I have a solution with multiple projects and we use FxCop. We want to run it once the compilation requested finishes (it may be one project, a folder with several folders or the whole solution).
Is there a way of doing this? We currently do it per project but this has some drawbacks.
Yes, there is a way to do it by putting a file next to your solution file with a specific naming pattern: after.{Your solution name here}.sln.targets
<!--?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?-->
<project toolsversion="4.0" xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003">
<target name="AtTheStart" beforetargets="Build">
<message text="GenerateCode target running" importance="high">
</message>
</target>
<target name="AtTheEnd" aftertargets="Build">
<message text="GenerateCode target running" importance="high">
</message>
</target>
</project>
But if you want to run FxCop effectively and have visualstudio installed, you can actually activate it during the build by including /p:RunCodeAnalysis=true or /p:RunCodeAnalysis=always on the call to MsBuild. This will run the configured ruleset file during the build. /p:CodeAnalysisRuleSet=PathTo.ruleset will let you specify a specific ruleset file.
The commandline will always overwrite the project's own configuration. And it will run in the most optimal way.
I would put the FxCop project set (with all the dll's in all your projects) and call it after all the projects are built in VS.
Related
Wondering if there is an easy way to do what I want with Visual Studio solution.
I have a solution that has 10+ VC++ projects. These projects don't have any dependencies on each other. I want to create msbuild target on the solution that goes and builds all the sub projects.
Something like:
msbuild mysolution.sln /t:RebuildAll /p:Configuration=Debug
How do I add "RebuildAll" target to my solution that iterates all projects in the solution and invokes "Rebuild" target on them?
Thanks
According to your description I make some test, you can refer to the following steps:
Create a file named test.proj
Use this code in the file, remember to change your own solution path in the code:
<Project xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003">
<ItemGroup>
<ProjectFile Include="Your solution path/**/*.vcxproj">
<Properties>Configuration=Release</Properties>
</ProjectFile>
</ItemGroup>
<Target Name="BuildAll">
<MSBuild Projects="#(ProjectFile)" BuildInParallel="true" />
</Target>
</Project>
Then use this msbuild command line to build your projects msbuild test.proj -t:BuildAll -v:normal -m:30.
We have a solution with around 70 projects. One of them takes relatively long (~10min) but does not use system resources. We also employ parallel build to speed things up.
When I (re)add this project to the solution, it is at the end of the build order. The machine is 100% busy when compilong 69 projects and then 10min idle when compiling the 70th. When I manually edit the .sln-file so that the project comes first in all lists, it is somewhere in the middle. How can I move it to the beginning?
This is not about dependencies. This project A has only one to another project B and I am fine if B is first as long as A is second. Also, no other projects depends on project A.
It sounds like you have already tried editing project dependencies in visual studio. If you have already edited it to make the project first, but it still takes a while then you probably should just take it out of the solution file. Then put the building of it into your own msbuild script where you can use the MSBuildExtensions parallel tasks to make it build at the same time as everything else:
See https://mikefourie.wordpress.com/2012/02/29/executing-msbuild-targets-in-parallel-part-1/
And I'm pretty sure the MSBuildExtensions library is a nuget package now as well.
VisualStudios sln-files are very limited and are written in a format defined decades ago. In fact, it is converted to a msbuild-script before doing anything useful.
To have more flexibility, I added an msbuild-script (master.msbuild) with something similar to this (untested but proper documentation is available)
<Project xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003">
<ItemGroup>
<ProjectsToBuild Include="longrunningproject.proj" />
<ProjectToBuild
Include="SolutionWithTheOther69Projects.sln"
Properties="Configuration=Debug;Platform=x86"/>
</ItemGroup>
<Target Name="Build" >
<MSBuild
Projects="#(ProjectsToBuild)"
Targets="Build"
BuildInParallel="true"
ContinueOnError="false"
Properties="VeloxVersion=$(VeloxVersion);RootDir=$(RootDir)"
/>
</Target>
</Project>
Projects are executed in order they are defined. Still no control what happens in the solution but I can put projects in front or behind it and can so influence the build order.
If the long-running task is called by an msbuild-exec-task, it is important to set the YieldDuringToolExecution-flag of this task. E.g.
<Exec
Command="..."
YieldDuringToolExecution="true"
/>
Otherwise, things are starting in parallel and then slowly dying off until the exec-task is done. I could not decode the logic behind that but honestly, I do not care.
After several days of try and error, the build machine screams at 100%-cpu-load, slowly come down to the one long-running task and then is done. Speedup-factor 2.5 :D
How can I move it to the beginning?
You can create a MSBuild project file named "before.<SolutionName>.sln.targets" in the same folder as your solution.
Then build the solution with command line (Visual Studio will ignore this file.), the before.<SolutionName>.sln.targets will be built before all of the Visual Studio projects in the solution.
In this case, we just need to build that special project in the before.<SolutionName>.sln.targets file, that special project will be built before all of projects in the solution.
The content of before.<SolutionName>.sln.targets like:
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<Project xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003">
<Target Name="BuildSpecialProject" BeforeTargets="Build">
<Message Text="Build My Specify Project" />
<MSBuild Projects="Path\YouSpecialName.csproj"/>
</Target>
</Project>
Then build the solution file with command line with MSBuild or dotnet:
msbuild /t:build "<SolutionPath>\<SolutionName>.sln"
dotnet build "<SolutionPath>\<SolutionName>.sln"
Check this thread for some more details.
Hope this helps.
How can a .cmd script run from within a Visual Studio (2005, 2008, 2010, 2012 and 2013 respectively) project's pre-link stage determine whether this is a full rebuild (Build.RebuildSolution/Build.RebuildOnlyProject) or "ordinary" build (Build.BuildSolution/Build.BuildOnlyProject)?
This is an external script (LuaJIT, if you must know) and I don't want to rebuild the library every single build of the project. Instead I'd like to limit the complete rebuild to situations where I choose exactly that option.
How can a .cmd script run from within a Visual Studio (2005, 2008, 2010, 2012 and 2013 respectively) project's pre-link stage determine whether this is a full rebuild ... or "ordinary" build ... ?
I do not know if the exact thing that you are asking can be done - perhaps someone else knows how to do it. I will, however, suggest an alternate approach.
My approach is to remove the build of the Lua library from the pre-link step to a separate Visual Studio NMake project. If you create an NMake project, you will be able to know which type of build (build or rebuild) is occurring.
Note that later versions of Visual Studio simply refer to the project type as "Make". For discussion purposes here, I will refer to the project type as "NMake". I believe this is just a naming difference, and that the underlying build project remains the same between the two versions.
As a simple test, I created two Visual Studio applications: 1) an NMake project that calls a batch file to create a static library, and 2) a console application that consumes the library from step 1.
The NMake Project
In Visual Studio, if you create a new NMake project, you will see a dialog that allows you to provide MS-DOS commands:
As you can see, there are commands for: Build, Clean, Rebuild, and others. I don't have a screen shot of the above dialog with my commands, but here is my NMake project's properties:
My Build command just checks for the existence of the output file (lua.lib). If it does not exist, then it calls the rebuild.bat batch file. My Rebuild command always calls the batch file. My Clean command just deletes the output. I am not really sure what the Output command is used for, but I just filled in the path to the build output (lua.lib).
Now if you do a build, the lua.lib file will only be created if it is not there. If it is already there, nothing is done. If you do a rebuild, then a new lua.lib file is created.
The Console Application
In my console application, I added a reference to the NMake project - this way the NMake project is built prior to the console application. Here is the console application's reference page:
I also added the lua.lib file as an input during the application's link stage:
When the console application is built (during a build), it will build the NMake project if needed, and use the output (lua.lib) during the linker stage. When the console application is rebuilt (during a rebuild), it will also rebuild the NMake project.
Other Thoughts
My screen shots above only show the debug version of the properties. Your projects will have to account for the release version. There probably is a VS macro to handle this, but I am not sure since it has been ages since I've done anything with C/ C++.
In my testing above I use a single build batch file for both the build and rebuild. Obviously, you could do the same or you could use different batch files.
It may be a bit of a hack, but in .csproj file there are sections
<Target Name="BeforeBuild">
</Target>
<Target Name="AfterBuild">
</Target>
You can set an variable from BeforeBuild and retrieve it from cmd script. Later on reset this variable in AfterBuild and you should be good to go.
Ok, this is going to be a long one.
First of all - do not take my code 'as is' - it is terrible one with lots of hacks, I had no idea msbuild is so broken by default (it seems at work I have access to waaaay more commands that make life easier). And another thing - it seems vcxproj is broken at some poin - I was not able to integrate the way I wanted with only BeforeRebuild and AfterRebuild targets - I had to redefine hole Rebuild target (it is located in C:\Windows\Microsoft.NET\Framework\v4.0.30319\Microsoft.Common.targets)
So, the idea is the following: when a Rebuild is happening we create an anchor. Then, during PreLink stage we execute cmd which is able to use created anchor. If the anchor is in place - we deal with Rebuild, if there is no anchor - it is a simple Build. After Rebuild is done - we delete the anchor.
modifications in vcxproj file:
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<Project DefaultTargets="Build" ToolsVersion="4.0" xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003">
....
<PropertyGroup Condition="'$(Configuration)|$(Platform)'=='Debug|Win32'" Label="Configuration">
....
<PreLinkEventUseInBuild>true</PreLinkEventUseInBuild>
....
</PropertyGroup>
....
<ItemDefinitionGroup Condition="'$(Configuration)|$(Platform)'=='Debug|Win32'">
.....
<PreLinkEvent>
<Command>D:\PreLink\b.cmd</Command>
</PreLinkEvent>
.....
</ItemDefinitionGroup>
.....
<Target Name="BeforeRebuild">
<Exec Command="echo 2 > D:\PreLink\2.txt" />
</Target>
<Target Name="AfterRebuild">
<Exec Command="del D:\PreLink\2.txt" />
</Target>
<!-- This was copied from MS file -->
<PropertyGroup>
<_ProjectDefaultTargets Condition="'$(MSBuildProjectDefaultTargets)' != ''">$(MSBuildProjectDefaultTargets)</_ProjectDefaultTargets>
<_ProjectDefaultTargets Condition="'$(MSBuildProjectDefaultTargets)' == ''">Build</_ProjectDefaultTargets>
<RebuildDependsOn>
BeforeRebuild;
Clean;
$(_ProjectDefaultTargets);
AfterRebuild;
</RebuildDependsOn>
<RebuildDependsOn Condition=" '$(MSBuildProjectDefaultTargets)' == 'Rebuild' " >
BeforeRebuild;
Clean;
Build;
AfterRebuild;
</RebuildDependsOn>
</PropertyGroup>
<Target
Name="Rebuild"
Condition=" '$(_InvalidConfigurationWarning)' != 'true' "
DependsOnTargets="$(RebuildDependsOn)"
Returns="$(TargetPath)"/>
<!-- End of copy -->
</Project>
And the cmd looks like this:
if exist 2.txt (
echo Rebuild818181
) else (
echo Build12312312
)
The output from Output window:
1>Task "Exec" (TaskId:41)
1> Task Parameter:Command=D:\PreLink\b.cmd
1> :VCEnd (TaskId:41)
1> Build12312312 (TaskId:41)
Things to improve:
Use normal variables instead of external file (it seems MsBuild extension pack should do it)
Probably find a way to override only BeforeRebuild and AfterRebuild instead of the hole Rebuild part
It is much easier. Just add the following target to your build file or visual Studio Project
<Target Name="AfterRebuild">
<Message Text="AFTER REBUILD" Importance="High" />
<!--
Do whatever Needs to be done on Rebuild - as the message shows in VS Output
window it is only executed when an explicit rebuild is triggered
-->
</Target>
If you want a two step solution use this as a template:
<PropertyGroup>
<IsRebuild>false</IsRebuild>
</PropertyGroup>
<Target Name="BeforeRebuild">
<Message Text="BEFORE REBUILD" Importance="High" />
<PropertyGroup>
<IsRebuild>true</IsRebuild>
</PropertyGroup>
</Target>
<Target Name="BeforeBuild">
<Message Text="BEFORE BUILD: IsRebuild: $(IsRebuild)" Importance="High" />
</Target>
I have a simple MSBuild file that I'm learning with.
Here it is:
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<Project ToolsVersion="4.0" DefaultTargets="Clean" xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003">
<PropertyGroup Label="Globals">
<ProjectGuid>{D5A16164-962E-4A6D-9382-240F31AB6C50}</ProjectGuid>
</PropertyGroup>
<Target Name="Clean">
<ItemGroup>
<BinFiles Include="bin\*.*" />
<fff Include="f\*.*" />
</ItemGroup>
<Delete Files="#(BinFiles)" />
<Delete Files="#(fff)" />
</Target>
</Project>
Now I want to include this in a Visual Studio solution and be able to run the "clean" target from Visual Studio 2012. I tried naming it testproject.msbuildproj like the internet seems to suggest "works", but it doesn't work. When I run the clean command I just get "unexpected error".
If I rename the project to testproject.csproj, it does some unintuitive things like creating compilation directories, but it does actually run my clean command properly. However, this is undesireable because it creates obj and bin/x86/debug type directories. It also looks goofy in Visual Studio because it still gives the References drop down.
How can I use just a plain vanilla MSBuild project from Visual Studio without random errors or false assumptions?
Note I only am having a problem with this from Visual Studio. Using msbuild from the command line it works perfectly
Visual Studio creates bin / obj folders when it opens csproj file. When you click Build / Rebuild / Clean it just uses appropriate targets from the project file.
You cannot stop VS from creating these folders, but you can ask it to create them in say temp folder by setting appropriate properties - refer this MSDN article for details.
So the steps are to rename your project to csproj, and add the following lines into project:
<PropertyGroup>
<OutputPath>$(Temp)\bin</OutputPath>
<IntermediateOutputPath>$(Temp)\obj</IntermediateOutputPath>
</PropertyGroup>
I usually use a bit different approach to work with MSBUILD files from VS:
I use regular csproj file with removed Import ... CSharp.targets part as pure container for my Build projects.
I add actual build files with targets and logic, and all properties, necessary artifacts like XSLT etc using "Include into project", so I can manage hierarchy and change any file from within VS.Net.
I redefine Build / Rebuild targets in csproj file for whatever I need, for example Build may contain minimum output, and while rebuild diagnostic one.
Like this:
<Target Name="Build">
<Exec Command="%windir%\Microsoft.NET\Framework64\v4.0.30319\msbuild.exe Builds\build.proj /t:Build /v:m" />
</Target>
<Target Name="Rebuild">
<Exec Command="%windir%\Microsoft.NET\Framework64\v4.0.30319\msbuild.exe Builds\build.proj /t:Build /v:d" />
</Target>
Since this question seems to have baffled / underwhelmed SO I will rephrase it with a partially formed idea of my own.
Could I somehow set up a batch file or something that runs after the whole solution is built, and this batch file would call msbuild to build specific targets inside a certain project? In order for it to work, I would have to somehow force msbuild build the target without regard to whether it thinks it's "up to date", because that is the core issue I'm butting up against.
Since you are dealing with building specifically you may want to replace your batch file with an MSBuild file. For example:
<Project xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003">
<ItemGroup>
<SolutionsToBuild Include="MySolution.sln"/>
<Projects Include="Proj1.csproj"/>
<Projects Include="Proj2.csproj"/>
<Projects Include="Proj3.csproj"/>
</ItemGroup>
<Target Name="BuildAll">
<!-- Just executes the DefaultTargets (Build) -->
<MSBuild Projects="#(SolutionsToBuild)"/>
<!-- Call Rebuild if you think its not building correctly -->
<MSBuild Projects="#(Projects)"
Targets="Rebuild"/>
</Target>
</Project>
Then you just invoke msbuild.exe on this file with:
msbuild.exe Build.proj /t:BuildAll
Since you said that you want to build specific projects after the solution is built just put those into the Projects ItemGroup as shown and use the MSBuild task to build them after the solution has been built. I've specified the Rebuild target to make sure you get a clean build.