I'm unable to join an EC2 instance to my Directory Services Simple AD in Amazon Web Services manually, per Amazon's documentation.
I have a Security Group attached to my instance which allows HTTP and RDP only from my IP address.
I'm entering the FQDN foo.bar.com.
I've verified that the Simple AD and the EC2 instance are in the same (public, for the moment) subnet.
DNS appears to be working (because tracert to my IP gives my company's domain name).
I cannot tracert to the Simple AD's IP address (it doesn't even hit the first hop)
I cannot tracert to anything on the Internets (same as above).
arp -a shows the IP of the Simple AD, so it appears my instance has received traffic from the Simple AD.
This is the error message I'm receiving:
The following error occurred when DNS was queried for the service
location (SRV) resource record used to locate an Active Directory
Domain Controller (AD DC) for domain "aws.bar.com":
The error was: "This operation returned because the timeout period
expired." (error code 0x000005B4 ERROR_TIMEOUT)
The query was for the SRV record for _ldap._tcp.dc._msdcs.aws.bar.com
The DNS servers used by this computer for name resolution are not
responding. This computer is configured to use DNS servers with the
following IP addresses:
10.0.1.34
Verify that this computer is connected to the network, that these are
the correct DNS server IP addresses, and that at least one of the DNS
servers is running.
The problem is the Security Group rules as currently constructed are blocking the AD traffic. Here's the key concepts:
Security Groups are whitelists, so any traffic that's not explicitly allowed is disallowed.
Security Groups are attached to each EC2 instance. Think of Security Group membership like having a copy of an identical firewall in front of each node in the group. (In contrast, Network ACLs are attached to subnets. With a Network ACL you would not have to specify allowing traffic within the subnet because traffic within the subnet does not cross the Network ACL.)
Add a rule to your Security Group which allows all traffic to flow within the subnet's CIDR block and that will fix the problem.
The question marked as the answer is incorrect.
Both of my AWS EC2 instances are in same VPC, same subnet, with same security group.
I have the same issue. Here are my inbound rules on my security group:
Here is the outbound rules:
I can also ping from the between the dc and the other host, bi-directional with replies on both side.
I also have the DC IP address set as the primary and only DNS server on the other EC2 instance.
AWS has some weird sorcery preventing a secondary EC2 instance from joining the EC2 domain controller, unless using their managed AD services which I am NOT using.
The other EC2 instance has the DC IP address set as primary DNS. And bundled with the fact I can ping each host from each other, I should have ZERO problems joining to domain.
I had a very similar problem, where at first LDAP over UDP (and before that, DNS) was failing to connect, even though the port tests were fine, resulting in the same kind of error (in network traces, communication between standalone server EC2 instance and the DC instance stopped at "CLDAP 201 searchRequest(4) "" baseObject", with nothing being returned). Did all sorts of building and rebuilding, only to find out that I was inadvertently blocking UDP traffic, which AWS needs for both LDAP and DNS. I had allowed TCP only, and the "All Open" test SG I was using was also TCP only.
D'oh!!!
Related
I am trying to set up SSM on Windows.
I have an ASG in a private subnet (absolutely 0 internet access). I can not use NAT, only VPC endpoints.
In the instance launch configuration, I have a PowerShell script that uses Set-DnsClientServerAddress so that the instance can find and join an AWS Managed MS AD service. I would also like to set up the instance so it can be fully managed with SSM.
The problem comes with the DNS Client Server Address.
When I set it to match the address of the AD service SSM will not work.
When I leave the DNS Client Server Address default, SSM works but I can not join the AD.
I tried forcing the SSM Agent to use the endpoints by creating a amazon-ssm-agent.json file and setting all three endpoints in there. This allowed the instance to show on the Managed Instance list, but its status never changed from pending and requests from within the instance still timed out.
Does anyone know the magic sauce to get these things all working at the same time?
EDIT 1:
I also tried adding a forward as described in this thread, however I'm either missing somethign or it is not working for my case:
https://forums.aws.amazon.com/thread.jspa?messageID=919331󠜣
It turns out that adding the forwarder as described in the link above worked. The part I was missing was joedaws comment, "I would also remove the existing 169.254.169.253 entry so that only the 10.201.0.2 ip address is in the list".
Of course, my IPs are different, but once I removed the preexisting forward so that my x.x.x.2 IP was the only one in the list (I did this for both of the AD DNS servers) the instance was discoverable by SSM.
So, I would make a minor change to the list that saugy wrote:
On a domain joined windows instance, log in with AD domain Admin user
Open DNS manager
Connect to one of the DNS IP addresses for the AWS AD
Select forwarders
Add the VPC's DNS IP (x.x.x.2 from you VPC's CIDR range)
Remove the existing IP (so you VPCs IP is the only one)
Click Apply
Repeat from step 3 with the other DNS IP address for the AWS AD (not 1
Also, as mentioned in the other post. This only has to be done once and the settings persist in the AD DNS.
I am unable to connect to amazon ec2 instance (public domain) form office network. It works fine outside the office network.
Looks like something is getting blocked in the network. Not sure how to figure out or which logs need to be checked to find out what exactly is getting blocked.
Error Message:
ec2-54-218-186-23.us-west-2.compute.amazonaws.com took too long to respond.
Typically, if the connection takes too long to respond, the problem is due to the Security Group assigned to the instance. Check that it is allowing Inbound access from the entire Internet (0.0.0.0/0) on your desired port (Windows RDP port 3389, SSH port 80).
Of course, opening up access to the entire Internet is not good for security, so it is better to limit it to a smaller range of IP addresses, such as your corporate network and your home IP address.
Reason
Security groups enable you to control traffic to your instance, including the kind of traffic that can reach your instance. For example, you can allow computers from only your home network to access your instance using SSH. If your instance is a web server, you can allow all IP addresses to access your instance using HTTP or HTTPS, so that external users can browse the content on your web server.
Before You Start
Decide who requires access to your instance; for example, a single host or a specific network that you trust such as your local computer's public IPv4 address. The security group editor in the Amazon EC2 console can automatically detect the public IPv4 address of your local computer for you. Alternatively, you can use the search phrase "what is my IP address" in an internet browser, or use the following service: Check IP. If you are connecting through an ISP or from behind your firewall without a static IP address, you need to find out the range of IP addresses used by client computers.
Warning
If you use 0.0.0.0/0, you enable all IPv4 addresses to access your instance using SSH. If you use ::/0, you enable all IPv6 address to access your instance. This is acceptable for a short time in a test environment, but it's unsafe for production environments. In production, you authorize only a specific IP address or range of addresses to access your instance.
THE SOLUTION BEGINS HERE
Your default security groups and newly created security groups include default rules that do not enable you to access your instance from the Internet. To enable network access to your instance, you must allow inbound traffic to your instance. To open a port for inbound traffic, add a rule to a security group that you associated with your instance when you launched it.
Adding a Rule for Inbound SSH Traffic to a Linux Instance
In the navigation pane of the Amazon EC2 console, choose Instances. Select your instance and look at the Description tab; Security groups lists the security groups that are associated with the instance. Choose view rules to display a list of the rules that are in effect for the instance.
In the navigation pane, choose Security Groups. Select one of the security groups associated with your instance.
In the details pane, on the Inbound tab, choose Edit. In the dialog, choose Add Rule, and then choose SSH from the Type list.
In the Source field, choose My IP to automatically populate the field with the public IPv4 address of your local computer. Alternatively, choose Custom and specify the public IPv4 address of your computer or network in CIDR notation. For example, if your IPv4 address is 203.0.113.25, specify 203.0.113.25/32 to list this single IPv4 address in CIDR notation. If your company allocates addresses from a range, specify the entire range, such as 203.0.113.0/24.
Choose Save.
You can find detailed solution here
For testing purposes, I set up a VPC on Amazon and created an instance within the VPC. I've added a gateway for the 0.0.0.0/0 address to the attached routing table, and given the instance an elastic IP address. I'm unable to ssh or ping it, even when I set the security group to allow all traffic. I must be missing something obvious. What am I doing wrong?
It turns out that when I created the instance, I accepted the default security group, which only allows access from a specific IP address. When I added another instance, I created it with a security group which allowed all traffic, and I was able to ping it.
I have tried everything, I can get to my application using the ec2-x-x-x-x.compute-1.amazonaws.com, I cannot ping the address.
However, when I do ping the amazon DNS, it identifies with the IP address of but does not respond to ping.
When I put the IP address in the browser, it times out and gives me the Chrome "Oops", I have went through the Security vgroup several times.
I have checked the server, including the IPtables and the ports that Apache is listening to.
I don't have a lot of knowledge in this area, But I tried everything in the forum and more.
I even created another Elastic IP and associated it with the instance.
Please help.
By default, you cannot ping an EC2 instance, since it is blocked by the firewall (see why can't I ping my instance):
Ping uses ICMP ECHO, which by default is blocked by your firewall.
You'll need to grant ICMP access to your instances by updating the
firewall restrictions that are tied to your security group.
ec2-authorize default -P icmp -t -1:-1 -s 0.0.0.0/0
Check out the latest developer guide for details.
Section: Instance Addressing and Network Security -> Network Security
-> Examples
As for HTTP requests - your instance is available and looks fine (I suggest you remove the real DNS name from your post though)...
For ec2 best options is
1) open port 5060 and 10000-20000 udp on firewall(security group)
2) order and attach elastic IP.
3) in sip.conf add
externhost=elastic_ip_her
localnet=10.0.0.0/255.0.0.0
Every time you start/stop that instance attach same elastic IP.
For web access you also need open port 80 in security group
How can I make ec2 instance communicate with rds instance on aws by internal ip address or dns?
I only see public dns like xxx.cehmrvc73g1g.eu-west-1.rds.amazonaws.com:3306
Will internal ipaddress will be faster than public dns?
Thanks
A note for posterity, ensure that you enable DNS on the VPC Peering link!
Enabling DNS Resolution Support for a VPC Peering Connection
To enable a VPC to resolve public IPv4 DNS hostnames to private IPv4
addresses when queried from instances in the peer VPC, you must modify
the peering connection.
Both VPCs must be enabled for DNS hostnames and DNS resolution.
To enable DNS resolution support for the peering connection
Open the Amazon VPC console at https://console.aws.amazon.com/vpc/.
In the navigation pane, choose Peering Connections.
Select the VPC peering connection, and choose Actions, Edit DNS
Settings.
To ensure that queries from the peer VPC resolve to private IP
addresses in your local VPC, choose the option to enable DNS
resolution for queries from the peer VPC.
If the peer VPC is in the same AWS account, you can choose the option
to enable DNS resolution for queries from the local VPC. This ensures
that queries from the local VPC resolve to private IP addresses in the
peer VPC. This option is not available if the peer VPC is in a
different AWS account.
Choose Save.
If the peer VPC is in a different AWS account, the owner of the peer
VPC must sign into the VPC console, perform steps 2 through 4, and
choose Save.
You can use the "Endpoint" DNS name. It will resolve to the internal IP when used within the VPC and resolves to a public ip when used outside of your AWS network. You should never use the actual IP address because the way the RDS works it could possibly change in the future.
If you ping it from your EC2 (on the same VPC) server you can verify this.
It is amazing to see the amount of down votes I've got given that my answer is the only correct answer, here is 2 other sources:
https://forums.aws.amazon.com/thread.jspa?threadID=70112
You can use the "Endpoint" DNS name. It will resolve to the internal IP when used within EC2.
https://serverfault.com/questions/601548/cant-find-the-private-ip-address-for-my-amazon-rds-instance2
The DNS endpoint provided in the AWS console will resolve to the internal IPs from within Amazon's network.
Check out the AWS EC2 docs: http://docs.aws.amazon.com/AWSEC2/latest/UserGuide/using-instance-addressing.html#concepts-private-addresses.
It doesn't appear that this necessarily applies to RDS, however.
When resolving your RDS instance from within the same VPC the internal IP is returned by the Amazon DNS service.
If the RDS instance is externally accessible you will see the external IP from outside the VPC. However, if the EC2 instance NOT available publiclly the internal IP address is returned to external and internal lookups.
Will internal ip address will be faster than the external address supplied by public dns?
Most likely as the packets will need to be routed when using the external addresses, increasing latency.
It also requires that your EC2 instances have a public IP or NAT gateway along with appropriate security groups and routes, increasing cost, increasing complexity and reducing security.
its pretty easy, telnet your RDS endpoint using command prompt on windows or through unix terminal
for example: telnet "you RDS endpoint" "Port"
trying to connect "You get your RDS internal IP here"