Does the rpc syntax in proto3 allow null requests or responses?
e.g. I want the equivalent of the following:
rpc Logout;
rpc Status returns (Status);
rpc Log (LogData);
Or should I just create a null type?
message Null {};
rpc Logout (Null) returns (Null);
rpc Status (Null) returns (Status);
rpc Log (LogData) returns (Null);
Kenton's comment below is sound advice:
... we as developers are really bad at guessing what we might want in the future. So I recommend being safe by always defining custom params and results types for every method, even if they are empty.
Answering my own question:
Looking through the default proto files, I came across Empty that is exactly like the Null type I suggested above :)
excerpt from that file:
// A generic empty message that you can re-use to avoid defining duplicated
// empty messages in your APIs. A typical example is to use it as the request
// or the response type of an API method. For instance:
//
// service Foo {
// rpc Bar(google.protobuf.Empty) returns (google.protobuf.Empty);
// }
//
message Empty {
}
You also can use predefined:
import "google/protobuf/empty.proto";
package MyPackage;
service MyService {
rpc Check(google.protobuf.Empty) returns (google.protobuf.Empty) {}
}
you can also use another bool property inside the Reply structure. like this
message Reply {
string result = 1;
bool found = 2;
}
so if you dont find the result or some error happened you can return from the service class this
return new Reply()
{
Found = false
};
Related
I'm designing a gRPC service written in Go.
In front of the gRPC service is Envoy which converts incoming HTTP requests to gRPC and converts the gRPC responses to JSON.
The requirement of this application is to have an endpoint that returns the following JSON object:
{
my_id: "AAA"
}
I can model this response pretty simply in Go like this:
// A MyResponse object.
message MyResponse {
// contents is a list of contents.
string my_id = 1;
}
But the requirement that I have is that sometimes my_id might be null. In that case, I want to get the following JSON back:
{
my_id: null
}
it
Is it possible to modify MyResponse such that my_id can be a string or a null in the JSON object that is returned? If so, how? If not, isn't this a pretty big gap in the design of gRPC?
I suggest you to use the StringValue field of the Package google.protobuf:
StringValue Wrapper message for string.
The JSON representation for StringValue is JSON string.
So in your proto files, you should import:
import "google/protobuf/wrappers.proto";
then use as example:
google.protobuf.StringValue name = 2;
For handle the values you can check the wrappers.StringValue
type of the github.com/golang/protobuf/ptypes/wrappers package and the helpers of the google.golang.org/protobuf/types/known/wrapperspb repo.
Given that i have multiple models, each needed to have their own create/get/get list API.
Do i need to add two different types of messages (single and list) for every model?
For example :
If i have a student type -
message Student{
string name = 1;
}
and a rpc:
rpc CreateStudent(Student) returns (google.protobuf.Empty){
..............
}
If i'd like to add a rpc to create a list of students, or get a list of students
rpc CreateStudends(??????) returns (google.protobuf.Empty){
..............
}
rpc GetAllStudents() returns (??????){
..............
}
Do i need to also define
message StudentList{
repeated Student students = 1;
}
Or is there a way to use a list type directly in the message input/output?
Yes, basically - you would want a different message type per element type, or maybe a single root type with a oneof style content. Raw protobuf does not include a concept of generics or templates.
Some libraries do, but: that's outside of the specification.
You can simply add the stream keyword to your RPCs. No need to define a message field as repeated, stream will send or receive multiple independent messages.
message Student {
string name = 1;
}
with RPCs:
rpc CreateStudent(Student) returns (google.protobuf.Empty) {
..............
}
rpc CreateStudents(stream Student) returns (google.protobuf.Empty) {
..............
}
rpc GetAllStudents() returns (stream Student) {
..............
}
It's good practice to send/stream a response object rather than empty. Otherwise, you only have the gRPC response code to indicate a problem and will need to reference the logs to debug.
I am using interceptors to perform additional validation based on the optional extensions set on an RPC on incoming and out going RPCs.
Given the following gRPC schema:
extend google.protobuf.MethodOptions {
string my_option = 50006;
}
service MyService {
rpc Foo (FooRequest) returns (FooResponse) {
option (my_option) = "foo"
}
}
How do I go about getting the value of my_option? At first I had thought to get it from the request using this. However, as this is a MethodOptions it doesn't seem that its part of the descriptor. Thoughts?
Found the following answer for those who get here in the future.
I see that StringValue is the message wrapper for a string message, which I attempt to use in:
service SomeService {
// health
rpc HealthCheck(google.protobuf.Empty)
returns (google.protobuf.Empty) {}
// create
rpc CreateSomething(SomeMessageType)
returns (StringValue) {}
}
However, I get a message from protoc like:
somefile.proto:30:14: "StringValue" is not defined.
I'm using proto3 syntax. What am I missing?
OK.
I needed:import "google/protobuf/wrappers.proto";
and, to use the fully qualified google.protobuf.StringValue
I'm trying to use Google protobuf and i 'm having the next descriptions:
message.proto file:
message Request {
required int32 id = 1;
optional string value = 2;
}
service.proto file:
import "message.proto";
service Service {
rpc request (Request) returns (bool);
}
I'm trying to generate c++ sources and getting an error:
$ protoc service.proto --cpp_out=/tmp/proto/build
service.proto:4:40: Expected message type.
Do i have to return user-defined types only? Are primitive (like bool or string) supported? Can i use primitive types as service method argument (instead of Request in my example)?
No, you cannot use a primitive type as either the request or response. You must use a message type.
This is important because a message type can be extended later, in case you decide you want to add a new parameter or return some additional data.
If you want to return a primitive type, wrap it in a message and return it:
message Name {
string name = 1;
}
In case you don't want to return anything, void I mean, you can just create an empty message:
message Void {}
message Name {
string name = 1;
}
..
service MyService{
rpc MyFunc(Name) returns (Void);
}
You can return scalar datatypes like bool, int, etc by making use of wrappers.proto
service.proto file:
import "message.proto";
import "google/protobuf/wrappers.proto";
service Service {
rpc request (Request) returns (.google.protobuf.BoolValue);
}