Question on how to remove a Visual Studio Breakpoint - visual-studio

Question

Let's say I have 10 breakpoints and I want to clear one but not the other 9.
If I toggle the breakpoint on the one that I want to remove, it is resurrected the next time I restart the app. The only way that I know to permanently get rid of it is to clear ALL the breakpoints, which I would rather not do since I would have to reset the other 9.
Is there a better way in ANY VS version?

Answer 1

The breakpoint's state is only temporarily altered if you change it while you're debugging and it's a multi-bound breakpoint. This is actually a feature of Visual Studio. See the last post here.
If you're not debugging, and you remove it, then it won't come back. Alternately, as others have suggested, you can remove it permanently using the breakpoint management window.

Answer 2

Hitting Ctrl+Alt+B will bring up a list of all breakpoints in your solution, from which you can manually toggle or delete them with a right-click.

Answer 3

Open the breakpoints window (Debug -> Windows -> Breakpoints), select the breakpoint you want to delete and press the delete key (or click the cross icon).
If you are toggling the breakpoint using the keyboard (F9 using my keyboard mappings), it sometimes doesn't remove it properly. Pressing F9 again will remove it fully (this is due to the breakpoint being set on multiple threads and toggling it whilst debugging only disables the main breakpoint but not the ones for the other threads).

Answer 4

If you want to delete a breakpoint with F9 or by clicking the red glyph, that breakpoint needs to be childless. Otherwise, the breakpoint will persist through its surviving child breakpoints. (Child breakpoints can form when you set breakpoints during debug.)
You could check this question, " Disable/remove child Breakpoints? ", for a macro to remove child breakpoints. I think you shouldn't call the macro during a Debug session though, as this might result in your breakpoints to not be hit.

Answer 5

The following code can be used as a macro to remove the breakpoint on the currently selected line. (Note that Visual Studio automatically selects the line of a breakpoint when it is hit.)
Sub RemoveBreakPoint()
Dim debugger As EnvDTE.Debugger = DTE.Debugger
Dim children As EnvDTE.Breakpoints
Dim sel As Integer = DTE.ActiveDocument.Selection.ActivePoint.Line
For Each bp As EnvDTE.Breakpoint In debugger.Breakpoints
If bp.File <> DTE.ActiveDocument.FullName Then
Continue For
End If
For Each bpc As EnvDTE.Breakpoint In bp.Children
If bpc.FileLine = sel Then
bp.Delete()
Exit For
End If
Next
Next
End Sub
You can assign a keyboard shortcut to it for easy access. (Tools > Options > Environment > Keyboard.)

Answer 6

Cross-post from https://stackoverflow.com/a/35935390/257470 , but it's even more relevant here.
There are some answers here, but in my opinion proposed actions are distractive to use during debugging (I don't want to lose my focus).
My flow with sticky breakpoints during breakpoints is as follows:
During debug, DISABLE the breakpoint instead of removing it.
Possible ways of disabling a breakpoint:
hover with cursor and click the two cycle icon;
or use context menu on it;
or keyboard short-cut CTRL+F9.
Later on, during development, I remove a disabled breakpoint when I see one.
PS. It's also a good practice to remove all breakpoints once in a while.