh
"C:/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe" -title1:"$1 (repo version)" -title2:"$1 " -max "$2" "$5"

Answer 7

One way I found to do it "simply" is to install TortoiseGit and set the diff / merge tools in TortoiseGit options.
However, this does not address the issue if you want to diff from the command line.

Answer 8

Since I've been bitten to customised git differs/mergers, I thought I would try to fix this one for once and for all. I got to the point where AraxisMerge started, but without the titles of the tabs. So that will be left as an exercise for the reader :)
Observations and comments:
I didn't have AraxisMerge, so I downloaded it and got a free 30-days evaluation license to try it out with. This version (7.0 it seems) comes with araxisgitdiff.exe, and the link with instructions you send works. So that would be option #1: upgrade araxis merge.
Since I'm working from CMD.EXE, 'git diff HEAD HEAD^' does not work. The '^' needs to be escaped to 'git diff HEAD "HEAD^"'.
For my own work I use kdiff3 as a free replacement on Windows which works reasonably well (it helps that it is supported by default by git)
Starting with the git-diff-driver.sh gave the same error to me. After changing the script to only contain 'echo', this did not change. So the error is independent from the contents of the script.
Then I removed the '/bin' part from .gitconfig, so the line becomes
external = "git-diff-driver.sh"
...and this started to work: it started the merger, but it does not escape the '(repo) ' part correctly. As a workaround I got it working without the titles with:
#!/bin/sh
"/c/Program Files/Araxis/Araxis Merge/compare.exe" -max "$2" "$5"
Good luck!