Codeigniter models loaded in controller overwritten by models loaded in models - codeigniter

Question

I'm having Codeigniter object scope confusion.
Say I load a model in a controller:
$this->load->model('A');
$this->A->loadUser(123); // loads user with ID 123
// output of $this->A now shows user 123
$this->load->model('B');
$this->B->examineUser ();
// output of $this->A now shows user 345
class B extends Model
{
public function examineUser ()
{
$this->load->model('A');
$this->A->loadUser(345); // loads user with ID 345
}
}
I would have thought that $this->A would be different from $this->B->A but they are not. What is the best solution to this issue? It appears the ->load->model('A') in the examineUser () method does nothing because it was loaded in the controller. Then the call to loadUser () inside that method overwrites the stored properties of $this->A. This seems like a bugfest waiting to happen. If I needed global models, I would have use static classes. What I wanted was something scoped pretty much locally to the model object I was in.
Is there a way I can accomplish this but not go way outside of CI's normal way of operating?
Followup/related:
Where do most people put there "->load->model" calls? All at the beginning of a controller action? I figured it would be easier -- though perhaps not excellent programming from a dependency injection perspective -- to load them in the model itself (construct or each method).

Answer 1

Whenever you use the Loader Class ($this->load->), it will load the object into the main CI object. The CI object is the one you keep referring to as $this->. What you've done is load model A twice into the CI object.
Essentially, all object loaded using the Loader class goes into a single global scope. If you need two of the same type, give them different names, as per $this->load->model('A','C'). I don't know of any way around it unless you revert to using bog-standard PHP.
In my team's code, we generally load the models in the controller's constructor, then load the data to send to the view in the function, often _remap().

Answer 2

This is not how the loader works sadly. CodeIgniter implements a singleton pattern, which will check to see if the class is included, instantiated and set to $this->A then will be ignored if loaded again. Even if you are inside a model, $this->A will be referenced to the super-instance via the __get() in class Model. Alis it, or just do:
class B extends Model
{
public function examineUser ()
{
$user = new A;
$user->loadUser(345); // loads user with ID 345
}
}

Answer 3

Here's what I've decided to do, please comment if you have advice:
I've extended the CI Loader class:
<?php
class SSR_Loader extends CI_Loader
{
function __construct()
{
parent::__construct ();
}
/**
* Model Retriever
*
* Written by handerson#executiveboard.com to create and return a model instead of putting it into global $this
*
* Based on original 2.0.2 CI_Loader::model ()
*
*/
function get_model($model)
{
if (empty ($model))
{
return;
}
$name = basename ($model);
if (!in_array($name, $this->_ci_models, TRUE))
{
$this->model ($model);
}
$name = ucfirst($name);
return new $name ();
}
}
Do any CI guru's see a problem with that before I invest time in changing my code a bit to accept the return obj, ala:
// in a controller:
public function test ($user_id=null)
{
$this->_logged_in_user = $this->load->get_model ('/db/users');
$this->_viewed_user = $this->load->get_model ('/db/users');
$this->_logged_in_user->load($this->session->userdata ('user.id'));
$this->_viewed_user->load($user_id);
}
I could also do private $_logged_in_user to make it available in the controller but positively force it to be limited to just the current controller and not spill anywhere else, or I could just do $_logged_in_user = $this->load->get_model ('/db/users'); and limit it to just the current method, which is probably what I'll do more often.
This seems like a pretty straightforward way to "fix" this issue (I say "fix" b/c it's not really a bug, just a way of doing things that I think is a bad idea). Anyone see any flaws?