What is the difference between PS1 and PROMPT_COMMAND? - bash

Question

While taking a look at this awesome thread I noticed that some examples use
PS1="Blah Blah Blah"
and some use
PROMPT_COMMAND="Blah Blah Blah"
(and some use both) when setting the prompt in a Bash shell. What is the difference between the two? A Stack Overflow search and even a bit of broader Google searching aren't getting me results, so even a link to the right place to look for the answer would be appreciated.

Answer 1

PROMPT_COMMAND can contain ordinary Bash statements whereas the PS1 variable can also contain the special characters, such as '\h' for hostname, in the variable.
For example, here is my Bash prompt that uses both PROMPT_COMMAND and PS1. The Bash code in PROMPT_COMMAND works out what Git branch you might be in and displays that at the prompt, along with the exit status of the last run process, hostname and basename of the pwd.
The variable RET stores the return value of the last executed program. This is convenient to see if there was an error and the error code of the last program I ran in the terminal. Note the outer ' surrounding the entire PROMPT_COMMAND expression. It includes PS1 so that this variable is reevaluated each time the PROMPT_COMMAND variable is evaluated.
PROMPT_COMMAND='RET=$?;\
BRANCH="";\
ERRMSG="";\
if [[ $RET != 0 ]]; then\
ERRMSG=" $RET";\
fi;\
if git branch &>/dev/null; then\
BRANCH=$(git branch 2>/dev/null | grep \* | cut -d " " -f 2);\
fi;
PS1="$GREEN\u#\h $BLUE\W $CYAN$BRANCH$RED$ERRMSG \$ $LIGHT_GRAY";'
Example output looks like this in a non-Git directory:
sashan#dhcp-au-122 Documents $ false
sashan#dhcp-au-122 Documents 1 $
And in a Git directory you see the branch name:
sashan#dhcp-au-122 rework mybranch $
Update
After reading the comments and Bob's answer, I think that writing it as he describes is better. It's more maintainable than what I originally wrote above, where the PS1 variable is set inside the PROMPT_COMMAND, which itself is a super complicated string that is evaluated at runtime by Bash.
It works, but it's more complicated than it needs to be. To be fair, I wrote that PROMPT_COMMAND for myself about 10 years ago and it worked and didn't think too much about it.
For those curious as to how I've amended my things, I've basically put the code for the PROMPT_COMMAND in a separate file (as Bob described) and then echo the string that I intend to be PS1:
GREEN="\[\033[0;32m\]"
CYAN="\[\033[0;36m\]"
RED="\[\033[0;31m\]"
PURPLE="\[\033[0;35m\]"
BROWN="\[\033[0;33m\]"
LIGHT_GRAY="\[\033[0;37m\]"
LIGHT_BLUE="\[\033[1;34m\]"
LIGHT_GREEN="\[\033[1;32m\]"
LIGHT_CYAN="\[\033[1;36m\]"
LIGHT_RED="\[\033[1;31m\]"
LIGHT_PURPLE="\[\033[1;35m\]"
YELLOW="\[\033[1;33m\]"
WHITE="\[\033[1;37m\]"
RESTORE="\[\033[0m\]" #0m restores to the terminal's default colour
if [ -z $SCHROOT_CHROOT_NAME ]; then
SCHROOT_CHROOT_NAME=" "
fi
BRANCH=""
ERRMSG=""
RET=$1
if [[ $RET != 0 ]]; then
ERRMSG=" $RET"
fi
if which git &>/dev/null; then
BRANCH=$(git branch 2>/dev/null | grep \* | cut -d " " -f 2)
else
BRANCH="(git not installed)"
fi
echo "${GREEN}\u#\h${SCHROOT_CHROOT_NAME}${BLUE}\w \
${CYAN}${BRANCH}${RED}${ERRMSG} \$ $RESTORE"
And in my .bashrc file:
function prompt_command {
RET=$?
export PS1=$(~/.bash_prompt_command $RET)
}
PROMPT_DIRTRIM=3
export PROMPT_COMMAND=prompt_command

Answer 2

From the GNU Bash documentation page (Bash Reference Manual):
PROMPT_COMMAND
If set, the value is interpreted as a command to execute before
the printing of each primary prompt ($PS1).
I never used it, but I could have used this back when I only had sh.

Answer 3

The difference is that PS1 is the actual prompt string used, and PROMPT_COMMAND is a command that is executed just before the prompt. If you want the simplest, most flexible way of building a prompt, try this:
Put this in your .bashrc file:
function prompt_command {
export PS1=$(~/bin/bash_prompt)
}
export PROMPT_COMMAND=prompt_command
Then write a script (Bash, Perl, or Ruby: your choice), and place it in file ~/bin/bash_prompt.
The script can use any information it likes to construct a prompt. This is much simpler, IMO, because you don't have to learn the somewhat baroque substitution language that was developed just for the PS1 variable.
You might think that you could do the same by simply setting PROMPT_COMMAND directly to ~/bin/bash_prompt, and setting PS1 to the empty string.
This at first appears to work, but you soon discover that the readline code expects PS1 to be set to the actual prompt, and when you scroll backwards in history, things get messed up as a result.
This workaround causes PS1 to always reflect the latest prompt (since the function sets the actual PS1 variable used by the invoking instance of the shell), and this makes readline and command history work fine.

Answer 4

From man bash:
PROMPT_COMMAND
If set, the value is executed as a command prior to issuing each primary prompt.
PS1
The value of this parameter is expanded (see PROMPTING below) and used as the primary prompt string. The default value is ''\s-\v\$ ''.
If you simply want to set the prompt string, using PS1 alone is enough:
PS1='user \u on host \h$ '
If you want to do something else just before printing the prompt, use PROMPT_COMMAND. For example, if you want to sync cached writes to disk, you can write:
PROMPT_COMMAND='sync'

Answer 5

Yeah, so to try to really nail this down:
PROMPT_COMMAND is a handy Bash convenience variable/function, but there is, strictly speaking, nothing that cannot also be done using PS1 alone, correct?
I mean, if one wants to set another variable with scope outside the prompt: depending on the shell, that variable would probably need to be declared first outside $PS1 or (worst case) one might have to get fancy with something waiting on a FIFO prior to calling $PS1 (and armed again at the end of $PS1); the \u \h might cause some trouble, particularly if you're using some fancy regex; but otherwise: one can accomplish anything PROMPT_COMMAND can by using command substitution within $PS1 (and, maybe in corner cases, explicit subshells)?
Right?

Answer 6

The difference is that
if you output an incomplete line from PROMPT_COMMAND, it will screw your Bash prompt
PS1 substitutes \H and friends
PROMPT_COMMAND runs its contents, and PS1 uses its contents as the prompt.
PS1 does variable expansion and command substitution at each prompt. There isn't any need to use PROMPT_COMMAND to assign a value to PS1 or to run arbitrary code. You can easily do export PS1='$(uuidgen) $RANDOM' once in file .bash_profile. Just use single quotes.

Answer 7

I spent so much time on this I just wanted to share what worked for me. I looked at a lot of the SO posts about PROMPT_COMMAND and PS1 and tried many combinations of single quotes, double quotes, calling functions... I could not get the prompt to update each time without printing control characters or the literal expanded but not processed prompt string, or without just setting PS1 in PROMPT_COMMAND as we are advised not to do. My problem was setting variables (colors) that contained control characters; these had to be hard-coded after the variable name in PS1. PROMPT_COMMAND is set to a function that sets variables and they are used (escaped) in a double-quoted PS1 string. This is for a powerline-style prompt that changes colors with each command.
icon1=#unicode powerline char like
#these: https://github.com/ryanoasis/powerline-extra-symbols#glyphs
icon2=#same
#array of ANSI colors. 2 for rgb mode then the rgb values
#then 'm' without '\]' control character. these are from
#the solarized theme https://ethanschoonover.com/solarized/
declare -a colors=(
"2;220;50;47m"
"2;203;75;22m"
"2;181;137;0m"
"2;133;153;0m"
"2;42;161;152m"
"2;38;139;210m"
"2;108;113;196m"
"2;211;54;130m"
"2;0;43;54m"
"2;7;54;66m"
"2;88;110;117m"
"2;101;123;131m"
"2;131;148;150m"
"2;147;161;161m"
)
#outside of vars set in PROMPT_COMMAND it's ok to have control chars
LEN=${#colors[#]}
BG="\[\e[48;"#set bg color
FG="\[\e[38;"#set fg color
TRANSP="1m\]"#transparency
BASE2="2;238;232;213m\]"#fg (text) color
myfunc(){
RAND=$(($RANDOM % $LEN))
COLOR1=${colors[$RAND]}
COLOR2=${colors[($RAND + 1) % $LEN]}
COLOR3=${colors[($RAND + 2) % $LEN]}
}
PROMPT_COMMAND=myfunc
#note double quotes and escaped COLOR vars followed by hard-coded '\]' control chars
PS1="$BG$TRANSP$FG\$COLOR1\]$icon1$BG\$COLOR1\]$FG$TRANSP$BG\$COLOR1\]$FG$BASE2
[username hard-coded in unicode] $BG\$COLOR2\]$FG\$COLOR1\]$icon2$BG\$COLOR2\]$FG$BASE2
\w $BG\$COLOR3\]$FG\$COLOR2\]$icon2$BG\$COLOR3\]$FG$BASE2 [more unicode]
\[\e[0m\]$FG\$COLOR3\]$icon2\[\e[0m\] "
That ought to get you going!