I want to add Oomph's MacMapKit as a framework to my Xcode (v4.3.2) project. I've already added a couple of standard Apple frameworks to my project (which was a breeze) but this is new to me and offers a rather intimidating array of settings and options.
Before I start clicking around in my project/build settings, I would like to ask:
(1) Is the MacMapKit framework in its current state technically speaking
"a framework"? From this post I gather that a Cocoa framework
requires some special preparation with Xcode and as such MacMapKit
would possibly not qualify.
(2) What would be the best way to add MacMapKit (source and resource files) in its current state to
my own project? I've read about various approaches which all seem to
assume you have an actual framework, which I'm not sure MacMapKit
qualifies for (see question 1).
This MacMapKit has several targets. One of the targets is the MapKit Framework.
You need to build this target first in order to use it like a common framework.
So just select the "MapKitFramework" target from the schemes list and build.
Related
I'm making stuff for IOS, Mac, and WatchOS - I have certain common functionality that is more about me and the way I program than about whatever it is I'm programming - helper methods etc
What I'd like is to have a "Common" framework or library in my app which is included into every other library. I understand I need a separate target for each of ios, macos, watchos, but I can't figure out how to set it up.
I can create a framework - and it comes with a target - I can duplicate that target and change stuff, but I don't seem to be able to change it from IOS to macos for instance. I can create a separate macos target, but then I can't seem to be able to change where it gets the code from.
Essentially in my source tree I want a single directory:
Common
and then have target frameworks CommonIOS, CommonMacOs, CommonWatchOS - that all just compile "Common". How do I achieve that?
You're misusing the word "framework". All you want is to keep some source code as a library that all your projects and targets, no matter what system they'll be compiled for, can use. You are describing a Swift package.
[Note: This question is, I think, dealing with the consequences of what prompted this never answered question]
I have a workspace that includes both a framework target and an application target. When I run the application many messages of the following form come to the console: Class "C" is implemented in both "Binary1" and "Binary2". One of the two will be used. Which one is undefined.
Here is a sampling of those messages:
objc[65093]: Class FIRAIdentifiers is implemented in both /Users/Robert/Library/Developer/Xcode/DerivedData/GenerationOfNow-bmsridmvnbtgfiduzqqomicqvsns/Build/Products/Debug-iphonesimulator/VerticonsToolbox.framework/VerticonsToolbox (0x10804bd20) and /Users/Robert/Library/Developer/CoreSimulator/Devices/33628599-9570-4784-B324-DAC383435F75/data/Containers/Bundle/Application/26411B80-FB71-44E9-AA64-05FEF20B9F08/GenerationOfNow.app/GenerationOfNow (0x10674a150). One of the two will be used. Which one is undefined.
objc[65093]: Class FIRASearchAdReporter is implemented in both /Users/Robert/Library/Developer/Xcode/DerivedData/GenerationOfNow-bmsridmvnbtgfiduzqqomicqvsns/Build/Products/Debug-iphonesimulator/VerticonsToolbox.framework/VerticonsToolbox (0x10804bd70) and /Users/Robert/Library/Developer/CoreSimulator/Devices/33628599-9570-4784-B324-DAC383435F75/data/Containers/Bundle/Application/26411B80-FB71-44E9-AA64-05FEF20B9F08/GenerationOfNow.app/GenerationOfNow (0x10674a1a0). One of the two will be used. Which one is undefined.
objc[65093]: Class FIRAZeroingWeakContainer is implemented in both /Users/Robert/Library/Developer/Xcode/DerivedData/GenerationOfNow-bmsridmvnbtgfiduzqqomicqvsns/Build/Products/Debug-iphonesimulator/VerticonsToolbox.framework/VerticonsToolbox (0x10804bde8) and /Users/Robert/Library/Developer/CoreSimulator/Devices/33628599-9570-4784-B324-DAC383435F75/data/Containers/Bundle/Application/26411B80-FB71-44E9-AA64-05FEF20B9F08/GenerationOfNow.app/GenerationOfNow (0x10674a218). One of the two will be used. Which one is undefined.
All of the duplicated class definitions come from Firebase frameworks which were installed into my workspace via the Pod file demonstrated in this question. Here is a screen shot of my workspace's Navigator:
Notice that both the framework target (VerticonsToolbox) and the application target (GenerationOfNow) are referencing the pods.
It seems to me that the proper way for a framework to be built is that it should not embed whatever frameworks it is linked against. It should be the responsibility of whatever application uses that framework to pull in the other dependencies. And indeed, when I examine the build phases for the framework VerticonsToolbox there is no option for specifying embedded binaries whereas there is for the application GenerationOfNow.
So, I am at a lose as to how to proceed. I suspect that what is happening is a result of the things that are put in place when pod install is executed. Can anyone advise me?
BTW: Can anyone point me to a good write up on how Xcode builds, what the various settings are, what tools there are for examining the binaries, etc? With Xcode everything is fine until it isn't and then there is this big, mysterious soup of stuff. Jeez!
I'm writing an iOS application in Swift, and I'm trying to figure out how to organize the project into separate modules. I'm using an MVVM architecture, and I want to make the Model, ViewModel, and View components separate Swift modules that make only subsets of themselves accessible to the modules that import them. The files in the View would import the ViewModel, and files in the ViewModel would import the Model. How can I accomplish this? Note that I'm not trying to create libraries that multiple applications can share. I'm just trying to enforce separation of components using modules.
EDIT: Maybe the question is, "What mechanism should I use to create modules aside from the one that comes with the initial iOS application project?"
One of the answers in "How do you use Namespaces in Swift?" https://stackoverflow.com/a/24032860/215400 says, "classes (etc) are implicitly scoped by the module (Xcode target) they are in." From that, one might conclude that targets correspond to modules and that the answer is to create separate targets within an Xcode project, but I tried that earlier, and tskulbru is saying that I need multiple Xcode projects.
Regarding multiple Xcode projects, the File > New > Project > iOS Framework & Library > Cocoa Touch Framework option didn't look right because it's supposed to be for things that use UIKit, and two of the modules I want to create shouldn't depend on UIKit. The other "Framework & Library" option, Cocoa Touch static library, isn't an option with Swift.
Another StackOverflow post mentioned using private Pods. After spending an hour working on that, I concluded that it wasn't the right solution because I shouldn't have to edit these modules in different workspaces.
This isn't possible without creating separate projects for the modules you want to create. This is because the way Swift handles namespacing.
Eonil answered this better than me: https://stackoverflow.com/a/24032860/215400
(Copy below)
Answered by SevenTenEleven in the Apple dev forum:
Namespaces are not per-file; they're per-target (based on the
"Product Module Name" build setting). So you'd end up with something
like this:
import FrameworkA
import FrameworkB
FrameworkA.foo()
All Swift declarations are considered to be part of
some module, so even when you say "NSLog" (yes, it still exists)
you're getting what Swift thinks of as "Foundation.NSLog".
Also Chris Lattner tweeted about namespacing.
Namespacing is implicit in swift, all classes (etc) are implicitly
scoped by the module (Xcode target) they are in. no class prefixes
needed
From my perspective if you want to encapsulate your components, probably you have two solutions:
Framework
Internal cocoapods
Both solutions will give you fully encapsulated modules, where you can define API that will be available in project through public keyword.
All other things will be not visible in your core project.
Managing your project will cost you a lot more time, but if you write this using SOLID principles, probably you will get more reusable code and those frameworks could be imported to other project just using import definition.
In Xcode, when I add a framework directly in Build Phases->Link Binary With Libraries, the framework appears at the root level of the project. If I drag the framework into the Frameworks group, the link to the framework appears red in Link Binary With Libraries. I have to re-drag the framework back into Link Binary with Libraries for it to appear black again. Why is it doing this? Usually moving files around in group should not result in removing it.
Is there a way to make the framework appear in the Frameworks group when adding it?
It's just a visual issue and won't actually affect the link phase. If you leave the Build Phases section and return (directly, or later), the framework's name will be black as you'd expect it to be. There's no need to re-drag or re-add a framework. In Xcode 4, there's no way to have Xcode put the framework in the correct group automatically.
The documentation for the project says just add the framework and the linker flags and you are good to go. Hours and hours of wasted time later, I have figured out that that's not true. If you do that, the project does not see the header files. You have to put the framework somewhere were the compiler will find the headers. In my case, that worked when I dropped the framework into /Developer/Library/Frameworks and then told it to recurse in searching that framework directory (do not fiddle around with the headers search directories).
Then the problem I get is that the link fails with the message:
ld: framework not found OCHamcrestIOS
I noticed that the documentation for the project says that it was updated for Xcode 4. I pulled down the binary of the framework after checking out the code and wasting a ton of time unable to build the IOS version of the framework.
The documentation is here.
I also noticed in that documentation that the cocoa instructions tell you to put a copy files phase into the build. I tried that. Didn't change the outcome.
The last time I fell into a sink hole it was because the library was C++ code. Maybe that's still the problem.
Barring a rapid solution here, I am going to go back to using STAsserts, as sickening as that prospect is, this is far, far worse.
Update: reinstalled Xcode. Still doesn't work. There are cheap ways to make this work, like add the header files to the project. Did a blog post about this that brought out a person with the same experience.
I use a number of frameworks in my projects. Some from other people and some are mine. Looking at the documentation I would suggest that the copy phase stuff is not for iOS development. So I would not do that. I downloaded the latest zip from https://github.com/jonreid/OCHamcrest and it appears to contain a ready to go iOS static library. (Not on my mac so I cannot test to confirm).
Anyway, the way I include static libs is to
Select the project (XCode 4).
Select the target I want to add the library to.
Select the Build phases tab.
Expand Link binary with Libraries.
Click the [+] button to add a framework.
Click the [Add Other ...] button and navigate to the directory containing the <lib>.framework directory and select that.
Thats all. The targets search paths will be updated to include the framework directory and the framework will be listed on the left under the project. Expanding it will show the headers.
The problem you mention sound like a couple of things. Firstly the framework not found sounds like the framework has not been included in the target. When you select the framework in the project list on the left, you should be able to see it's Target Membership displayed on the right. Check it's on for the target you are compiling.
Secondly building frameworks is not a trivial task so don't attempt it unless you have the scripts to do it. I say this because building a iOS static framework means compiling for both simulator and devices, combining the compiled lib files into a universal one, and then storing it and the header in a specific directory strucuture.
The downloaded zip from OCHamcrest though, appears to have the correct OCHamcrestiOS.framework in it. So if you store that directory somewhere and link to it using the steps I've outlined above it should work just fine.
So the solution I adopted for now, after much thrashing around, was to include the framework in the project.
Create a group inside the Xcode project called Third Party.
Link it to a folder called thirdparty.
Go to the Add Files in Xcode and pick the framework.
Drag it over to the dependencies.
Run the tests, they pass!
This is maybe preferable anyway because referencing it in /System/Library/Frameworks would present some versioning issues, and this can be setup very quickly. Furthermore, we have a continuous integration server, and having to get in there and sync versions whenever something changes is not so great.
Thanks for checking it out, Derek.