During the developement of my engine, I'm trying to implement a feature, that enables hot-swapping between OpenGL and DirectX. Currently I'm testing on Win32 platform, and came across the following problem:
I implemented both renderer (OpenGL 3.0, and Direct3D11), both work fine alone. The swapping mechanism is the following:
Destroy the current rendering context, and build up the new one. For example: Release all DirectX objects, and then create OpenGL context, via WGL. I'm trying to implement this, using only one window (HWND).
Swapping from OpenGL 3.0 to DirectX11 works. (After destroying OpenGL, DirectX renders fine)
Destroying OpenGL and then recreating OpenGL again, works. Same with DirectX.
When I'm trying to swap from DirectX to OpenGL, the window will stop displaying the newly draw content, only the lastly drawn DirectX frame.
To construct the OpenGL context I'm using WGL. The class for the window was created with the CS_OWNDC style. I'm using SwapBuffers to flip the window buffers. Before setting up the context, I use SetPixelFormat with the previously returned value from ChoosePixelFormat. The created context is version 3.0, ensured via wglCreateContextAttribsARB.
Additional information:
All of the DirectX references are released, this was checked by calling ReportLiveDeviceObjects and checking the return value of ID3D11Device1::Release (0). ID3D11DeviceContext1::ClearState and Flush were called to ensure object destruction.
None of the OpenGL methods report error via glGetError, this is checked after every call. This is same for all OS, and WGL calls.
The OpenGL rendering calls are executing as expected, for example:
OpenGL rendering with 150 fps
Swap to DirectX, render with 60 fps (VSYNC)
Swap back to OpenGL, rendering again with 150 fps (not more)
There are other scenarios where OpenGL renders with more than 150 fps, so the rendering calls are executing properly.
My guess is that the flipping of the buffers doesn't work somehow, however SwapBuffers returns TRUE anyway.
I tried using SaveDC and RestoreDC before and after using DirectX, this resulted in now solution.
Using wglSwapLayerBuffers instead of SwapBuffers gives no change.
Can I somehow restore the HWND, or HDC to the original state, or do you guys have any idea why this might happen?
Guess I posted my question to soon, but however, this is how I solved it.
I dug around the documnentation for DirectX, and for the function CreateSwapChainForHwnd, I found the following:
Because you can associate only one flip presentation model swap chain at a time with an HWND, the Microsoft Direct3D 11 policy of deferring the destruction of objects can cause problems if you attempt to destroy a flip presentation model swap chain and replace it with another swap chain.
I was using DXGI_SWAP_EFFECT_FLIP_SEQUENTIAL in my swap chain descriptor, and this could mean, that DirectX sets up a flip swap chain for the window, but when I try to use it with OpenGL, it will fail swapping buffers somehow.
The solution for this, is to not use FLIP mode for creating the swap chain:
DXGI_SWAP_CHAIN_DESC1 scd;
scd.SwapEffect = DXGI_SWAP_EFFECT_DISCARD;
scd.Scaling = DXGI_SCALING_ASPECT_RATIO_STRETCH;
You have to set the Scaling to something else than DXGI_SCALING_NONE, or the creation will fail.
The interesting part is, that the DirectX still does not properly destroy the flip model on the window, altough I did everything it suggested in the documentation (ClearState and Flush calls).
CreateSwapChainForHwnd see Remarks
Edit: I found this question after some time. If anybody still has some idea, how to revert back to using GDI again instead of the DWM backbuffer, it is greatly appreciated.
Related
I'm trying to do pretty much what TangoARScreen does but with multithreaded rendering on in Unity. I did some experiments and I'm stuck.
I tried several things, such as letting Tango render into the OES texture that would be then blitted into a regular Texture2D in Unity, but OpenGL keeps complaining about invalid display when I try to use it. Probably not even OnTangoCameraTextureAvailable is called in the correct GL context? Hard to say when you have no idea how Tango Core works internally.
Is registering a YUV texture via TangoService_Experimental_connectTextureIdUnity the way to go? I'd have to deal with YUV2RGB conversion I assume. Or should I use OnTangoImageMultithreadedAvailable and deal with the buffer? Render it with a custom share for instance? The documentation is pretty blank in these areas and every experiment means several wasted days at least. Did anyone get this working? Could you point me in the right direction? All I need is live camera image rendered into Unity's camera background.
Frome the April 2017: Gankino release notes: "The C API now supports getting the latest camera image's timestamp outside a GL thread .... Unity multithreaded rendering support will get added in a future release.". So I guess we need to wait a little bit.
Multithreaded rendering still can be used in applications without camera feed (with motion tracking only), choosing "YUV Texture and Raw Bytes" as overlay method in Tango Application Script.
First of all after 4 hours of debugging I have no problem with my code. But I'm curious why I had issue that I had.
I created fullscreen window with d3d11 rendering. Problem occurred when I tried to alt-tab window and didn't have Present() in my loop (I simply found this issue before implementing rendering function). In that case after minimizing window Red and Blue channels on my screen were swapped (yes, literally).
It took me long time to find because I suspected my swap chain or window itself (sdl). Can you help me find the reason of this bug- for educational purposes?
This usually is due to a graphics driver bug with RGBA swap chains. You can try updating your driver (run Windows Update). But to improve compatibility you can change your swap chain surface format to BGRA (specifically, B8G8R8A8_UNORM). As long as you are just doing normal rendering (and not doing anything fancy like UpdateSubresource directly to the back buffer), you should be able to leave everything else as-is and it will render correctly.
I followed this post to play with OpenGL (programmable pipeline) on Ruby
Basically, I'm just trying to create a blue window, and here's the code.
Ray::GL.major_version = 3
Ray::GL.minor_version = 2
Ray::GL.core_profile = true # if you want/need one
window = Ray::Window.new("Test Window", [800, 600])
window.make_current
glClearColor(0, 0, 1, 1);
glClear(GL_COLOR_BUFFER_BIT | GL_DEPTH_BUFFER_BIT);
glEnable(GL_DEPTH_TEST);
Instead, I got a white window created. This indicated that I was missing something, but I couldn't figure out what I was missing as the resources for OpenGL on Ruby seemed limited. I have been searching all over the web, but all I found was fixed-pipeline OpenGL stuff for Ruby.
Yes, I could use Ray's built-in functions to set the background color and draw stuff, but I didn't want to do that. I just wanted to use Ray to setup the window, then called OpenGL APIs directly. However, I couldn't figure out what I was missing in the code above.
I would greatly appreciate any hint or pointer to this (maybe I needed to swap the buffer? but then I didn't know how to do it with Ray). Is there any body familiar with using Ray that can give me some hints on this?
Or, are there any other tools that would allow me to setup OpenGL binding (for none fixed-pipeline)?
It would appear that you set the clear color to be blue, then cleared the back buffer to make it blue. But, as you said, you have not swapped the buffers to put the back buffer onto your screen. As far as swapping buffers goes, here's another answer from stack overflow
"Swapping the front and back buffer of a double buffered window is a function provided by the underlying graphics system, i.e. Win32 GDI, or X11 GLX. The function's you're looking for are wglSwapBuffers and/or glXSwapBuffers. On MacOS X NSOpenGLViews are automatically swapped.
However most likely you're using some framework, like GLUT, GLFW or Qt, which provide a portable wrapper around those functions. Read the framework's documentation."
I've never used Ray, so I'd say just keep rooting around in the documentation or look through example projects to see how buffer swapping is done.
Nearly every example I see of OpenGL ES involves it updating every frame, even if the image itself is not moving in any way.
I did some tests and I see it works quite fine to just render (using drawArrays etc) and then present the render buffer (these two actions, together) just once and then not do either again until you have something change onscreen.
Is this "normal" ? I just don't see this really done much. Once drawn, the graphics stay on the screen without additional constant rendering.
Is this acceptable?
Yes, it is acceptable and completely valid. You also need to take account to render again when the context is lost. To give you an example, using Android standard OpenGL helper classes there is an option to only draw when needed, not in loop (RENDERMODE_WHEN_DIRTY).
I'm calling this method:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd371264(VS.85).aspx
The call fails with E_NOINTERFACE. The documentation is especially unhelpful as to why this may happen. I've enabled all of the DirectX 11 debug stuff and that's the best I got. I know that I have a valid IDXGISurface1* (also tried IDXGISurface) and the other parameters are set correctly. Any ideas as to why this call may fail?
Edit:
I also am having problems creating D3D11 devices. If I pass nullptr as the IDXGIAdapter* argument in D3D11CreateDeviceAndSwapChain, it works fine, but if I enumerate the adapters myself and pass in a pointer (the only one returned), it fails with invalid argument. The MSDN documentation explicitly says that if nullptr is passed, then the system uses the first return from EnumAdapters1. I am running a DX11 system.
Direct2D only works when you create a Direct3D 10.1 device, but it can share surfaces with Direct3D 11. All you need to do is create both devices and render all of your Direct2D content to a texture that you share between them. I use this technique in my own applications to use Direct2D with Direct3D 11. It incurs a slight cost, but it is small and constant per frame.
A basic outline of the process you will need to use is:
Create your Direct3D 11 device like you do normally.
Create a texture with the D3D10_RESOURCE_MISC_SHARED_KEYEDMUTEX option in order to allow access to the ID3D11KeyedMutex interface.
Use the GetSharedHandle to get a handle to the texture that can be shared among devices.
Create a Direct3D 10.1 device, ensuring that it is created on the same adapter.
Use OpenSharedResource function on the Direct3D 10.1 device to get a version of the texture for Direct3D 10.1.
Get access to the D3D10 KeyedMutex interface for the texture.
Use the Direct3D 10.1 version of the texture to create the RenderTarget using Direct2D.
When you want to render with D2D, use the keyed mutex to lock the texture for the D3D10 device. Then, acquire it in D3D11 and render the texture like you were probably already trying to do.
It's not trivial, but it works well, and it is the way that they intended you to interoperate between them. Windows 8 looks like it will introduce full D3D11 compatibility, so it will be just as simple as you expect.
Direct2D uses D3D10 devices not D3D11 devices. D3D11 device is probably that is reported as lacking interface by that E_NOINTERFACE.