We are using IntelliJ idea in order to develop our product.
till now, we saved the iml/ipr files in a version control in order to share the same configuration among developers (and also between different versions of our product).
however, since idea changes those iml files a lot, it is an exhausted task to resolve its conflicts, and actually feels a bit wrong.
Moreover, idea 15 is no longer checks-out iml/ipr automatically.
I tried the maven-idea-plugin which suppose to generate the iml/ipr based on the pom.xml and it looks promising (except for some minor issues) but it's obsolete and there many stackoverflow posts advise against it.
I also undestand that the "correct way" to load our project is by loading the e pom.xml directly in idea.
The problem with that loading the pom.xml is that each user has to reconfigure idea (such as exclude directories, set the run configuration, plugins, maven version, JDK location etc.)
every time he download the code from the version control, which happens quite often.
So, my question is what is the best way to use intellij idea with our project.
my goal is that once a developer download the code he will be able run idea without manually configure a thing.
Thanks,
Meir
I am using Intellij 15.0.3 Community edition.
In our current project we do not add *.iml to Git.
For shure we do add pom.xml to Git.
I did not add any special plugins or configure idea in the way you described
(such as exclude directories, set the run configuration, plugins, maven version, JDK location etc.)
So I am using Idea out of the box, only the plugin 'Maven integration' is activated. I initially cloned the Git repository in a new folder.
In Idea I choosed File| New | 'Project from existing sources '
and selected the folder with the pom.xml.
Thats all, works perfectly. I can build in Idea or on the command line.
I can use Git in Idea or on the command line.
Everything works perfect.
So I can asure you that its absolutely possible without having *.iml under version controle.
Related
I had a NoClassDefFoundError problem with some test, launched from IntelliJ. In order to repair the situation, I had to make several changes in many poms of the project - adding new packages and excluding some old ones for to escape the overlapping of them. Also, I reapired the situation with different versions. But the situation did not improve. Again, some package, declared in pom, was not found where it should be.
I refreshed the maven repository by
mvn -e clean install -U
, as is advised in https://stackoverflow.com/a/9697970/715269 - so old and upvoted answer, that it surely looks as Santa.
The problem remained unchanged.
I output the maven map. It was correct and it contained all needed.
I looked at the list of the External Libraries of the project. It was the old uncorrected list of overlapping jars with same names and different versions, and without good packages I added just now, and well seen in maven tree output!
Already hapless,
I reimported packages in IntelliJ
by:
Ctrl+Shift+A, Reimport All Maven Projects.
Ho! The list of libraries got repaired. And the problem, mentioned in subj, disappeared.
The question is: How it could happen, that the same project has that very pom for everything, but gets packages differently being launched in maven and in IntelliJ?
I know about that feature "delegate IDE build to Maven". And I keep it turned off. But I am NOT talking about the different SW for building. Whether they are different or not, they should be up to the actual pom's. And whereas maven, if turned off from the automatic building won't know about changes in poms, IntelliJ KNOWS about them. It could have jars up to pom, or up to maven - it has sense, but it simply has some old rubbish. Was there some deep thought under that construction?
Every time you manually change the pom.xml file, including the dependencies you need to load these changes into IDE. IDE does it on Reload from Maven action. See also Import Maven dependencies.
Intellij doesn't use maven to bulid and run a project except you are delegating build and run action to maven:
Since, IDEA doen't really use maven to run and build, it uses the pom.xml to import the project structure and "tries" to build the project the same way was maven does.
Actually, there are quite a few differences between these to build processes.
Generating sources or filtering resources (don't know if this is still an issue) aren't done during building the project with Intellij IDEA.
In case you are using code generation you have to build the project via maven first and then - when all the resouces are filtered and additional sources are generated - you are able to run, debug aso. the project with Inellij IDEA.
That's an important thing to be aware of and that's the reason why maven and IntelliJ IDEA project structures might get out of sync.
You can enable the "Reload project after changes in build scripts" feature and select the Any changes checkbox to keep your project structure updated:
Why should you disable this feature anyway
If you are working on a build file (gradle or maven is not important) reloading the structure on any change can be very anoying. It's cpu intense, dependcies are fetched aso.
Therefore, I prefer to reload project structure only in case of an external change. This happens when pulling an updated version of the build file for example.
I am using a dependency and I have some issues with it.
I could download the sources and include it as part of my project and then start modifying the source to help me debug my issue.
However, is there an easier way to do this, using maven ? I have the source-jars downloaded but I am not sure if I can then use these source jars and modify the code as well ?
I could in theory unbar the sources and add them to my source build path, but is there an easier way to accomplish this ?
I am using maven and IntelliJ.
Are you able to get a successful build of the dependency you're having issues with (in it's own project?).
If so, change the version, e.g. 1.2.3-CUSTOM-1, make the improvements, rebuild, and use it as a proper maven depdendency with <version>1.2.3-CUSTOM-1</version>.
This might seem a lot of work, but it's not really - you end up with a properly versioned jar.... having a "hacked" version of 1.2.3 jar is asking for all sorts of problems later.
On the plus side, you can share and deploy the -CUSTOM-1 jar if you need to, and you can keep versioning -CUSTOM-2, etc.
This is the "proper way" I would say.
As Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen wrote, source jars are read-only. You can setup debugger breakpoints in them, but you can't "write" in them
Either unjar the sourced jar or if you know it came from a git release tag, clone the original repository and checkout the correct tag
Make sure its sources compile
Bump up the version in case you know you are going to hack the source
On the right pane, use Maven projects / Plus icon to add sources and use the "m" Execute goal icon to build the sources in IDEA :
I am debugging code in Intellij. I use maven to build the project and there are various versions of the project sitting in the local .m2 repository. Intellij keeps on picking the old version of the code from the previous snapshot of the project when I start debugging. How do I make IntelliJ debug the latest code from the local repository?
You can tell Intellij 2016 to ask you each time which source code to step through.
File->Settings->Debugger
Show alternative source switcher
Try removing .jar and .war files that contain your code from your ~/.m2/repository/
For me the issue is that I built something and it is now registered in Maven under what Maven considers a newer version, but isn't what I was currently working on. I compiled, say, version "2.1" to debug something and then went back to working on "sand-box-idea-SNAPSHOT". I keep thinking why isn't Intellij picking up my latest sand box change but it's because it's deferring to the Maven version 2.1 which Maven assumes is better than 'sand-box-SNAPSHOT'.
It may be that you have some plug-ins interfering with IntelliJ's build process. I know that the Google Protocol Buffers Plugin can cause my Intellij to be unable to detect dirty classes that need to be re-compiled.
I've met similar behavior, maybe it can help you :-)
I developed app (using maven) and during the time I change output packaging from jar to war. Maven repository than contained both versions, jar and war, because maven does not remove old jar when you change it. As project pointed to mvn repository, it still used old reference to jar but new version within war was updated.
I was really upset as maven compilation and tests worked fine but Idea used me old version. I've had rebuild idea project and it worked later fine.
I have seen this very recently after upgrading from IDEA 13 to IDEA 14. It seems like launching configurations created in IDEA 13 are no longer automatically triggering a mvn package prior to launch.
In order to fix this I manually added a mvn goal in the "Before Launch" dialog.
We are using maven for building the project. It's legacy and huge one.
We newly added few .keystore files to it's resources folder.
The problem is, once the build is done, the .keystore files are getting tampered [may be maven is trying to replace/search for some placeholders]. Since it's legacy one, the project structure is so much messed up and we don't have separate distributions or no other choice but to go with plain build.
What I want is, tell maven to copy these sort of files without touching them and keeping the build as usual like before.
Between, there's no explicit is mentioned in pom.xml, tried to doing with that as per this http://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-resources-plugin/examples/include-exclude.html but it's messing up the project build.
I don't want to tamper the build, since it's legacy and huge one. We are using Ant plugin
Just switch off filtering for the respective <resource/> or add an <exclude/> for it.
After going through lot of sources, Found the solution http://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-resources-plugin/examples/binaries-filtering.html
Thanks :)
(first, I admit, I have no love for maven/m2eclipse, but it wouldn't be that bad if I could figure out how to overcome these issues)
I am using maven/m2eclipse. m2eclipse is the only good way I know of to suck in the maven jars. Some of these may not have solutions(but I am hoping to be surprised). Maybe solving #9 solves them all?
ISSUES
When I run "mvn clean package", I am dead in the water as far as running a unit test in eclipse while maven is building as I LOVE to multitask but maven prevents me here. How to get around this?
I move eclipse to point to eclipsegen/classes but then the unit tests are still using the classes in target/classes so it's not using my latest code that I just edited in eclipse and debugging is not lining up and it's stepping on blank lines that don't have code.
If I just slightly touch the pom.xml, bam, it builds when I don't really want it to and turning of automatic builds did not seem to help.
On top of #3, I get random pom builds downloading jars which just freezes eclipse from doing anything why the jars are being downloaded(I am a bit multitasker so this frustrates me to no end)
If I want to modify or do something really custom I need, the answer is usually create a java plugin but this then would require me to create another source control project with another automated build making sure the build tags all versions so we can reproduce issues with certain versions. (in ant, I just modify the xml to do custom stuff).
(I hear there is a bug open for 5 years on this one). global exclusions because people on our project keep breaking stuff when they include new things that depend on log4j and sucking that library in breaks us so we want to globally exclude it so people stop breaking the project when adding new things (IVY has global exclusions, why doesn't maven!!!!)
The xml code for generation from an xsd in maven is about 2-3 times the code of doing it in ant. Why is this? That really shouldn't be the case I think.
Running my unit test says xxxx-12.0.8-SNAPSHOT is missing but in my pom.xml it clearly says 12.0.9-SNAPSHOT not .8. ie. m2eclipse gets into some weird state and I get screwed wasting yet more time because someone selected maven
(I don't like IvyDE for the same reasons I don't like m2eclipse). In maven, is there any way like in Ivy to say on a build MOVE ALL jars into target/lib so that I can uninstall m2eclipse(if maven had this one feature, I think all my problems might go away)....That IS AN Ivy feature that rocks by the way!!!!
NOTE: I just realized that uninstalling m2eclipse and running "mvn eclipse:clean eclipse:eclipse" is not really an option since on this project I had to import 30 projects. I think on single projects, that is a great solution.
Is there no way like ant to log the command that was run for debugging purposes? ( in maven how to log the command that was run? )
I should really look into gradle(I hear it's best of maven and ant) as the theory of maven sounded great but you can tell there was a lot of controversy over it(which usually indicates a bad tool). Good tools that really help typically do have some controversy, but not as much as maven has had so it makes me think twice as I don't want to screw the guy who takes over my project(and I know ant will work). Many people I think don't even consider that. They think "I am fine, so why won't the next guy be fine".
Any ideas on how to fix the above issues?
About #9, if you have 2 alternatives :
Execute
mvn dependency:copy-dependencies
See http://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-dependency-plugin/copy-dependencies-mojo.html for customization options. You'll have to set your Eclipse classpath manually to point to the newly copied jars.
Use JBoss Tools JDT Extensions to get the "Materialize Library" feature (see http://docs.jboss.org/tools/whatsnew/core/core-news-3.3.0.M4.html). You'll basically just have to right-click on the Maven Classpath library, select a destination folder, select (and rename) the jars you want, and you'll get a m2e-free project in Eclipse (still a valid Maven project in command line though).
You can install JBoss Tools JDT Extensions from http://download.jboss.org/jbosstools/updates/development/indigo/
Disclaimer: I like Maven and M2Eclipse, and I have not experienced any of the issues that you mention. In general, M2Eclipse does not get in the way much for the way I'm working.
One thing that might help is disabling the Maven Builder for the projects (right-click the project, select "Properties", then "Builders"). This will get rid of many of the issues you're complaining about.
One other thing that might help you (and comes close to #9 on your list: Uninstall M2Eclipse and use mvn eclipse:eclipse, which will generate Eclipse .project and .classpath files, which include all dependencies as Eclipse project dependencies. Whenever you add or change dependencies, you will have to run mvn eclipse:eclipse again. Give this a try...
Although it does sound like a faster PC would solve some of your issues I do agree that the m2eclipse plugin sucks (although it sucks a little less since eclipse indigo). Because of this I switched to using Intellij for a while but I switched back to eclipse after a month (for me, eclipse is still the best in spite of m2eclipse).
I use m2eclipse to be able to work in eclipse but nothing more. All my maven builds (package, install, whatever) I run with maven itself (command line) simply because there have been too many occasions where the result was different (working in one, not in the other and and maven was always correct).
So, sorry, no direct answers to your questions, just some tips:
1) do it outside eclipse
2) stick to maven standards (target/classes); that will make your life a lot easier
6) using dependency management in a parent pom might help a bit
8) if you get the same issue when running from command line then there is a problem in your pom (resolve using mvn dependency:tree), if not, see 1
9) maybe assembly is an option here but I would not recommend your approach