Avoid translating standard menus items in XCode project - xcode

Question

I have an XCode project, with the XIB interface files built using Interface Builder. I'm building localized XIB files by using ibtool to extract strings, translating them, and using ibtool again to build localized XIB files.
However, doing this means I have to translate all items in the application menus, including those that are completely standard (File, Save, Open, Minimize, etc.). Is there a way to avoid that?

Answer 1

i've developed a solution to this problem.
https://www.corecode.io/index_opensource.html
look for "Translator", it will translate your MainMenu.strings file into a dozen languages with the standard Apple translations for the standard menu item strings.
if you find some strings or languages missing that Aapple has included in their base apps, please send a patch over.

Answer 2

So, apparently no way around this.

Answer 3

I have been looking for a similar solution for a while and I found this resource
http://www.bdunagan.com/2009/03/15/ibtool-localization-made-easy/
It quotes toward the end of the article:
ibtool will look through MainMenu.xib for every user-visible string and insert that string with an associated ObjectID into MainMenu.strings, essentially a dictionary of strings keyed by ObjectID. Even better, the tool sorts them by ObjectID, so versioned .strings files are nicely diff’able. I can easily see what strings are added, removed, or just changed. Let me repeat this because it’s so incredibly handy: .strings files diff well! Of course, these .strings files are unicode, so they are not grep’able. Below is an example of the output for a string:
Go ahead and take a look I really hope it helps you as much as it helped me!

Answer 4

Translator by https://github.com/core-code/MiscApps/blob/master/Translator/Translator/MainMenuTranslations.plist
is cool but if you do not want to deal with 30 MainMenu.string files in your build (I personally don't) - you can just add MainMenuTranslations.plist to your resources (230KB uncompressed is tiny) and do it on the fly like this:
- (void) processMenu: (NSString*) app {
NSDictionary* d = [self loadMenuTranslations: app];
NSMenu* mm = NSApplication.sharedApplication.mainMenu;
for (int i = 0; i < mm.numberOfItems; i++) {
NSMenuItem* mi = [mm itemAtIndex: i];
mi.title = [self translateMenu: mi.title withDictionary: d];
NSMenu* sm = [[mm itemAtIndex: i] submenu];
sm.title = [self translateMenu: sm.title withDictionary: d];
for (int j = 0; j < sm.numberOfItems; j++) {
NSMenuItem* mi = [sm itemAtIndex: j];
mi.title = [self translateMenu: mi.title withDictionary: d];
}
}
}
- (NSString*) translateMenu: (NSString*) key withDictionary: (NSDictionary*) dictionary {
for (NSString* lang in dictionary) {
NSDictionary* translation = dictionary[lang];
NSString* t = translation[key];
if (t != null) {
return t;
}
}
return key;
}
- (NSDictionary*) loadMenuTranslations: (NSString*) app {
NSArray* langs = [NSUserDefaults.standardUserDefaults objectForKey: #"AppleLanguages"];
NSURL* url = [NSBundle.mainBundle URLForResource:#"MainMenuTranslations.plist" withExtension: null];
NSMutableDictionary* r = NSMutableDictionary.new;
NSDictionary* translations = [NSDictionary dictionaryWithContentsOfURL: url];
for (NSString* lang in langs) {
NSString* locale = [NSString stringWithFormat:#"%#.lproj", lang];
NSDictionary* translation = translations[locale];
NSMutableDictionary* d = [NSMutableDictionary.alloc initWithCapacity: translations.count * 3 / 2];
for (NSString* k in translation) {
NSString* v = translation[k];
NSString* key = k;
if ([k indexOf: #"APPLICATIONNAME"] >= 0) {
key = [k stringByReplacingOccurrencesOfString: #"APPLICATIONNAME" withString: app];
}
if ([v indexOf: #"APPLICATIONNAME"] >= 0) {
v = [v stringByReplacingOccurrencesOfString: #"APPLICATIONNAME" withString: app];
}
d[key] = v;
}
if (d.count > 0) {
r[lang] = d;
}
}
return r;
}
just call it from
- (void) applicationDidFinishLaunching: (NSNotification*) n {
// ...
[self processMenu: #"<your app name>"];
}
I wish there is a UniversalTranslation.plist somewhere (which could be probably collected automatically via creative use of translate.google.com)