Accessing collection from a relationship - laravel

Question

So I have 2 tables.
DirtyEvent model and Event model.
I am retrieving DirtyEvent with Event which works fine
In blade I have:
#if (\Request::is('profile/event'))
#foreach ($events as $event)
#if (empty( $event->image ))
<div class="card-header">
<span class="card-title"> {{($event->title) }}</span>
</div>
#else
<div class="card-image">
<img class="img-responsive" src="{{ $event->image }}"></img>
<span class="card-title"> {{($event->title) }}</span>
</div>
#endif
<div class="card-content">
<p><strong>Starts: </strong>#php echo ($startdate) #endphp - {{$event->startime }}</p>
<br>
#if ($startdate != $enddate)
<p><strong>Ends: </strong>#php echo ($enddate) #endphp - {{$event->endtime }}</p>
<br>
#endif
<p><strong>Description:</strong></p>
<br>
<p>{{$event->description }}</p>
</div>
<div class="card-action">
<i class="fa fa-pencil-square-o fa-2x" aria-hidden="true"></i>
<form method="POST" action={{ url('events/delete/' . $event->id) }}>
{{ method_field('PATCH') }}
{{ csrf_field() }}
<button type="submit" class="delete" style="border:none;"><i class="fa fa-trash-o fa-2x" aria-hidden="true"></i></button>
</form>
</div>
#foreach ($events->publicevents as $eventss)
{{dd($events)}}
#endforeach
#endforeach
However dd($events) gives me:
DirtyEvent Collection -> relations -> publicevents -> Event collection
But, It is saying that publicevents do not exist in current collection.
Controller
public function index()
{
$id = Auth::id();
$events = DirtyEvent::where('user_id', $id)
->with('publicevents')
->get();
return view('events.viewEvent', compact('events'));
}
Model
public function publicevents()
{
return $this->hasMany('App\Event', 'event_id');
}

Answer 1

I guess not all dirty event objects have events. So check this first with empty() or isEmpty() or count():
#if (!empty($event->publicevents))
#foreach ($event->publicevents as $eventss)
{{ $eventss->id }}
#endforeach
#endif
Update
It should be $event->publicevents, not $events->publicevetns.