We have an issue with a asp.net core 3.1 MVC application. The application is using the built in asp.net Identity feature. The application is working well for existing users. If you hit any [Authorized] route, you are redirected to the login page as expected.
However, rather than have a registration process in our app, for new users, we onboard them via Stripe Checkout. Upon successful payment, stripe redirects to a specific route in our application /conversion/success/{sessionid} where sessionid is the Stripe session. This action is marked as [AllowAnonymous].
We then pull the necessary customer details from Stripe, create a user in our repository via UserManager<T>. We then call SignInManager<T>.SignInAsync() to sign in the new user, before redirecting the new user to the [Authorized] home page.
This process works perfectly when running locally on our test machines. Also, when running on our production server (Azure App Service) it also works perfectly when we hit the route manually through the browser.
However, when we actually run the process through Stripe, complete a payment and let Stripe redirect the customer, we get a strange behaviour.
The conversion route is hit, the user record is created, the sign in process completes but upon redirection to home page, the authentication middleware takes over, says it's not authenticated and redirects to the login page.
Just to compound matters further, if you then simply type in the home page route in the browser, the user is in fact logged in exactly as expected and the application works perfectly.
Using Fiddler to intercept the calls and look at headers, etc. we can't see why there would be a different behaviour when coming from Stripe as opposed to typing directly. We've even tried redirecting from a different website to our registration process and that works as expected too.
Any idea why we are seeing this behaviour?
---- Update ---
If, rather than redirect to home page at the end of the onboarding process, we simply show a simple View with an anchor link to home page, the user can then go to home page as expected.
Is it possible that you're rendering the page before authentication has been completed? Since UserManager uses a cookie to establish the user's session, authentication needs to complete before any response headers or body is set so that the Set-Cookie header can be sent in the response.
Based on what you described it sounds like the user is hitting the homepage after the redirect without having the authentication cookie. Where I'd start debugging this is by using your web inspector with "Preserve log" turned on and going through the Stripe Checkout process. Then, inspect the headers sent to the browser when you land on the redirect page & make sure the authentication cookie is set.
Between requests to Stripe and SignInAsync it seems possible that there might be a missing await, so the redirect is happening before the authentication context is updated. Hard to say more without seeing your code!
On the website https://code.google.com/apis/console I have registered my application, set up generated Client ID: and Client Secret to my app and tried to log in with Google.
Unfortunately, I got the error message:
Error: redirect_uri_mismatch
The redirect URI in the request: http://127.0.0.1:3000/auth/google_oauth2/callback did not match a registered redirect URI
scope=https://www.googleapis.com/auth/userinfo.profile https://www.googleapis.com/auth/userinfo.email
response_type=code
redirect_uri=http://127.0.0.1:3000/auth/google_oauth2/callback
access_type=offline
approval_prompt=force
client_id=generated_id
What does mean this message, and how can I fix it?
I use the gem omniauth-google-oauth2.
The redirect URI (where the response is returned to) has to be registered in the APIs console, and the error is indicating that you haven't done that, or haven't done it correctly.
Go to the console for your project and look under API Access. You should see your client ID & client secret there, along with a list of redirect URIs. If the URI you want isn't listed, click edit settings and add the URI to the list.
EDIT: (From a highly rated comment below) Note that updating the google api console and that change being present can take some time. Generally only a few minutes but sometimes it seems longer.
In my case it was www and non-www URL. Actual site had www URL and the Authorized Redirect URIs in Google Developer Console had non-www URL. Hence, there was mismatch in redirect URI. I solved it by updating Authorized Redirect URIs in Google Developer Console to www URL.
Other common URI mismatch are:
Using http:// in Authorized Redirect URIs and https:// as actual URL, or vice-versa
Using trailing slash (http://example.com/) in Authorized Redirect URIs and not using trailing slash (http://example.com) as actual URL, or vice-versa
Here are the step-by-step screenshots of Google Developer Console so that it would be helpful for those who are getting it difficult to locate the developer console page to update redirect URIs.
Go to https://console.developers.google.com
Select your Project
Click on the menu icon
Click on API Manager menu
Click on Credentials menu. And under OAuth 2.0 Client IDs, you will find your client name. In my case, it is Web Client 1. Click on it and a popup will appear where you can edit Authorized Javascript Origin and Authorized redirect URIs.
Note: The Authorized URI includes all localhost links by default, and any live version needs to include the full path, not just the domain, e.g. https://example.com/path/to/oauth/url
Here is a Google article on creating project and client ID.
If you're using Google+ javascript button, then you have to use postmessage instead of the actual URI. It took me almost the whole day to figure this out since Google's docs do not clearly state it for some reason.
In any flow where you retrieved an authorization code on the client side, such as the GoogleAuth.grantOfflineAccess() API, and now you want to pass the code to your server, redeem it, and store the access and refresh tokens, then you have to use the literal string postmessage instead of the redirect_uri.
For example, building on the snippet in the Ruby doc:
client_secrets = Google::APIClient::ClientSecrets.load('client_secrets.json')
auth_client = client_secrets.to_authorization
auth_client.update!(
:scope => 'profile https://www.googleapis.com/auth/drive.metadata.readonly',
:redirect_uri => 'postmessage' # <---- HERE
)
# Inject user's auth_code here:
auth_client.code = "4/lRCuOXzLMIzqrG4XU9RmWw8k1n3jvUgsI790Hk1s3FI"
tokens = auth_client.fetch_access_token!
# { "access_token"=>..., "expires_in"=>3587, "id_token"=>..., "refresh_token"=>..., "token_type"=>"Bearer"}
The only Google documentation to even mention postmessage is this old Google+ sign-in doc. Here's a screenshot and archive link since G+ is closing and this link will likely go away:
It is absolutely unforgivable that the doc page for Offline Access doesn't mention this. #FacePalm
For my web application i corrected my mistake by writing
instead of : http://localhost:11472/authorize/
type : http://localhost/authorize/
Make sure to check the protocol "http://" or "https://" as google checks protocol as well.
Better to add both URL in the list.
1.you would see an error like this
2.then you should click on request details
after this , you have to copy that url and add this on https://console.cloud.google.com/
go to https://console.cloud.google.com/
click on Menu -> API & Services -> Credentials
you would see a dashboard like this ,click on edit OAuth Client
now in Authorized Javascript Origins and Authorized redirect URLS
add the url that has shown error called redirect_uri_mismatch i.e here it is
http://algorithammer.herokuapp.com , so i have added that in both the places in
Authorized Javascript Origins and Authorized redirect URLS
click on save and wait for 5 min and then try to login again
This seems quite strange and annoying that no "one" solution is there.
for me http://localhost:8000 did not worked out but http://localhost:8000/ worked out.
This answer is same as this Mike's answer, and Jeff's answer, both sets redirect_uri to postmessage on client side. I want to add more about the server side, and also the special circumstance applying to this configuration.
Tech Stack
Backend
Python 3.6
Django 1.11
Django REST Framework 3.9: server as API, not rendering template, not doing much elsewhere.
Django REST Framework JWT 1.11
Django REST Social Auth < 2.1
Frontend
React: 16.8.3, create-react-app version 2.1.5
react-google-login: 5.0.2
The "Code" Flow (Specifically for Google OAuth2)
Summary: React --> request social auth "code" --> request jwt token to acquire "login" status in terms of your own backend server/database.
Frontend (React) uses a "Google sign in button" with responseType="code" to get an authorization code. (it's not token, not access token!)
The google sign in button is from react-google-login mentioned above.
Click on the button will bring up a popup window for user to select account. After user select one and the window closes, you'll get the code from the button's callback function.
Frontend send this to backend server's JWT endpoint.
POST request, with { "provider": "google-oauth2", "code": "your retrieved code here", "redirect_uri": "postmessage" }
For my Django server I use Django REST Framework JWT + Django REST Social Auth. Django receives the code from frontend, verify it with Google's service (done for you). Once verified, it'll send the JWT (the token) back to frontend. Frontend can now harvest the token and store it somewhere.
All of REST_SOCIAL_OAUTH_ABSOLUTE_REDIRECT_URI, REST_SOCIAL_DOMAIN_FROM_ORIGIN and REST_SOCIAL_OAUTH_REDIRECT_URI in Django's settings.py are unnecessary. (They are constants used by Django REST Social Auth) In short, you don't have to setup anything related to redirect url in Django. The "redirect_uri": "postmessage" in React frontend suffice. This makes sense because the social auth work you have to do on your side is all Ajax-style POST request in frontend, not submitting any form whatsoever, so actually no redirection occur by default. That's why the redirect url becomes useless if you're using the code + JWT flow, and the server-side redirect url setting is not taking any effect.
The Django REST Social Auth handles account creation. This means it'll check the google account email/last first name, and see if it match any account in database. If not, it'll create one for you, using the exact email & first last name. But, the username will be something like youremailprefix717e248c5b924d60 if your email is youremailprefix#example.com. It appends some random string to make a unique username. This is the default behavior, I believe you can customize it and feel free to dig into their documentation.
The frontend stores that token and when it has to perform CRUD to the backend server, especially create/delete/update, if you attach the token in your Authorization header and send request to backend, Django backend will now recognize that as a login, i.e. authenticated user. Of course, if your token expire, you have to refresh it by making another request.
Oh my goodness, I've spent more than 6 hours and finally got this right! I believe this is the 1st time I saw this postmessage thing. Anyone working on a Django + DRF + JWT + Social Auth + React combination will definitely crash into this. I can't believe none of the article out there mentions this except answers here. But I really hope this post can save you tons of time if you're using the Django + React stack.
In my case, my credential Application type is "Other". So I can't find Authorized redirect URIs in the credentials page. It seems appears in Application type:"Web application". But you can click the Download JSON button to get the client_secret.json file.
Open the json file, and you can find the parameter like this: "redirect_uris":["urn:ietf:wg:oauth:2.0:oob","http://localhost"]. I choose to use http://localhost and it works fine for me.
When you register your app at https://code.google.com/apis/console and
make a Client ID, you get a chance to specify one or more redirect
URIs. The value of the redirect_uri parameter on your auth URI has to
match one of them exactly.
Checklist:
http or https?
& or &?
trailing slash(/) or open ?
(CMD/CTRL)+F, search for the exact match in the credential page. If
not found then search for the missing one.
Wait until google refreshes it. May happen in each half an hour if you
are changing frequently or it may stay in the pool. For my case it was almost half an hour to take effect.
for me it was because in the 'Authorized redirect URIs' list I've incorrectly put https://developers.google.com/oauthplayground/ instead of https://developers.google.com/oauthplayground (without / at the end).
The redirect url is case sensitive.
In my case I added both:
http://localhost:5023/AuthCallback/IndexAsync
http://localhost:5023/authcallback/indexasync
If you use this tutorial: https://developers.google.com/identity/sign-in/web/server-side-flow then you should use "postmessage".
In GO this fixed the problem:
confg = &oauth2.Config{
RedirectURL: "postmessage",
ClientID: ...,
ClientSecret: ...,
Scopes: ...,
Endpoint: google.Endpoint,
}
beware of the extra / at the end of the url
http://localhost:8000 is different from http://localhost:8000/
It has been answered thoroughly but recently (like, a month ago) Google stopped accepting my URI and it would not worked. I know for a fact it did before because there is a user registered with it.
Anyways, the problem was the regular 400: redirect_uri_mismatch but the only difference was that it was changing from https:// to http://, and Google will not allow you to register http:// redirect URI as they are production publishing status (as opposed to localhost).
The problem was in my callback (I use Passport for auth) and I only did
callbackURL: "/register/google/redirect"
Read docs and they used a full URL, so I changed it to
callbackURL: "https://" + process.env.MY_URL+ "/register/google/redirect"
Added https localhost to my accepted URI so I could test locally, and it started working again.
TL;DR use the full URL so you know where you're redirecting
2015 July 15 - the signin that was working last week with this script on login
<script src="https://apis.google.com/js/platform.js" async defer></script>
stopped working and started causing Error 400 with Error: redirect_uri_mismatch
and in the DETAILS section: redirect_uri=storagerelay://...
i solved it by changing to:
<script src="https://apis.google.com/js/client:platform.js?onload=startApp"></script>
Rails users (from the omniauth-google-oauth2 docs):
Fixing Protocol Mismatch for redirect_uri in Rails
Just set the full_host in OmniAuth based on the Rails.env.
# config/initializers/omniauth.rb
OmniAuth.config.full_host = Rails.env.production? ? 'https://domain.com' : 'http://localhost:3000'
REMEMBER: Do not include the trailing "/"
None of the above solutions worked for me. below did
change authorised Redirect urls to - https://localhost:44377/signin-google
Hope this helps someone.
My problem was that I had http://localhost:3000/ in the address bar and had http://127.0.0.1:3000/ in the console.developers.google.com
Just make sure that you are entering URL and not just a domain.
So instead of:
domain.com
it should be
domain.com/somePathWhereYouHadleYourRedirect
Anyone struggling to find where to set redirect urls in the new console: APIs & Auth -> Credentials -> OAuth 2.0 client IDs -> Click the link to find all your redirect urls
My two cents:
If using the Google_Client library do not forget to update the JSON file on your server after updating the redirect URI's.
I also get This error Error-400: redirect_uri_mismatch
This is not a server or Client side error but you have to only change by checking that you haven't to added / (forward slash) at the end like this
redirecting URL list ❌:
https://developers.google.com/oauthplayground/
Do this only ✅:
https://developers.google.com/oauthplayground
Let me complete #Bazyl's answer: in the message I received, they mentioned the URI
"http://localhost:8080/"
(which of course, seems an internal google configuration). I changed the authorized URI for that one,
"http://localhost:8080/" , and the message didn't appear anymore... And the video got uploaded... The APIS documentation is VERY lame... Every time I have something working with google apis, I simply feel "lucky", but there's a lack of good documentation about it.... :( Yes, I got it working, but I don't yet understand neither why it failed, nor why it worked... There was only ONE place to confirm the URI in the web, and it got copied in the client_secrets.json... I don't get if there's a THIRD place where one should write the same URI... I find nor only the documentation but also the GUI design of Google's api quite lame...
I needed to create a new client ID under APIs & Services -> Credentials -> Create credentials -> OAuth -> Other
Then I downloaded and used the client_secret.json with my command line program that is uploading to my youtube account. I was trying to use a Web App OAuth client ID which was giving me the redirect URI error in browser.
I have frontend app and backend api.
From my backend server I was testing by hitting google api and was facing this error. During my whole time I was wondering of why should I need to give redirect_uri as this is just the backend, for frontend it makes sense.
What I was doing was giving different redirect_uri (though valid) from server (assuming this is just placeholder, it just has only to be registered to google) but my frontend url that created token code was different. So when I was passing this code in my server side testing(for which redirect-uri was different), I was facing this error.
So don't do this mistake. Make sure your frontend redirect_uri is same as your server's as google use it to validate the authenticity.
The main reason for this issue will only come from chrome and chrome handles WWW and non www differently depending on how you entered your URL in the browsers and it searches from google and directly shows the results, so the redirection URL sent is different in a different case
Add all the possible combinations you can find the exact url sent from fiddler , the 400 error pop up will not give you the exact http and www infromation
Try to do these checks:
Bundle ID in console and in your application. I prefer set Bundle ID of application like this "org.peredovik.${PRODUCT_NAME:rfc1034identifier}"
Check if you added URL types at tab Info just type your Bundle ID in Identifier and URL Schemes, role set to Editor
In console at cloud.google.com "APIs & auth" -> "Consent screen" fill form about your application. "Product name" is required field.
Enjoy :)
I have a web application(Jboss) as following https://ourURL/intranet/index.xhtml
If you are not authenticated we redirect the users to the Access management system (Oracle webgate 11.1.1) that uses PIV card to login. After the authentication user redirects back to ourURL/intranet/index.xhtml and happy.
Underneath, I use isapi_redirect.dll with ajp
Lately very randomly, when users are doing some post actions (submitting a form and etc), they get redirected to the Access management System like if they are sessioned out or not authenticated, and when they sign in again with their piv card they are redirected to the following url:
ourURL/intranet/isapi_redirect.dll
So it acts like if the user was trying to request /isapi_redirect.dll, user is not authenticated, they authenticate and then user goes to /isapi_redirect.dll and 404.
Logs does not tell much other than like following.
2017-09-29 22:39:42 165.112.255.29 POST /intranet/isapi_redirect.dll - 80 - 165.112.255.25 Mozilla/5.0+(Windows+NT+6.1;+WOW64)+AppleWebKit/537.36+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Chrome/61.0.3163.100+Safari/537.36 404 0 0 46
Have you ever get redirected to /isapi_redirect.dll directly? Any direction or similar situation with a solution would be helpful trouble shooting this.
Thanks.
OK. I was able to reproduce the issue and found the quick solution for now.
Reproduce:
I was uploading a document, searching for some data, submitting something or overall doing some POST action. And 60 mins after the initial authentication I got redirected to the authentication page, I had to re-authenticate and then directed back to 404.
The oracle webgate has the following config file, ObAccessClient.xml
And it has the following :
<SimpleList>
<NameValPair
ParamName="tokenValidityPeriod"
Value="3600"></NameValPair>
</SimpleList>
So after 60 min, the token was invalidated and needed to issue a new token. When it gets redirected to the authentication page, it remembered where to go back and somehow it was /isapi_redirect.dll?
For a workaround, I am bumping the number up. Better config or changes are needed on the webgate side, but I was able to at least find what the issue was.
I am using Ionic to build a login system on top of Codeigniter/Ion_Auth/codeigniter-restclient and when I try to login from "ionic server" the login works but the next api request to the logged_in() method returns false.
The same thing works properly when I point the browser to the www folder.
So here is the problem step by step:
run ionic serve
you see the login form (http://localhost:8100/#/app/login)
enter email and pass
the rest api returns "login successful"
$state.go('app.profile') works and redirects to http://localhost:8100/#/app/profile
REST get api/logged_in returns false and I redirect to the login page
If I do the same in a regular browser, step 1 becomes: open browser and go to http://localhost:8888/App/www/#/app/login, at step 6 REST get api/logged_in returns true and I don't get redirected to the login page, I stay on the profile page.
The code is the same. So my guess is that maybe ion_auth doesn't get the cookies it wants or the session is reseted. I am not sure at this point what the problem is. This is my first Ionic/App project so I might be missing something about the proper way to authenticate from a mobile app using code that works in browsers
Thank you
UPDATE:
It seems that when using the 'ionic server' window every request to the API triggers a new session. The new session is stored in the database and ion_auth tests the logged_in against that last one, which doesn't contain the login details.
you were taking about REST api and cookies and sessions. Cookies and sessions don't go with REST philosophy. Here is why.
Let me tell you how we accomplish this problem in our project. Basic way of knowing which user is requesting and if it has the access rights is by the 'Authorization' header value. You can use Basic Authentication, Barer or any other.
We generally prefer token based authorisation system. When a login is successful, server sends a token. In ionic app, we save it using a factory called SessionService. So whenever user logs in, token is stored and is used for every request. But token would be lost if user closes the app. So we can store it in local storage. User can then be directly redirected to dashboard until user logs out.
app.factory("SessionService", function($window){
var user={};
if ($window.localStorage['user']!=undefined){
user=JSON.parse($window.localStorage['user']);
console.log(user);
}
return{
isLoggedIn:function(){
return !isEmpty(user);
},
logout:function(){
console.log("logout")
user={};
$window.localStorage.clear();
},
setUser:function(data){
user=data;
$window.localStorage['user']= JSON.stringify(user);
},
getUser:function(){
return user;
}
}
})
Now in every web request, you can call SessionService.getUser().token when setting value Authorization header.
UPDATE:
Despite using cookies is not recommended, you can use it in your application easily.
If you are sending request with CORS, angular doesn't sends cookies with request.
One of the way address this issue is to send withCredentials: true with every request:
$http({withCredentials: true, ...}).get(...)
Read further about this here.
Hope this helps!