Hibernate 4 + Spring 3.2 + Transaction : One Service, Several Dao , One Method - spring

Question

I'm a beginner in hibernate 4 & Spring 3.2 stuffs.
I have read some tutorials and discussion on stack but i don't find a clear answer to my questions. And i think the best way to understand is to ask and share knowledges !
Here we go!
So you create each time a Pojo, a Dao , a Service class, with methods annotated transactionnal. That's ok. I'm using Sessionfactory to handle my transaction. I'm looking for good practices.
1- If you want to use Delete Method and Save Method from the same Service, how will you do to make it works in a same transaction. When i look at the log, each method are executed in different transactions.
This SampleServiceImpl:
#Transactional
public void save(Sample sample){
sampleDao.save(sample);
}
#Transactional
public void delete(Sample sample){
sampleDao.delete(sample);
}
// A solution could be that , but not very clean...there should be an another way, no?
#Transactional
public void action(Sample sample){
sampleDao.save(sample);
sampleDao.delete(sample);
}
2- If you want to use Delete Method and Save Method from different Services class, how will you do to make it works in a same transaction. Because each method in each service class is handled by a Transactionnal annotation. Do you create a global Service calling all subservice in one method annoted Transactional
SampleServiceImpl:
#Transactional
public void save(Sample sample){
sampleDao.save(sample);
}
ParcicipantServiceImpl
#Transactional
public void save(Participant participant){
participantDao.save(participant);
}
// A solution could be that , but not very clean...there should be an another way, no?
GlobalServiceImpl
#Transactional
public void save(Participant participant,Sample sample){
participantDao.save(participant);
sampleDao.save(sample);
}
3- And the last question but not the least .If you want to use several Methods from severals service in one global transaction. Imagine you want to fill up 5 or more table in one execution of a standalone program. How is it possible because each Service to have his proper transactional method, so each time you called this method, there is a transaction.
a- I have successfully arrive to fill up two tables in a sample transaction using Mkyong tutorial and cascade property in the mapping. So i see how to make it works for one table directly joined to one another or more tables.
b- But if you have a 3 tables Participant -> Samples -> Derived Products. How will you fill up the three tables in a same transaction.
I don't know if i'm clear. But i would appreciated some help or example on that from advanced users.
Thanks a lot for you time.

Answer 1

Your solution is fine, maybe this works if you want to using nested transactional methods(note I saw this solution couple days ago and didn't test it):
< tx:annotation-driven mode="aspectj" / >
< context:load-time-weaver aspectj-weaving="on"/ >
#Transactional
public void action(Sample sample){
save(sample);
delete(sample);
}
Transaction should propagate.
GlobalServiceImpl
#Transactional
public void save(Participant participant,Sample sample){
participantDao.save(participant);
sampleServiceImpl.save(sample);
}

Answer 2

The approch you are following is cleaner approch,
ServiceOpjects are ment to contain business logic. Hence they will always manuplate through data objects.
What we do in practise is create a another layer that uses dataObjects and and other functional call of same layer. Then this all business layer is called via service layer having annotation #transactional.
Can you please mention why you think this approch is dirty??