Transpose and reshape a 3d array in matlab - performance

Suppose I have an array X of size n by p by q. I would like to reshape it as a matrix with p rows, and in each row put the concatenation of the n rows of size q, resulting in a matrix of size p by nq.
I managed to do it with a loop but it takes a while say if n=1000, p=300, q=300.
F0=[];
for k=1:size(F,1)
F0=[F0,squeeze(X(k,:,:))];
end
Is there a faster way?

I think this is what you want:
Y = reshape(permute(X, [2 1 3]), size(X,2), []);
Example with n=2, p=3, q=4:
>> X
X(:,:,1) =
0 6 9
8 3 0
X(:,:,2) =
4 7 1
3 7 4
X(:,:,3) =
4 7 2
6 7 6
X(:,:,4) =
6 1 9
1 4 3
>> Y = reshape(permute(X, [2 1 3]), size(X,2), [])
Y =
0 8 4 3 4 6 6 1
6 3 7 7 7 7 1 4
9 0 1 4 2 6 9 3

Try this -
reshape(permute(X,[2 3 1]),p,[])
Thus, for code verification, one can look into a sample case run -
n = 2;
p = 3;
q = 4;
X = rand(n,p,q)
F0=[];
for k=1:n
F0=[F0,squeeze(X(k,:,:))];
end
F0
F0_noloop = reshape(permute(X,[2 3 1]),p,[])
Output is -
F0 =
0.4134 0.6938 0.3782 0.4775 0.2177 0.0098 0.7043 0.6237
0.1257 0.8432 0.7295 0.2364 0.3089 0.9223 0.2243 0.1771
0.7261 0.7710 0.2691 0.8296 0.7829 0.0427 0.6730 0.7669
F0_noloop =
0.4134 0.6938 0.3782 0.4775 0.2177 0.0098 0.7043 0.6237
0.1257 0.8432 0.7295 0.2364 0.3089 0.9223 0.2243 0.1771
0.7261 0.7710 0.2691 0.8296 0.7829 0.0427 0.6730 0.7669

Rather than using vectorization to solve the problem, you could look at the code to try and figure out what may improve performance. In this case, since you know the size of your output matrix F0 should be px(n*q), you could pre-allocate memory to F0 and avoid the constant resizing of the matrix at each iteration of the for loop
n=1000;
p=300;
q=300;
F0=zeros(p,n*q);
for k=1:size(F,1)
F0(:,(k-1)*q+1:k*q) = squeeze(F(k,:,:));
end
While probably not as efficient as the other two solutions, it is an alternative. Try the above and see what happens!

Related

How to change the elements by different values in a matrix simultaneously in Octave?

I want to change the individual elements in a matrix by different values simultaneously.
How do I do that?
For example: I want to change the first element in matrix A by certain amount and the second element by a different amount simultaneously.
{ A = [1; 2]
% instead of doing A(1) = .....
A(2) = .....
}
You can access the elements of a vector or matrix and replace them.
For a vector this is intuitive.
octave:16> A = 1:9
A =
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
octave:17> A([1 3 5 7 9]) = 0
A =
0 2 0 4 0 6 0 8 0
This can be done for a matrix as well. The elements of a matrix are arranged in a column-first manner. You can use a single index to access the elements of a matrix.
octave:18> A = [1 2 3; 4 5 6; 7 8 9]
A =
1 2 3
4 5 6
7 8 9
The 2nd element of A is the same as A(2, 1). The 4th element of A is the same as A(1, 2).
octave:21> A(2)
ans = 4
octave:22> A(4)
ans = 2
So, you can set all the odd elements of A to 0 in one go like this:
octave:19> A([1 3 5 7 9]) = 0
A =
0 2 0
4 0 6
0 8 0
Just add a vector with the differences. A += [0.1; 0.2]
octave:1> A = [1; 2];
octave:2> A += [0.1; 0.2]
A =
1.1000
2.2000

Matlab: sorting a matrix in a unique way

I have a problem with sorting some finance data based on firmnumbers. So given is a matrix that looks like:
[1 3 4 7;
1 2 7 8;
2 3 7 8;]
On Matlab i would like the matrix to be sorted as follows:
[1 0 3 4 7 0;
1 2 0 0 7 8;
0 2 3 0 7 8;]
So basically every column needs to consist of 1 type of number.
I have tried many things but i cant get the matrix sorted properly.
A = [1 3 4 7;
1 2 7 8;
2 3 7 8;]
%// Get a unique list of numbers in the order that you want them to appear as the new columns
U = unique(A(:))'
%'//For each column (of your output, same as columns of U), find which rows have that number. Do this by making A 3D so that bsxfun compares each element with each element
temp1 = bsxfun(#eq,permute(A,[1,3,2]),U)
%// Consolidate this into a boolean matrix with the right dimensions and 1 where you'll have a number in your final answer
temp2 = any(temp1,3)
%// Finally multiply each line with U
bsxfun(#times, temp2, U)
So you can do that all in one line but I broke it up to make it easier to understand. I suggest you run each line and look at the output to see how it works. It might seem complicated but it's worthwhile getting to understand bsxfun as it's a really useful function. The first use which also uses permute is a bit more tricky so I suggest you first make sure you understand that last line and then work backwards.
What you are asking can also be seen as an histogram
A = [1 3 4 7;
1 2 7 8;
2 3 7 8;]
uniquevalues = unique(A(:))
N = histc(A,uniquevalues' ,2) %//'
B = bsxfun(#times,N,uniquevalues') %//'
%// bsxfun can replace the following instructions:
%//(the instructions are equivalent only when each value appears only once per row )
%// B = repmat(uniquevalues', size(A,1),1)
%// B(N==0) = 0
Answer without assumptions - Simplified
I did not feel comfortable with my old answer that makes the assumption of everything being an integer and removed the possibility of duplicates, so I came up with a different solution based on #lib's suggestion of using a histogram and counting method.
The only case I can see this not working for is if a 0 is entered. you will end up with a column of all zeros, which one might interpret as all rows initially containing a zero, but that would be incorrect. you could uses nan instead of zeros in that case, but not sure what this data is being put into, and if it that processing would freak out.
EDITED
Includes sorting of secondary matrix, B, along with A.
A = [-1 3 4 7 9; 0 2 2 7 8.2; 2 3 5 9 8];
B = [5 4 3 2 1; 1 2 3 4 5; 10 9 8 7 6];
keys = unique(A);
[counts,bin] = histc(A,transpose(unique(A)),2);
A_sorted = cell(size(A,1),1);
for ii = 1:size(A,1)
for jj = 1:numel(keys)
temp = zeros(1,max(counts(:,jj)));
temp(1:counts(ii,jj)) = keys(jj);
A_sorted{ii} = [A_sorted{ii},temp];
end
end
A_sorted = cell2mat(A_sorted);
B_sorted = nan(size(A_sorted));
for ii = 1:size(bin,1)
for jj = 1:size(bin,2)
idx = bin(ii,jj);
while ~isnan(B_sorted(ii,idx))
idx = idx+1;
end
B_sorted(ii,idx) = B(ii,jj);
end
end
B_sorted(isnan(B_sorted)) = 0
You can create at the beginning a matrix with 9 columns , and treat the values in your original matrix as column indexes.
A = [1 3 4 7;
1 2 7 8;
2 3 7 8;]
B = zeros(3,max(A(:)))
for i = 1:size(A,1)
B(i,A(i,:)) = A(i,:)
end
B(:,~any(B,1)) = []

improve the performance of the code with fewer number of operations

There are two vectors:
a = 1:5;
b = 1:2;
in order to find all combinations of these two vectors, I am using the following piece of code:
[A,B] = meshgrid(a,b);
C = cat(2,A',B');
D = reshape(C,[],2);
the result includes all the combinations:
D =
1 1
2 1
3 1
4 1
5 1
1 2
2 2
3 2
4 2
5 2
now the questions:
1- I want to decrease the number of operations to improve the performance for vectors with bigger size. Is there any single function in MATLAB that is doing this?
2- In the case that the number of vectors is more than 2, the meshgrid function cannot be used and has to be replaced with for loops. What is a better solution?
For greater than 2 dimensions, use ndgrid:
>> a = 1:2; b = 1:3; c = 1:2;
>> [A,B,C] = ndgrid(a,b,c);
>> D = [A(:) B(:) C(:)]
D =
1 1 1
2 1 1
1 2 1
2 2 1
1 3 1
2 3 1
1 1 2
2 1 2
1 2 2
2 2 2
1 3 2
2 3 2
Note that ndgrid expects (rows,cols,...) rather than (x,y).
This can be generalized to N dimensions (see here and here):
params = {a,b,c};
vecs = cell(numel(params),1);
[vecs{:}] = ndgrid(params{:});
D = reshape(cat(numel(vecs)+1,vecs{:}),[],numel(vecs));
Also, as described in Robert P.'s answer and here too, kron can also be useful for replicating values (indexes) in this way.
If you have the neural network toolbox, also have a look at combvec, as demonstrated here.
One way would be to combine repmat and the Kronecker tensor product like this:
[repmat(a,size(b)); kron(b,ones(size(a)))]'
ans =
1 1
2 1
3 1
4 1
5 1
1 2
2 2
3 2
4 2
5 2
This can be scaled to more dimensions this way:
a = 1:3;
b = 1:3;
c = 1:3;
x = [repmat(a,1,numel(b)*numel(c)); ...
repmat(kron(b,ones(1,numel(a))),1,numel(c)); ...
kron(c,ones(1,numel(a)*numel(b)))]'
There is a logic! First: simply repeat the first vector. Secondly: Use the tensor product with the dimension of the first vector and repeat it. Third: Use the tensor product with the dimension of (first x second) and repeat (in this case there is not fourth, so no repeat.

Replacing elements of a 2D matrix

I'm trying to increase the efficiency of my MATLAB code. What it does is, it replaces the nonzero elements of a matrix with the multiplication of the rest of the nonzero elements in the same row. For instance,
X = [2 3 6 0; 0 3 4 2]
transforms into
X = [18 12 6 0; 0 8 6 12]
It's an easy task to implement within a for loop. It checks every row, finds nonzero values and do its replacements. I want to get rid of the for loop though. Is there a way to implement this without a loop?
Code
X = [2 3 6 0; 0 3 4 2];
X1 = X;
X1(~X) = 1;
out = bsxfun(#rdivide,prod(X1,2),X1).*(X~=0)
Output
out =
18 12 6 0
0 8 6 12
Probably getting the row product first once and then divide by the element you don't want is the simplest way:
X = [2 3 6 0; 0 3 4 2]
Y=X
%get the product of all elements in a row
Y(Y==0)=1
Y=prod(Y,2)
%repeat Y to match the size of X
Y=repmat(Y,1,size(X,2))
%For all but the zero elements, divide Y by X, which is the product of all other elements.
X(X~=0)=Y(X~=0)./X(X~=0)

issue with sub2ind and matrix of matrix in matlab with images

I here by post the code why I came across while exploring one technique.
Y = repmat((1:m)', [1 n]);
X = repmat(1:n, [m 1]) - labels_left;
X(X<1) = 1;
indices = sub2ind([m,n],Y,X);
final_labels = labels_left;
final_labels(abs(labels_left - labels_right(indices))>=1) = -1;
In above code labels left is single channel image.[m n] is the size of that image. I want to know how this sub2ind works in above code.And Iam also facing problem in the last statement which contains
labels_right(indices)
what the above expression evaluates to.Here labels right is also an image
Maybe a smaller example could help understand:
%# image matrix
M = rand(4,3)
[m n] = size(M)
%# meshgrid, and convert to linear indices
[X,Y] = meshgrid(1:n,1:m)
indices = sub2ind([m,n],Y,X)
%# extract those elements
M(indices)
The matrix M:
>> M
M =
0.95717 0.42176 0.65574
0.48538 0.91574 0.035712
0.80028 0.79221 0.84913
0.14189 0.95949 0.93399
the grid of (x,y) coordinates of all points:
>> X,Y
X =
1 2 3
1 2 3
1 2 3
1 2 3
Y =
1 1 1
2 2 2
3 3 3
4 4 4
converted to linear indices:
>> indices
indices =
1 5 9
2 6 10
3 7 11
4 8 12
then we index into the matrix using those indices.
>> M(indices)
ans =
0.95717 0.42176 0.65574
0.48538 0.91574 0.035712
0.80028 0.79221 0.84913
0.14189 0.95949 0.93399
Note that: M(indices(i,j)) = M(Y(i,j)),X(i,j)).

Resources