Background process appears to hang - bash

Question

Editor's note: The OP is ultimately looking to package the code from this answer
as a script. Said code creates a stay-open FIFO from which a background command reads data to process as it arrives.
It works if I type it in the terminal, but it won't work if I enter those commands in a script file and run it.
#!/bin/bash
cat >a&
pid=$!
it seems that the program is stuck at cat>a&
$pid has no value after running the script, but the cat process seems to exist.

Answer 1

cdarke's answer contains the crucial pointer: your script mustn't run in a child process, so you have to source it.
Based on the question you linked to, it sounds like you're trying to do the following:
Open a FIFO (named pipe).
Keep that FIFO open indefinitely.
Make a background command read from that FIFO whenever new data is sent to it.
See bottom for a working solution.
As for an explanation of your symptoms:
Running your script NOT sourced (NOT with .) means that the script runs in a child process, which has the following implications:
Variables defined in the script are only visible inside that script, and the variables cease to exist altogether when the script finishes running.
That's why you didn't see the script's $myPid variable after running the script.
When the script finishes running, its background tasks (cat >a&) are killed (as cdarke explains, the SIGHUP signal is sent to them; any process that doesn't explicitly trap that signal is terminated).
This contradicts your claim that the cat process continues to exist, but my guess is that you mistook an interactively started cat process for one started by a script.
By contrast, any FIFO created by your script (with mkfifo) does persist after the script exits (a FIFO behaves like a file - it persists until you explicitly delete it).
However, when you write to that FIFO without another process reading from it, the writing command will block and thus appear to hang (the writing process blocks until another process reads the data from the FIFO).
That's probably what happened in your case: because the script's background processes were killed, no one was reading from the FIFO, causing an attempt to write to it to block. You incorrectly surmised that it was the cat >a& command that was getting "stuck".
The following script, when sourced, adds functions to the current shell for setting up and cleaning up a stay-open FIFO with a background command that processes data as it arrives. Save it as file bgfifo_funcs:
#!/usr/bin/env bash
[[ $0 != "$BASH_SOURCE" ]] || { echo "ERROR: This script must be SOURCED." >&2; exit 2; }
# Set up a background FIFO with a command listening for input.
# E.g.:
# bgfifo_setup bgfifo "sed 's/^/# /'"
# echo 'hi' > bgfifo # -> '# hi'
# bgfifo_cleanup
bgfifo_setup() {
(( $# == 2 )) || { echo "ERROR: usage: bgfifo_setup <fifo-file> <command>" >&2; return 2; }
local fifoFile=$1 cmd=$2
# Create the FIFO file.
mkfifo "$fifoFile" || return
# Use a dummy background command that keeps the FIFO *open*.
# Without this, it would be closed after the first time you write to it.
# NOTE: This call inevitably outputs a job control message that looks
# something like this:
# [1]+ Stopped cat > ...
{ cat > "$fifoFile" & } 2>/dev/null
# Note: The keep-the-FIFO-open `cat` PID is the only one we need to save for
# later cleanup.
# The background processing command launched below will terminate
# automatically then FIFO is closed when the `cat` process is killed.
__bgfifo_pid=$!
# Now launch the actual background command that should read from the FIFO
# whenever data is sent.
{ eval "$cmd" < "$fifoFile" & } 2>/dev/null || return
# Save the *full* path of the FIFO file in a global variable for reliable
# cleanup later.
__bgfifo_file=$fifoFile
[[ $__bgfifo_file == /* ]] || __bgfifo_file="$PWD/$__bgfifo_file"
echo "FIFO '$fifoFile' set up, awaiting input for: $cmd"
echo "(Ignore the '[1]+ Stopped ...' message below.)"
}
# Cleanup function that you must call when done, to remove
# the FIFO file and kill the background commands.
bgfifo_cleanup() {
[[ -n $__bgfifo_file ]] || { echo "(Nothing to clean up.)"; return 0; }
echo "Removing FIFO '$__bgfifo_file' and terminating associated background processes..."
rm "$__bgfifo_file"
kill $__bgfifo_pid # Note: We let the job control messages display.
unset __bgfifo_file __bgfifo_pid
return 0
}
Then, source script bgfifo_funcs, using the . shell builtin:
. bgfifo_funcs
Sourcing executes the script in the current shell (rather than in a child process that terminates after the script has run), and thus makes the script's functions and variables available to the current shell. Functions by definition run in the current shell, so any background commands started from functions stay alive.
Now you can set up a stay-open FIFO with a background process that processes input as it arrives as follows:
# Set up FIFO 'bgfifo in the current dir. and process lines sent to it
# with a sample Sed command that simply prepends '# ' to every line.
$ bgfifo_setup bgfifo "sed 's/^/# /'"
# Send sample data to the FIFO.
$ echo 'Hi.' > bgfifo
# Hi.
# ...
$ echo 'Hi again.' > bgfifo
# Hi again.
# ...
# Clean up when done.
$ bgfifo_cleanup

Answer 2

The reason that cat >a "hangs" is because it is reading from the standard input stream (stdin, file descriptor zero), which defaults to the keyboard.
Adding the & causes it to run in background, which disconnects from the keyboard. Normally that would leave a suspended job in background, but, since you exit your script, its background tasks are killed (sends a SIGHUP signal).
EDIT: although I followed the link in the question, it was not stated originally that the OP was actually using a FIFO at that stage. So thanks to #mklement0.
I don't understand what you are trying to do here, but I suspect you need to run it as a "sourced" file, as follows:
. gash.sh
Where gash.sh is the name of your script. Note the preceding .

Answer 3

You need to specify a file with "cat":
#!/bin/bash
cat SOMEFILE >a &
pid=$!
echo PID $pid
Although that seems a bit silly - why not just "cp" the file (cp SOMEFILE a)?
Q: What exactly are you trying to accomplish?