In make, how do I use the wildcard % to describe multiple files in both target and prerequisites?
%.1: %.md
for f in $?; do ...; done
I thought the above was the way to trigger the rule to create *.1 files for any *.md that were modified since the last run, but shows this instead:
make: *** No targets. Stop.
Your rule is saying "if you need to make a .1, here is how to do so if you have a .md", you haven't asked make to do any .1. You probably need also something like:
SOURCES=$(wildcard *.md)
all: $(SOURCES:%.md=%.1)
%.1: %.md
echo $#
Note that * and % are similar (they stands for unspecified characters) but appears in different contexts (* to look for existing files, % when examining strings -- the strings are often part of file name, but that's not something mandatory and you could for instance use it to match arguments of utilities)
Related
Using GNU make, I am trying to solve a problem similar to make recipe execute twice — that is, to have a Makefile recipe run twice. In my case, however, the recipe is run under the .SECONDEXPANSION target, and the two different runs will be called with different parameters to generate different versions of the output file from the same input file. That is, with input file foo, this example Makefile should be callable via make foo.pdf or make foo.expanded.pdf to build one .pdf file, or make all to build both .pdf files:
.PHONY: all
all: foo.pdf foo.expanded.pdf
.SECONDEXPANSION:
%.expanded.pdf %.pdf: %
#echo building $(basename $#)
Of the two solutions given in that answer, the first is unsuitable because it always runs the rule twice; I want it run twice when the user asks for it.
The second solution posted there is conceptually what I am looking for and have implemented in the above example Makefile, with only the small problem that it doesn't work: although the all target lists both .pdf files as dependencies, only one is built when make all is run.
Is there a way to tell GNU make to build two different files using the same rule under a .SECONDEXPANSION?
EDIT: Clarified in problem description that the same input file is used to build both versions of the output file, and modified sample Makefile to include this dependency.
EDIT: I would like a solution as scalable as possible; that is, it should work if the input filename contains dots, specifying additional output file foo.reduced.pdf should require only adjusting the targets and recipe as appropriate, etc. This limits performing string surgery that relies on the filenames appearing exactly as given in this narrow example (e.g., changing the rule to %.pdf: $$(firstword $$(subst ., ,$$*)) fails if the input file could be either foo or foo.bar).
You are probably looking for Pattern-specific Variable Values. Let's assume your recipe depends on a make variable named BUILDFLAGS that takes value normal by default and special for the "expanded" targets. Then this Makefile:
BUILDER := builder
BUILDFLAGS := normal
.PHONY: all
all: foo.pdf foo.expanded.pdf
%.expanded.pdf: BUILDFLAGS := special
%.pdf:
$(BUILDER) $(BUILDFLAGS) $#
should do about what you want with the same rule for all targets, plus one pattern-specific variable value declaration. Replace builder, normal and special with what makes sense in your case. Demo:
$ make foo.pdf
builder normal foo.pdf
$ make foo.expanded.pdf
builder special foo.expanded.pdf
$ make
builder normal foo.pdf
builder special foo.expanded.pdf
Your problem has nothing to do with .SECONDEXPANSION. You can just drop that and the problem will be the same.
Your problem is that you are using a pattern rule with multiple target patterns, and expecting that it works similar to an explicit rule with multiple targets. But it does not (and in fact you cannot have a rule with both pattern and explicit targets).
For a pattern rule with multiple target patterns, Make matches the same pattern to all the %, including multiple times in the targets, and then assumes that it just has to execute the recipe with that pattern once, and it will make all the matched targets.
In your case the best way is to use multiple rules (I changed your recipe because using echo as a Make recipe is a bad idea):
.PHONY: all
all: foo.expanded.pdf foo.pdf
RECIPE = touch $#
%.expanded.pdf:
$(RECIPE)
%.pdf:
$(RECIPE)
Wondering how to apply something such as pattern rules to accomplish the following in the Makefile:
FILES := a b c d
$(FILES).c:
run build $(FILE).c
# use $(FILE) without .c extension, etc.
Without having to name all of the values in FILES like a.c, b.c, etc. because I am going to use the names elsewhere.
If I try the above with make a.c, I get:
No rule to make target `a.c'. Stop.
The addsuffix built-in function, which already operates on lists, could be useful here:
targets := $(addsuffix .c,$(FILES))
However, you could simply use pattern rules instead. The automatic variable $* would correspond to the stem (i.e., the % part):
%.c:
run build $#
# use $* for filename without .c extension, etc.
I have this implicit rule:
%.so: %.so.5
qnx_ln $< $#
I realized that for another target, I have to make all .so files the prerequisite for that target.
I tried this:
makegen: $(TEAM_ROOT)HMI_FORGF/src/src.pro module_dirs %.so
...
But I got the output
*** No rule to make target '%.so', needed by 'makegen'. Stop.
% prerequisite patterns can only be used in static and implicit pattern rules, where they match the respective % part of the target; when used in a regular rule % is a literal character.
You'll need to specify the dependencies literally, unless there is some correspondence between certain source filenames and the .so filenames that you can leverage, presumably you're already doing either of these to link the .so files in the first place.
As pointed out previously, no you can't do that because this is not how prerequisite patterns work. Maybe you gave the following a thought and rejected it but I suspect you might find the following a close-enough fit:
%.so.target: %.so.5
echo $< >> $(BUILD)/so.targets
SO_TARGETS=$(basename $(shell cat $(BUILD)/so.targets))
makegen: $(TEAM_ROOT)HMI_FORGF/src/src.pro module_dirs $(SO_TARGETS)
Maybe you are looking for a rule to match on every existing *.so file?
makegen: $(TEAM_ROOT)HMI_FORGF/src/src.pro module_dirs $(wildcard *.so)
...
However, if there are patterns which could generate *.so files which have not yet generated those files, they will (obviously) not be matched by the wildcard, which simply examines existing files. If that's what you actually want to accomplish, you'll probably want to enumerate the actual files, one way or another.
I have another make-like tool that produces an XML as an artifact after parsing my makefile which I'll then further process with Python.
It'd simplify things for me - a lot - if I could have make consider every single prerequisite to be an actual target because then this other tool
will classify each and every file as a "job".
This is a fragment of my makefile:
.obj/eventlookupmodel.o: C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/src/AL2HMIBridge/LookupModels/eventlookupmodel.cpp C:\Users\User1\Desktop\A\PROJ\src\AL2HMIBridge\LookupModels\eventlookupmodel.h \
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qabstractitemmodel.h \
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qvariant.h \
...
I'd want for make to think I have a dummy rule for each prerequisite such as below:
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qvariant.h:
#echo target pre= $#
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/qt5binaries/include/QtCore/qabstractitemmodel.h:
#echo target pre=$#
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/PROJ/src/AL2HMIBridge/LookupModels/eventlookupmodel.cpp :
#echo target pre=$#
C:\Users\User1\Desktop\A\PROJ\src\AL2HMIBridge\LookupModels\eventlookupmodel.h:
#echo target pre=$#
I don't care about the exact form of the rule just that each file is considered an actual target.
My method of passing in this rule would be by setting the MAKEFILES variable like so
make all MAKEFILES=Dummy.mk
with Dummy.mk containing this rule so that I do not modify the makefiles.
I've tried the following so far.
Dummy.mk:
%.h:
#echo header xyz = $#
%:
#echo other xyz= $#
This partially works.
I run make all --trace --print-data-base MAKEFILES=Dummy.mk and I can see that
make does "bind" the %.h: rule to the header files. In the --print-data-base section, I see that rule being assigned to the header files.
C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/QNX_SDK/target/qnx6/usr/include/stddef.h:
# Implicit rule search has been done.
# Implicit/static pattern stem: 'C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/QNX_SDK/target/qnx6/usr/include/stddef'
# Last modified 2016-05-27 12:39:16
# File has been updated.
# Successfully updated.
# recipe to execute (from '#$(QMAKE) top_builddir=C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/HMI_FORGF/src/../lib/armle-v7/release/ top_srcdir=C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/HMI_FORGF/ -Wall CONFIG+=release CONFIG+=qnx_build_release_with_symbols CONFIG+=rtc_build -o Makefile C:/Users/User1/Desktop/A/HMI_FORGF/src/HmiLogging/HmiLogging.pro
', line 2):
#echo header xyz = $#
However, I do NOT see the "echo header xyz $#"-rule being executed.
Regarding the %: rule, it is neither executed for the .cpp files nor "bound" to them in the --print-data-base section.
However, it is bound and executed for existing targets which have no suffix i.e.
all: library binary
binary: | library
ifs: | library
For the %: rule, the reason for this behavior is because of 10.5.5 Match-Anything Pattern Rules: If you do not mark the match-anything rule as terminal, then it is non-terminal. A non-terminal match-anything rule cannot apply to a file name that indicates a specific type of data. A file name indicates a specific type of data if some non-match-anything implicit rule target matches it.
If I make it non-terminal - no double colon - then the rule doesn't apply to built-in types like .cppunless I un-define the built-in rules that negate my intended %: rule.
If I make it terminal, "it does not apply unless its prerequisites actually exist". But a .h or .cpp doesn't technically have prerequisites; can I just create a dummy file and have that as its prerequisite?
NOTE: This has NOTHING to do with gcc -M generation. Yes the -M option would help in the specific case of header and source files but this question is for more generic targets and prerequisites that already exist in the makefile when make is launched.
This may take a few iterations. Try:
%.h: null
#echo header xyz = $#
%: null
#echo other xyz= $#
null:
#:
Try generating static pattern rules for the header files. See one of the answers to Make ignoring Prerequisite that doesn't exist.
Static pattern rules only apply to an explicit list of target files like this:
$(OBJECTS): %.o: %.c
*recipe here*
where the variable OBJECTS is defined earlier in the makefile to be a list of target files (separated by spaces), for example:
OBJECTS := src/fileA.c src/fileB.c src/fileC.c
Note that you can use the various make utility functions to build that list of target files. For example, $(wildcard pattern), $(addsuffix), etc.
You should also ensure that the recipe "touches" the header file to change the timestamp.
I've found that using static pattern rules instead of pattern rules fixes problems where make doesn’t build prerequisites that don’t exist, or deletes files that you want.
Here is an example of using wildcard to copy files from one directory to another.
# Copy images to build/images
img_files := $(wildcard src/images/*.png src/images/*.gif src/images/*.jpg \
src/images/*.mp3)
build_images := $(subst src/,$(BUILD_DIR)/,$(img_files))
$(build_images): $(BUILD_DIR)/images/% : src/images/%
mkdir -p $(dir $#)
cp -v -a $< $#
There are other make functions like addprefix that could be used to generate a more complex file specification.
I want to run pocketlint on all **/*.js files.
.PHONY: lint_js2
LINT_JS = $(wildcard static/js/*.js static/js/**/*.js)
LINT_JS_TARGETS = $(addprefix lint__,$(LINT_JS))
#.PHONY: $(LINT_JS_TARGETS)
lint_js2: $(LINT_JS_TARGETS)
echo $<
lint__%: %
pocketlint $<
However, I get this error:
make: *** No rule to make target `lint__static/js/ad_list.js', needed by `lint_js2'. Stop.
Why lint__static/js/ad_list.js is not captured by lint__%?
If I uncomment second .PHONY, it echoes lint__static/js/ad_list.js, but does not invoke pocketlint static/js/ad_list.js. Why?
If my approach is wrong, what would be the right approach? Since tasks are independent, I would appreciate if make -j50 would do what I am expecting.
Thanks!
It's not clear what is intended: does pocketlint write a file named lint__static/js/ad_list.js, or is that really a phony filename? Anyway...
Reread the second paragraph of How Patterns Match:
When the target pattern does not contain a slash (and it usually does not), directory names in the file names are removed from the file name before it is compared with the target prefix and suffix. After the comparison of the file name to the target pattern, the directory names, along with the slash that ends them, are added on to the prerequisite file names generated from the pattern rule's prerequisite patterns and the file name.
In short, % generally matches just a filename, not a pathname with slashes in it. So lint__static/js/ad_list.js is not captured because actually it is only ad_list.js that is being matched against lint__%.
If you can arrange it so that the output files from pocketlint are static/js/lint__ad_list.js etc, then this could be made to work:
LINT_JS_TARGETS = $(foreach f,$(LINT_JS),$(dir $f)lint__$(notdir $f))
lint__%: %
pocketlint $<
Alternatively you can make % match pathnames by having the target pattern be a pathname (containing a slash):
LINT_JS_TARGETS = $(addprefix linted/,$(LINT_JS))
linted/%: %
pocketlint $<
This time % = static/js/ad_list.js does match the pattern rule.
In either case, you're going to have to have pocketlint produce output (if indeed it produces output) named differently than lint__static/*.
Implicit rule search is suppressed for phony targets (see Phony Targets, paragraph 5). So the rule involving pocketlint is never considered when lint__static/js/ad_list.js is phony.
It's not obvious why the result is Nothing to be done for (phony) lint__static/js/ad_list.js rather than No rule to make target lint__static/js/ad_list.js, but I wouldn't lose sleep over it!