fast loading of large hash table in Perl - performance

Question

I have about 30 text files with the structure
wordleft1|wordright1
wordleft2|wordright2
wordleft3|wordright3
...
The total size of the files is about 1 GB with about 32 million lines of word combinations.
I tried a few approaches to load them as fast as possible and store the combinations within a hash
$hash{$wordleft} = $wordright
Opening file by file and reading line by line takes about 42 seconds. I then store the hash with the Storable module
store \%hash, $filename
Loading the data again
$hashref = retrieve $filename
reduces the time to about 28 seconds. I use a fast SSD drive and a fast CPU and have enough RAM to hold all the data (it takes about 7 GB).
I'm searching for a faster way to load this data into the RAM (I can't keep it there for a few reasons).

Answer 1

You could try using Dan Bernstein's CDB file format using a tied hash, which will require minimal code change. You may need to install CDB_File. On my laptop, the cdb file is opened very quickly and I can do about 200-250k lookups per second. Here is an example script to create/use/benchmark a cdb:
test_cdb.pl
#!/usr/bin/env perl
use warnings;
use strict;
use Benchmark qw(:all) ;
use CDB_File 'create';
use Time::HiRes qw( gettimeofday tv_interval );
scalar #ARGV or die "usage: $0 number_of_keys seconds_to_benchmark\n";
my ($size) = $ARGV[0] || 1000;
my ($seconds) = $ARGV[1] || 10;
my $t0;
tic();
# Create CDB
my ($file, %data);
%data = map { $_ => 'something' } (1..$size);
print "Created $size element hash in memory\n";
toc();
$file = 'data.cdb';
create %data, $file, "$file.$$";
my $bytes = -s $file;
print "Created data.cdb [ $size keys and values, $bytes bytes]\n";
toc();
# Read from CDB
my $c = tie my %h, 'CDB_File', 'data.cdb' or die "tie failed: $!\n";
print "Opened data.cdb as a tied hash.\n";
toc();
timethese( -1 * $seconds, {
'Pick Random Key' => sub { int rand $size },
'Fetch Random Value' => sub { $h{ int rand $size }; },
});
tic();
print "Fetching Every Value\n";
for (0..$size) {
no warnings; # Useless use of hash element
$h{ $_ };
}
toc();
sub tic {
$t0 = [gettimeofday];
}
sub toc {
my $t1 = [gettimeofday];
my $elapsed = tv_interval ( $t0, $t1);
$t0 = $t1;
print "==> took $elapsed seconds\n";
}
Output ( 1 million keys, tested over 10 seconds )
./test_cdb.pl 1000000 10
Created 1000000 element hash in memory
==> took 2.882813 seconds
Created data.cdb [ 1000000 keys and values, 38890944 bytes]
==> took 2.333624 seconds
Opened data.cdb as a tied hash.
==> took 0.00015 seconds
Benchmark: running Fetch Random Value, Pick Random Key for at least 10 CPU seconds...
Fetch Random Value: 10 wallclock secs (10.46 usr + 0.01 sys = 10.47 CPU) # 236984.72/s (n=2481230)
Pick Random Key: 9 wallclock secs (10.11 usr + 0.02 sys = 10.13 CPU) # 3117208.98/s (n=31577327)
Fetching Every Value
==> took 3.514183 seconds
Output ( 10 million keys, tested over 10 seconds )
./test_cdb.pl 10000000 10
Created 10000000 element hash in memory
==> took 44.72331 seconds
Created data.cdb [ 10000000 keys and values, 398890945 bytes]
==> took 25.729652 seconds
Opened data.cdb as a tied hash.
==> took 0.000222 seconds
Benchmark: running Fetch Random Value, Pick Random Key for at least 10 CPU seconds...
Fetch Random Value: 14 wallclock secs ( 9.65 usr + 0.35 sys = 10.00 CPU) # 209811.20/s (n=2098112)
Pick Random Key: 12 wallclock secs (10.40 usr + 0.02 sys = 10.42 CPU) # 2865335.22/s (n=29856793)
Fetching Every Value
==> took 38.274356 seconds

Answer 2

It sounds like you do have a good use case for wanting an in-memory perl hash.
For faster storing/retrieving, I would recommend Sereal (Sereal::Encoder/Sereal::Decoder). If your disk storage is slow, you may even want to enable Snappy compression.