sed/awk between two patterns in a file: pattern 1 set by a variable from lines of a second file; pattern 2 designated by a specified charcacter - bash

Question

I have two files. One file contains a pattern that I want to match in a second file. I want to use that pattern to print between that pattern (included) up to a specified character (not included) and then concatenate into a single output file.
For instance,
File_1:
a
c
d
and File_2:
>a
MEEL
>b
MLPK
>c
MEHL
>d
MLWL
>e
MTNH
I have been using variations of this loop:
while read $id;
do
sed -n "/>$id/,/>/{//!p;}" File_2;
done < File_1
hoping to obtain something like the following output:
>a
MEEL
>c
MEHL
>d
MLWL
But have had no such luck. I have played around with grep/fgrep awk and sed and between the three cannot seem to get the right (or any output). Would someone kindly point me in the right direction?

Answer 1

Try:
$ awk -F'>' 'FNR==NR{a[$1]; next} NF==2{f=$2 in a} f' file1 file2
>a
MEEL
>c
MEHL
>d
MLWL
How it works
-F'>'
This sets the field separator to >.
FNR==NR{a[$1]; next}
While reading in the first file, this creates a key in array a for every line in file file.
NF==2{f=$2 in a}
For every line in file 2 that has two fields, this sets variable f to true if the second field is a key in a or false if it is not.
f
If f is true, print the line.

Answer 2

A plain (GNU) sed solution. Files are read only once. It is assumed that characters in File_1 needn't to be quoted in sed expression.
pat=$(sed ':a; $!{N;ba;}; y/\n/|/' File_1)
sed -E -n ":a; /^>($pat)/{:b; p; n; /^>/ba; bb}" File_2
Explanation:
The first call to sed generates a regular expression to be used in the second call to sed and stores it in the variable pat. The aim is to avoid reading repeatedly the entire File_2 for each line of File_1. It just "slurps" the File_1 and replaces new-line characters with | characters. So the sample File_1 becomes a string with the value a|c|d. The regular expression a|c|d matches if at least one of the alternatives (a, b, c for this example) matches (this is a GNU sed extension).
The second sed expression, ":a; /^>($pat)/{:b; p; n; /^>/ba; bb}", could be converted to pseudo code like this:
begin:
read next line (from File_2) or quit on end-of-file
label_a:
if line begins with `>` followed by one of the alternatives in `pat` then
label_b:
print the line
read next line (from File_2) or quit on end-of-file
if line begins with `>` goto label_a else goto label_b
else goto begin

Answer 3

Let me try to explain why your approach does not work well:
You need to say while read id instead of while read $id.
The sed command />$id/,/>/{//!p;} will exclude the lines which start
with >.
Then you might want to say something like:
while read id; do
sed -n "/^>$id/{N;p}" File_2
done < File_1
Output:
>a
MEEL
>c
MEHL
>d
MLWL
But the code above is inefficient because it reads File_2 as many times as the count of the id's in File_1.
Please try the elegant solution by John1024 instead.

Answer 4

If ed is available, and since the shell is involve.
#!/usr/bin/env bash
mapfile -t to_match < file1.txt
ed -s file2.txt <<-EOF
g/\(^>[${to_match[*]}]\)/;/^>/-1p
q
EOF
It will only run ed once and not every line that has the pattern, that matches from file1. Like say if you have a to z from file1,ed will not run 26 times.
Requires bash4+ because of mapfile.
How it works
mapfile -t to_match < file1.txt
Saves the entry/value from file1 in an array named to_match
ed -s file2.txt point ed to file2 with the -s flag which means don't print info about the file, same info you get with wc file
<<-EOF A here document, shell syntax.
g/\(^>[${to_match[*]}]\)/;/^>/-1p
g means search the whole file aka global.
( ) capture group, it needs escaping because ed only supports BRE, basic regular expression.
^> If line starts with a > the ^ is an anchor which means the start.
[ ] is a bracket expression match whatever is inside of it, in this case the value of the array "${to_match[*]}"
; Include the next address/pattern
/^>/ Match a leading >
-1 go back one line after the pattern match.
p print whatever was matched by the pattern.
q quit ed