I would like to make a complete text document from several sources (since one of the file source change, I want the doc to change).
I have to pass it through a translator I develop. I would like to pass the language as argument, to make it cleaner.
Yesterday, late at night, I dreamed of a makefile like this...
#makefile
# ...
my_complete_doc.%.html: my_trans_exe header.%.html $(wildcard source/*.%.html)
$< --language $(variable_for_%) > $#
(?) Does it replace % by all the languages which have their own header.language.html files. And does the file my_completed_doc.language.html get changed as soon as one of the source/*.language.html get changed?
(?) How to get the % replaced in several prerequisites, possibly into the wildcard and necessarily in the recipe?
First, the easy problem: you wish to use the '%' variable in the recipe. The answer is to use the '$*' automatic variable:
my_complete_doc.%.html: my_trans_exe ...
$< --language $* > $#
Then the easy question: yes, the header.%.html prerequisite is correct. When you try to build my_complete_doc.dutch.html then Make will evaluate it as header.dutch.html, when you try to build my_complete_doc.french.html, Make will evaluate it as header.french.html.
Now the tricky problem: the prerequisite $(wildcard source/*.%.html). Ordinarily, Make expands $(wildcard ...) statements before executing any rule, or deciding which targets to build. So it searches for any files such as source/foo.%.html or source/bar.%.html (that is, files whose names contain the character '%'), finds none, and evaluates the statement as an empty string. But Make will defer this evaluation until it has chosen the rule, if you use SECONDEXPANSION:
.SECONDEXPANSION:
my_complete_doc.%.html: my_trans_exe header.%.html $$(wildcard source/*.%.html)
$< --language $* > $#
(Note the '$$'. In the first -- ordinary -- expansion, Make reduces "$$(...)" to "$(...)", and in the second -- when '%' has a value -- it expands "$(...)".) Now if you modify any file such as source/foo.german.html, Make will consider the file my_complete_doc.german.html out of date and in need of rebuilding.
Related
I want to use the match pattern of a Makefile rule in a text function in the perquisites list.
Let's say I want to build a file, and that files perquisites are any other files with the same name in a list.
list_of_files=a/x b/x a/y b/y c/z
%:
echo 0 $#
touch $#
build/%: $(filter %/$*,$(list_of_files))
echo 1 target $#
echo 1 prereq $?
touch $#
.PHONY:
all: build/x
echo
In the above case, I want for a/x and b/x rules to also be triggered as they are filtered out of the list, however they are not.
The docs are pretty clear that what you're trying won't work as-is:
It’s very important that you recognize the limited scope in which automatic variable values are available: they only have values within the recipe. In particular, you cannot use them anywhere within the target list of a rule; they have no value there and will expand to the empty string. Also, they cannot be accessed directly within the prerequisite list of a rule.
One way to deal with this (as mentioned in the above documentation) is to use the secondary expansion capability:
.SECONDEXPANSION:
getprereqs = $(filter %/$*,$(list_of_files))
build/%: $$(getprereqs)
I have a rule for the target
data/processed/21.12.2021/experiment6/written_piv21122021.005.exp6.mp4
in my makefile such that it has a dependency
data/raw/21.12.2021/experiment6/piv21122021.005.exp6.mov
Using subst functions, I'm trying to create the dependency by pattern matching as
%/written_*.mp4: \
$(subst processed,raw, $$*)/*.mov \
<do something>
However, the above rule can't find the *.mov dependency. i have tried many versions of $(subst processed,raw, $$*)/*.mov to match the dependency but didn't work.
How to do this? What is the correct syntax?
First, you can't do this:
%/written_*.mp4:
You can't combine a pattern % with a wildcard *. You have to realize that make works in two very discrete steps: first, all the makefiles are parsed and an internal representation of all the targets and prerequisites are constructed into a graph. Then, make walks that graph figuring out what needs to be built and how to build it, and running recipes.
Make variables, functions, and wildcards in targets and prerequisites are expanded when makefiles are parsed (in the first step). Automatic variables like $* are not set until a recipe is invoked (the second step), and patterns like % are not matched/expanded until make tries to decide how to build something (again in the second step).
So, a rule like:
%/written_*.mp4: $(subst processed,raw, $$*)/*.mov
can't work because the wildcard will expand to files matching the literal filename %/written_*.mp4 which clearly has no matches since you won't have a directory named %. In any event you can't use wildcards in targets because when make is parsing the makefile those targets won't exist (since that's what you want make to build) so the wildcards won't match anything. Also, $$* is the literal string $* and there is no processed string in that so the subst function will do nothing. And, even if /*.mov did match something it would put ALL the files matching that wildcard as prerequisites of every target so they'd all get rebuilt whenever any one changed.
And finally, you definitely should not use a backslash after your prerequisites: this just turns your recipe into prerequisites.
Your problem is very difficult to solve because your target and prerequisite differ in multiple distinct places and make doesn't support multiple % matching. You can get most of the way there with this:
data/processed/%.mp4: data/raw/%.mov
<do something>
However this is not quite right because the % in the target is written_... while in the prerequisite it's just ... and this is not possible to represent in make.
If you can rework the filenames so that instead of written_piv21122021.005.exp6.mp4 you can use piv21122021.005.exp6.written.mp4 (or even better you don't need the written_ prefix at all) then you can easily do this. If not you'll need to get very fancy to make this work.
Here is an imperfect kludge.
Delegate the work to another makefile I'll call adjunct.mk. In the main makefile:
data/processed/%.mp4:
#$(MAKE) -f adjunct.mk $#
And in adjunct.mk this ugly transformation:
.SECONDEXPANSION:
$(MAKECMDGOALS): $$(patsubst data/processed/%,data/raw/%,$$(subst written_,,$$(patsubst %.mp4,%.mov,$$#)))
...do whatever with $< and $#...
This incurs the usual cost of recursive Make: it blinds the higher-level Make to the dependency relations being tracked by the lower one. So if your Make must build that mov file, or you try to build the mp4 when the mov does not exist, then this solution will require some more careful pipefitting before it will work correctly.
I'm trying to write a Makefile where multiple source files (in my case they are markdown) create multiple target files (pdfs). However, the target files generated have extra characters in the file name that can't be predicted (it happens to be a version number encoded in the source), but ideally the Makefile would not have to read the source itself.
So, for example:
file1.md => file1-v1.pdf
file2.md => file2-v2.pdf
...
I can calculate source name given a target name (by excluding anything after the hyphen and adding .md), but cannot calculate target name given the source.
Is it possible to write a Makefile that builds only the targets where the source have been updated?
This will be ugly, but it will work.
As it often is with Make, our problem divides into these two problems:
1. construct a list of targets
2. build them
Suppose we have five md files which map to pdf files (whose names we don't know beforehand):
file1.md => file1-v1.pdf
file2.md => file2-v1.pdf
file3.md => file3-v1.pdf
file4.md => file4-v1.pdf
file5.md => file5-v1.pdf
We can't use the real output file names as targets, because we don't know them beforehand, but we see five input files and know that we must build one output file for each. For now, a fake target name will do:
file1-dummy.pdf: file1.md
zap file1.md
When Make executes this rule, it produces the file file1-v1.pdf. The fact that it doesn't produce a file named file1-dummy.pdf is disquieting, but not a serious problem. We can turn this into a pattern rule:
%-dummy.pdf: %.md
zap $<
Then all we have to do is turn the list of existing input files (file1.md, file2.md, ...) into a list of dummy targets (file1-dummy.pdf, file2-dummy.pdf, ...), and build them. So far, so good.
But suppose some of the output files already exist. If file2-v2.pdf already exists -- and is newer than file2.md -- then we would prefer that Make not rebuild it (by attempting to build file2-dummy.pdf). In that case we would prefer that file2-v2.pdf be in the target list, with a rule that worked like this:
file2-v2.pdf: file2.md
zap $<
This is not easy to turn into a pattern rule, because Make does not handle wildcards very well, and cannot cope with multiple wildcards in a single phrase, not without a lot of clumsiness. But there is a way to write one rule that will cover both cases. First note that we can obtain the part of a variable before the hyphen with this kludge:
$(basename $(subst -,.,$(VAR)))
Armed with this, and with secondary expansion, we can write a pattern rule that will work with both cases, and construct a target list that will exploit it:
# There are other ways to construct these two lists, but this will do.
MD := $(wildcard *.md)
PDF := $(wildcard *.pdf)
PDFROOTS := $(basename $(subst -,.,$(basename $(PDF))))
MDROOTS := $(filter-out $(PDFROOTS), $(basename $(MD)))
TARGETS:= $(addsuffix -foo.pdf, $(MDROOTS)) $(PDF)
.SECONDEXPANSION:
%.pdf: $$(basename $$(subst -,., $$*)).md
# perform actions on $<
Make's algorithm always starts with the final output product and works its way backwards to the source files, to see what needs to be updated.
Therefore, you HAVE to be able to enumerate the final output product as a target name and correlate that back to the inputs that generate that output, for make to work.
This is also why make is not a great tool for building Java, for example, since the output filenames don't map easily to the input file names.
So, you must have at least one target/prerequisite pair which is derivable (for implicit rules), or state-able (for explicit rules)--that is, known at the time you write the makefile. If you don't then a marker file is your only alternative. Note you CAN add extra generated, non-derivative prerequisites (for example, in compilers you can add header files as prerequisites that are not related to the source file name), in addition to the known prerequisite.
#Beta's answer is informative and helpful, but I needed a solution (using GNU Make 4.1) that worked when the destination filename bears no resemblance to the input filename, for example, if it is generated from its content. I came up with the following, which takes every file matching *.in, and creates a file by reading the contents of the source file, appending a .txt, and using it as a filename to create. (For example, if test.in exists and contains foo, the makefile will create a foo.txt file.)
SRCS := $(wildcard *.in)
.PHONY: all
all: all_s
define TXT_template =
$(2).txt: $(1)
touch $$#
ALL += $(2).txt
endef
$(foreach src,$(SRCS),$(eval $(call TXT_template, $(src), $(shell cat $(src)))))
.SECONDARY_EXPANSION:
all_s: $(ALL)
The explanation:
The define block defines the recipe needed to make the text file from the .in file. It's a function that takes two parameters; $(1) is the .in. file and $(2) is the contents of it, or the base of the output filename. Replace touch with whatever makes the output. We have to use $$# because eval will expand everything once, but we want $# to left after this expansion. Since we have to collect all the generated targets so we known what all the make, the ALL line accumulates the targets into one variable. The foreach line goes through each source file, calls the function with the source filename and the contents of the file (i.e. what we want to be the name of the target, here you'd normally use whatever script generates the desired filename), and then evaluates the resulting block, dynamically adding the recipe to make. Thanks to Beta for explaining .SECONDARY_EXPANSION; I needed it for reasons not entirely clear to me, but it works (putting all: $(ALL) at the top doesn't work). The all: at the top depends on the secondary expansion of all_s: at the bottom and somehow this magic makes it work. Comments welcome.
maybe try this ? or something along those lines
# makefile
SRCS=$(wildcard *.md)
PDFS=$(shell printf *.pdf)
$(PDFS): $(SRCS)
command ...
the printf *.pdf is meant to either expand to the first of the pdf files if they exist, else fail if they don't and that will signal to make that it should build. if this doesn't work i suggest maybe experimenting with find, ls or other listing tools (e.g. compgen, complete), maybe even in combination with xargs to get everything on one line.
I have another make-like tool that produces an XML as an artifact after parsing my makefile which I'll then further process with Python.
It'd simplify things for me - a lot - if I could have make consider every single prerequisite to be an actual target because then this other tool
will classify each and every file as a "job".
This is a fragment of my makefile:
.obj/eventlookupmodel.o: C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/src/AL2HMIBridge/LookupModels/eventlookupmodel.cpp C:\Users\User1\Desktop\A\PROJ\src\AL2HMIBridge\LookupModels\eventlookupmodel.h \
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qabstractitemmodel.h \
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qvariant.h \
...
I'd want for make to think I have a dummy rule for each prerequisite such as below:
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qvariant.h:
#echo target pre= $#
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qabstractitemmodel.h:
#echo target pre=$#
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/src/AL2HMIBridge/LookupModels/eventlookupmodel.cpp :
#echo target pre=$#
C:\Users\User1\Desktop\A\PROJ\src\AL2HMIBridge\LookupModels\eventlookupmodel.h:
#echo target pre=$#
I don't care about the exact form of the rule just that each file is considered an actual target.
My method of passing in this rule would be by setting the MAKEFILES variable like so
make all MAKEFILES=Dummy.mk
with Dummy.mk containing this rule so that I do not modify the makefiles.
I've tried the following so far.
Dummy.mk:
%.h:
#echo header xyz = $#
%:
#echo other xyz= $#
This partially works.
I run make all --trace --print-data-base MAKEFILES=Dummy.mk and I can see that
make does "bind" the %.h: rule to the header files. In the --print-data-base section, I see that rule being assigned to the header files.
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/QNX_SDK/target/qnx6/usr/include/stddef.h:
# Implicit rule search has been done.
# Implicit/static pattern stem: 'C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/QNX_SDK/target/qnx6/usr/include/stddef'
# Last modified 2016-05-27 12:39:16
# File has been updated.
# Successfully updated.
# recipe to execute (from '#$(QMAKE) top_builddir=C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/HMI_FORGF/src/../lib/armle-v7/release/ top_srcdir=C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/HMI_FORGF/ -Wall CONFIG+=release CONFIG+=qnx_build_release_with_symbols CONFIG+=rtc_build -o Makefile C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/HMI_FORGF/src/HmiLogging/HmiLogging.pro
', line 2):
#echo header xyz = $#
However, I do NOT see the "echo header xyz $#"-rule being executed.
Regarding the %: rule, it is neither executed for the .cpp files nor "bound" to them in the --print-data-base section.
However, it is bound and executed for existing targets which have no suffix i.e.
all: library binary
binary: | library
ifs: | library
For the %: rule, the reason for this behavior is because of 10.5.5 Match-Anything Pattern Rules: If you do not mark the match-anything rule as terminal, then it is non-terminal. A non-terminal match-anything rule cannot apply to a file name that indicates a specific type of data. A file name indicates a specific type of data if some non-match-anything implicit rule target matches it.
If I make it non-terminal - no double colon - then the rule doesn't apply to built-in types like .cppunless I un-define the built-in rules that negate my intended %: rule.
If I make it terminal, "it does not apply unless its prerequisites actually exist". But a .h or .cpp doesn't technically have prerequisites; can I just create a dummy file and have that as its prerequisite?
NOTE: This has NOTHING to do with gcc -M generation. Yes the -M option would help in the specific case of header and source files but this question is for more generic targets and prerequisites that already exist in the makefile when make is launched.
This may take a few iterations. Try:
%.h: null
#echo header xyz = $#
%: null
#echo other xyz= $#
null:
#:
Try generating static pattern rules for the header files. See one of the answers to Make ignoring Prerequisite that doesn't exist.
Static pattern rules only apply to an explicit list of target files like this:
$(OBJECTS): %.o: %.c
*recipe here*
where the variable OBJECTS is defined earlier in the makefile to be a list of target files (separated by spaces), for example:
OBJECTS := src/fileA.c src/fileB.c src/fileC.c
Note that you can use the various make utility functions to build that list of target files. For example, $(wildcard pattern), $(addsuffix), etc.
You should also ensure that the recipe "touches" the header file to change the timestamp.
I've found that using static pattern rules instead of pattern rules fixes problems where make doesn’t build prerequisites that don’t exist, or deletes files that you want.
Here is an example of using wildcard to copy files from one directory to another.
# Copy images to build/images
img_files := $(wildcard src/images/*.png src/images/*.gif src/images/*.jpg \
src/images/*.mp3)
build_images := $(subst src/,$(BUILD_DIR)/,$(img_files))
$(build_images): $(BUILD_DIR)/images/% : src/images/%
mkdir -p $(dir $#)
cp -v -a $< $#
There are other make functions like addprefix that could be used to generate a more complex file specification.
Given this bit of Makefile:
# for pattern matching
$(OBJDIR) := build
# just to see if a level of indirection will work
my_dir = $(dir $(1))
$(OBJECTS) : $(OBJDIR)/% : $(HEADERS) $(SRCDIR)/% | % $(dir %) $(call my_dir,%)
#echo output-only = $|
This is a static pattern rule with order-only prerequisites.
Consider the target "build/utility/debug.js". The output of the above rule will be this:
output-only = utility/debug.js ./
The first component, "utility/debug.js", is properly copied from the stem (%).
The second component, "./", is the output of calling the dir function in the prerequisites list.
The third component, an empty string, is the output of calling my my_dir function in the prerequisites list.
If I change my_dir to this:
my_dir = $(1)
The output remains the same. If I change it to this:
my_dir = "foo"
Then make complains there is no rule to make "foo" (which is expected). It appears, then, that $(1) is not getting bound in the call to my_dir.
What's going on? Why can't I pass the stem to a function? I have a workaround that uses secondary expansion, but I want to know why I can't write my rule this way.
EDIT: I'm new to stackoverflow, forgive me if this is not the way things are done here.
I want $(1) because I am passing the stem as an argument to my_dir, as Alex pointed out.
I don't know why it was suggested I want "$". I don't believe $ by itself expands to anything in any context.
I know that automatic variables are only available in the recipe. I am not using an automatic variable in the prerequisites - I am using the stem:
Each target is matched against the target-pattern to extract a part of the target name, called the stem. This stem is substituted into each of the prereq-patterns to make the prerequisite names (one from each prereq-pattern). - the manual
The fact that the stem is available is demonstrated by the example: the stem expands to the correct value when used alone, but not when passed to a function.
As can be seen in this section of the GNU make manual, variable and function references in the list of prerequisites are immediately expanded, during the read in phase. This means, before any pattern matching is done, so the % has no special meaning yet; it is interpreted as a literal character in the two function references, $(dir %) and $(call my_dir,%), both having ./ as a result, which get merged in the reference to $| in the recipe.
I don't know of any other workaround than the one you already found, i.e. secondary expansion.
Note $1 is not a special variable that expands to anything interesting related to pattern rules (or static pattern rules). The $1 variable only has unique behavior within the context of a user-defined macro invoked by the $(call ...) function.
You wanted to use $*, not $1; $* is an automatic variable which expands to the stem of the target of the rule.
However, in all versions of make (including the POSIX standard definition of make), automatic variables (including $*, $<, $#, $^, etc.) are only available in the context of the recipe. They are not available in the context of the target or prerequisite lists. See the GNU make manual section on Automatic Variables for more details.
As you suggest, there is a GNU make-specific feature enabled by the .SECONDEXPANSION pseudo target which provides a way to avoid this limitation.