I'm struggling with the following code.
#!/bin/bash
test-one () {
if [[ ! -z $1 ]] ; then
echo "You are in function test-one with arg $1"
else
echo "You are in function test-one with no args"
fi
}
while getopts ":a:b:" opt; do
case $opt in
a) test-one ${OPTARG}
exit;;
b) FOO=${OPTARG}
exit;;
esac
done
I's just like to call the function test-one whether the optional argument is passed or not.
What I am looking for is:
./script.sh -a argument1
would results in:
You are in function test-one with arg argument1
While:
./script.sh -a
would results in:
You are in function test-one with no args
Far by now the example "./script.sh -a" simply skip the function call ...
What am I doing wrong?
Thanks!
Regarding error-reporting, there are two modes getopts can run in:
verbose mode & silent mode
For productive scripts I recommend to use the silent mode, since everything looks more professional, when you don't see annoying standard messages. Also it's easier to handle, since the failure cases are indicated in an easier way.
Verbose Mode
invalid option VARNAME is set to ?(question-mark) and OPTARG is unset
required argument not found VARNAME is set to ?(question-mark), OPTARG is unset and an error message is printed
Silent Mode
invalid option VARNAME is set to ?(question-mark) and OPTARG is set to the (invalid) option character
required argument not found VARNAME is set to :(colon) and OPTARG contains the option-character in question
Try this:
#!/bin/bash
while getopts ":a:" opt; do
case $opt in
a)
echo "-a was triggered, Parameter: $OPTARG" >&2
;;
\?)
echo "Invalid option: -$OPTARG" >&2
exit 1
;;
:) echo "Option -$OPTARG requires an argument." >&2
exit 1
;;
esac
done
When a -a is passed you will pass the value on the command line that is given as the argument to -a, stored in OPTARG. In your second example you there is no such argument, so the value gets an empty string, which is dutifully passed to the function.
Unfortunately here, a 0-length string is not preserved as an argument, and at least would in fact be a 0-length string which would "pass" the -z test.
So for "what you are doing wrong" it seems that you are expecting an empty argument to be treated as a non empty argument. You could test OPTARG before using it as an argument if you wanted to verify that -a did in fact have a value passed along with it.
Related
I want getopts to recognize when a user passes "-?" and "-h" and send to my help function.
I also don't want getopts to send the user to the help function if an invalid option is presented. I want a different message to display telling them it was an invalid option and send to stderr.
Here is my options section:
options(){
# grab options flags before entering application:
while getopts ":h?vu:d" opts; do
case "${opts}"
in
h\?) # Help
help_section
exit 0
;;
v) # Version
version
exit 0
;;
u) # units
other_units="$OPTARG"
;;
d) # Debug
debug=1
;;
\?) # Invalid options
echo "no here"
>&2 echo "[!] ERROR: Invalid Option: -$OPTARG"
exit 1
;;
esac
done
shift $((OPTIND -1))
# Run main function
main_run "$#"
}
Problem: getopts keeps sending the user to help when they put an invalid option in. I need to make sure the user recognizes they provided an invalid parameter; I do not want to send them to help.
Is there a way to implement this with getopts? Or build logic outside of getopts to capture and perform what I need?
Bash Command Line Input Example
The following example shows how to take various types of inputs and default to an invalid input option.
# -- Get input options (if any)
function get_user_input_options() {
if [[ $# -lt 1 ]];then
echo "no input, help infomration"
#show_help_info_function
exit
fi
while [[ $# > 0 ]] ;do
key="$1"
case ${key,,} in
-o|--opt)
echo " we a seting option=$2"
option=2
shift
;;
-\?|-h|--\?|--help)
echo "help information"
#show_help_info_function # a function that prints help and exits
exit;
;;
*)
echo "not understanding your input at all!"
exit;
;;
esac
shift
done
}
get_user_input_options "$#"
What is going on here?
We read in all of the inputs and based on the type we can shift to the next or shift twice. If you see --opt is used, it is expecting something after which would be set to a variable. More on point of your issue, we accept -? or --? and if that happens it will do what is within the section of help; if none of these inputs is processed, it will do whatever the default is in the section '*' which means any input. Note: this is just an example and in this case the help section causes the script to stop even if other inputs were provided, this may or may not be what you personally are looking to do.
Example output
$ ./args.sh -o something
we a seting option=something
$ ./args.sh -j somethingelse
not understading your input at all!
$ ./args.sh -?
help information
$ ./args.sh
no input, help infomration
$ ./args.sh -h
help information
I am inexperienced with bash shell scripting, and have run into a problem with bash optarg
Here's a small script to reproduce the problem:
#!/bin/sh
while getopts ":a:b:" opt; do
case ${opt} in
a ) echo "a=$OPTARG"
;;
b ) echo "b=$OPTARG"
;;
\? ) echo "Invalid option: $OPTARG" 1>&2
;;
: ) echo "Invalid option: $OPTARG requires an argument" 1>&2
esac
done
When I try this:
./args.sh -a av -b bv
I get the expected result:
a=av
b=bv
But when I omit the argument for -a:
/args.sh -a -b bv
I get this unfortunate result:
a=-b
When I would expect an error to show that the value of -a is missing.
It seems to have taken the -b argument as the value for -a.
Have I done something wrong & how can I achieve the expected behaviour?
The only positive advice is how do you treat But when I omit the argument for '-a', you cannot just skip to the next subsequent option. By convention getopts a: means you are expecting to an provide an arg value for the flag defined.
So even for the omitting case, you need to define an empty string which means the value for the arg is not defined i.e.
-a '' -b bv
Or if you don't expect the -a to get any arg values, better change the option string to not receive any as :ab:.
Any other ways of working around by checking if the OPTARG for -a is does not contain - or other hacks are not advised as it does not comply with the getopts() work flow.
getopts doesn't support such detection. So there's no way to do that with getopts.
You can probably write a loop around the arguments instead. something like:
#!/bin/sh
check_option()
{
case $1 in
-*)
return 1
;;
esac
return 0
}
for opt in $#; do
case ${opt} in
-a) shift
if check_option $1; then
echo "arg for -a: $1"
shift
else
echo "Invalid option -a"
fi
;;
-b) shift
if check_option $1; then
echo "arg for -b: $1"
shift
else
echo "Invalid option -b"
fi
;;
esac
done
I wrote a bash script that takes flexible number of parameters and now I would like to add an optional argument (-l) to each of them.
I am currently having difficulty getting the desired behavior.
I want all of the following to execute correctly:
./Script.sh arg1 arg2 arg3 -l opt
./Script.sh arg1 arg2 arg3
./Script.sh arg1 arg2 arg3 arg4 -l opt
./Script.sh arg1 arg2 arg3 arg4 arg5
The problem is that $OPTIND cannot be set.
The following loop works if the -l opt is placed before first argument.
while getopts ":l:" option
do
case "$option" in
t)
F_NAME=$OPTARG
;;
esac
done
shift $((OPTIND - 1))
However, place the optional -l as last parameter is a requirement.
What's the easiest way to achieve this?
Here is a trick I have found to use arguments with optional parameters with getopts.
The way to manage the case where the optional parameter is inside the command is given by Jan Schampera in is reply on bash-hackers.org :
if [[ $OPTARG = -* ]]; then
((OPTIND--))
continue
fi
(see : http://wiki.bash-hackers.org/howto/getopts_tutorial deep in the page)
But it does not manage the case where the option is given at the end of the command.
In that case, that is considered wrong because no parameter is given, getopts set the opt variable to ':' (colon) and OPTARG to the fault option value.
So we have to manage the ':' case, with a case $OPTARG.
Let us say we write a script having three options :
a : without parameter
b : with a required parameter
v : to set the verbosity with a value from 0 to 2. The default value is 0 and a preset value is used when the script is called with -v without parameter or with a bad value.
Here is the code :
#!/bin/bash
VERBOSITY=0 # default verbosity set to 0
PRESET_VERBOSITY=1 # preset verbosity when asked
while getopts :ab:v: opt; do
case $opt in
a)
echo "manage option a"
;;
b)
echo "manage option b with value '$OPTARG'"
;;
v)
if [[ $OPTARG = -* ]]; then # Jan Schampera reply
echo "set verbosity to PRESET (no value given, not last position)"
VERBOSITY=$PRESET_VERBOSITY
((OPTIND--))
continue
fi
if [[ "$OPTARG" =~ ^[0-2]$ ]]; then
echo "set verbosity to $OPTARG (good value given)"
VERBOSITY=$OPTARG
else
echo "set verbosity to PRESET (bad value given)"
VERBOSITY=$PRESET_VERBOSITY
fi
;;
:)
case $OPTARG in
v)
echo "set verbosity to PRESET (no value given, last option)"
VERBOSITY=$PRESET_VERBOSITY
;;
esac
;;
\?)
echo "WTF!"
;;
esac
done
echo "**verbosity is set to $VERBOSITY**"
getopts conforms to the posix-standard command-line syntax where flag options come first. So it's not easy to use for non-standard cases.
However, you may have the Gnu implementation of getopt(1) (see man 1 getopt), which can handle permuted option flags as well as long options. However, it's not as easy an interface.
Or you can just interpret the argument yourself.
for ((i=1; i<=$#; ++i)); do
if [[ ${!i} == "-l" ]]; then
((++i))
OPT_L=${!i}
else
# handle the argument (in "${!i]")
fi
done
(Note: the above does not throw an error if the -l appears right at the end of the argument list; it just sets the option value to an empty string. If that's not appropriate, which it probably isn't, then insert some error checking.)
I have written the following shell script to parse arguments and print. Its not working as intended. I am sure that I am not passing correct argument to the function thats evaluating the optional params. Can some one please help is correcting it
#! /bin/sh
MAX_NO_OF_DATABASE=500;
MAX_NO_OF_CONCURRENT_REQUEST=500;
MAX_NO_OF_REQUEST=500;
function showUsage(){
echo "Sample Usage : ./benchmarking.sh <CORE_URL> <SYNC_SERVER_URL> [-d MAX_NO_OF_DATABASE] [-c MAX_NO_OF_CONCURRENT_REQUEST] [-n MAX_NO_OF_REQUEST]";
exit;
}
function readArguements(){
# Check for core url
if [ -z $1 ]; then
echo "CORE_URL is not specified"
showUsage
fi
# Check for sync server url
if [ -z $2 ]; then
echo "SYNC_SERVER_URL is not specified"
showUsage
fi
}
function readOptionalArguements(){
# Check for the optional parameters
while getopts dcn: opt
do
case $opt in
d) MAX_NO_OF_DATABASE="$OPTARG";;
c) MAX_NO_OF_CONCURRENT_REQUEST="$OPTARG";;
n) MAX_NO_OF_REQUEST="$OPTARG";;
esac
done
}
readArguements $*
readOptionalArguements $*
echo "$1 $2 $MAX_NO_OF_DATABASE $MAX_NO_OF_CONCURRENT_REQUEST $MAX_NO_OF_REQUEST"
When I run it ./benchmarker.sh core_url sync_url -d 500 -c 100 -n 200
It prints as
core_url sync_url 500 500 500
I had debugging on and I could see that it does not evaluate the switch block. Am I passing the correct arguments to readOptionalArguements
You should set the string to d:c:n:, because all three options take parameters.
Read carefully what man bash says about getopts:
When the end of options is encountered, getopts exits with a return
value greater than zero. OPTIND is set to the index of the first non-
option argument, and name is set to ?.
Therefore, you have to process the first two non-option parameters before processing the options.
core_url=$1
sync_server=$2
shift 2
readArguements "$#"
readOptionalArguements "$#"
Also, if you are using bash, do not write #!/bin/sh in the shebang line.
getopts stops on the first non-option argument, so you need to shift-out those non-option arguments before using them in getopts.
So for example:
function readOptionalArguements(){
# skip two mandatory arguments
shift 2
# Check for the optional parameters
while getopts d:c:n: opt
do
case $opt in
d) MAX_NO_OF_DATABASE="$OPTARG";;
c) MAX_NO_OF_CONCURRENT_REQUEST="$OPTARG";;
n) MAX_NO_OF_REQUEST="$OPTARG";;
esac
done
}
Also, you should declare a local OPTIND to keep that variable safe in case you call the function multiple times.
I believe, the problem may be in the readOptionalArguments method (btw, this is misspelled in your question). The following seems to work for me (in bash)
function readOptionalArguements() {
# Check for the optional parameters
while getopt "d:c:n:" $*
do
echo "opt: <$1>";
case $1 in
-d) shift; MAX_NO_OF_DATABASE="$1"; shift;;
-c) shift; MAX_NO_OF_CONCURRENT_REQUEST="$1"; shift;;
-n) shift; MAX_NO_OF_REQUEST="$1"; shift;;
--) break;;
*) break;;
esac
done
}
I'd like to be able to accept both mandatory and optional flags in my script. Here's what I have so far.
#!bin/bash
while getopts ":a:b:cdef" opt; do
case $opt in
a ) APPLE="$OPTARG";;
b ) BANANA="$OPTARG";;
c ) CHERRY="$OPTARG";;
d ) DFRUIT="$OPTARG";;
e ) EGGPLANT="$OPTARG";;
f ) FIG="$OPTARG";;
\?) echo "Invalid option: -"$OPTARG"" >&2
exit 1;;
: ) echo "Option -"$OPTARG" requires an argument." >&2
exit 1;;
esac
done
echo "Apple is "$APPLE""
echo "Banana is "$BANANA""
echo "Cherry is "$CHERRY""
echo "Dfruit is "$DFRUIT""
echo "Eggplant is "$EGGPLANT""
echo "Fig is "$FIG""
However, the output for the following:
bash script.sh -a apple -b banana -c cherry -d dfruit -e eggplant -f fig
...outputs this:
Apple is apple
Banana is banana
Cherry is
Dfruit is
Eggplant is
Fig is
As you can see, the optional flags are not pulling the arguments with $OPTARG as it does with the required flags. Is there a way to read $OPTARG on optional flags without getting rid of the neat ":)" error handling?
=======================================
EDIT: I wound up following the advice of Gilbert below. Here's what I did:
#!/bin/bash
if [[ "$1" =~ ^((-{1,2})([Hh]$|[Hh][Ee][Ll][Pp])|)$ ]]; then
print_usage; exit 1
else
while [[ $# -gt 0 ]]; do
opt="$1"
shift;
current_arg="$1"
if [[ "$current_arg" =~ ^-{1,2}.* ]]; then
echo "WARNING: You may have left an argument blank. Double check your command."
fi
case "$opt" in
"-a"|"--apple" ) APPLE="$1"; shift;;
"-b"|"--banana" ) BANANA="$1"; shift;;
"-c"|"--cherry" ) CHERRY="$1"; shift;;
"-d"|"--dfruit" ) DFRUIT="$1"; shift;;
"-e"|"--eggplant" ) EGGPLANT="$1"; shift;;
"-f"|"--fig" ) FIG="$1"; shift;;
* ) echo "ERROR: Invalid option: \""$opt"\"" >&2
exit 1;;
esac
done
fi
if [[ "$APPLE" == "" || "$BANANA" == "" ]]; then
echo "ERROR: Options -a and -b require arguments." >&2
exit 1
fi
Thanks so much, everyone. This works perfectly so far.
: means "takes an argument", not "mandatory argument". That is, an option character not followed by : means a flag-style option (no argument), whereas an option character followed by : means an option with an argument.
Thus, you probably want
getopts "a:b:c:d:e:f:" opt
If you want "mandatory" options (a bit of an oxymoron), you can check after argument parsing that your mandatory option values were all set.
It isn't easy... Any "optional" option arguments must actually be required as far as getopts will know. Of course, an optional argument must be a part of the same argument to the script as the option it goes with. Otherwise an option -f with an optional argument and an option -a with a required argument can get confused:
# Is -a an option or an argument?
./script.sh -f -a foo
# -a is definitely an argument
./script.sh -f-a foo
The only way to do this is to test whether the option and its argument are in the same argument to the script. If so, OPTARG is the argument to the option. Otherwise, OPTIND must be decremented by one. Of course, the option is now required to have an argument, meaning a character will be found when an option is missing an argument. Just use another case to determine if any options are required:
while getopts ":a:b:c:d:e:f:" opt; do
case $opt in
a) APPLE="$OPTARG";;
b) BANANA="$OPTARG";;
c|d|e|f)
if test "$OPTARG" = "$(eval echo '$'$((OPTIND - 1)))"; then
OPTIND=$((OPTIND - 1))
else
case $opt in
c) CHERRY="$OPTARG";;
d) DFRUIT="$OPTARG";;
...
esac
fi ;;
\?) ... ;;
:)
case "$OPTARG" in
c|d|e|f) ;; # Ignore missing arguments
*) echo "option requires an argument -- $OPTARG" >&2 ;;
esac ;;
esac
done
This has worked for me so far.
For bash, this is my favorite way to parse/support cli args. I used getopts and it was too frustrating that it wouldn't support long options. I do like how it works otherwise - especially for built-in functionality.
usage()
{
echo "usage: $0 -OPT1 <opt1_arg> -OPT2"
}
while [ "`echo $1 | cut -c1`" = "-" ]
do
case "$1" in
-OPT1)
OPT1_ARGV=$2
OPT1_BOOL=1
shift 2
;;
-OPT2)
OPT2_BOOL=1
shift 1
;;
*)
usage
exit 1
;;
esac
done
Short, simple. An engineer's best friend!
I think this can be modified to support "--" options as well...
Cheers =)
Most shell getopts have been annoying me for a long time, including lack of support of optional arguments.
But if you are willing to use "--posix" style arguments, visit bash argument case for args in $#
Understanding bash's getopts
The bash manual page (quoting the version 4.1 manual) for getopts says:
getopts optstring name[args]
getopts is used by shell scripts to parse positional parameters. optstring contains
the option characters to be recognized; if a character is followed by a
colon, the option is expected to have an argument, which should be separated
from it by white space. The colon (‘:’) and question mark (‘?’) may not be
used as option characters. Each time it is invoked, getopts places the next
option in the shell variable name, initializing name if it does not exist, and the
index of the next argument to be processed into the variable OPTIND. OPTIND
is initialized to 1 each time the shell or a shell script is invoked. When an
option requires an argument, getopts places that argument into the variable
OPTARG. The shell does not reset OPTIND automatically; it must be manually
reset between multiple calls to getopts within the same shell invocation if a
new set of parameters is to be used.
When the end of options is encountered, getopts exits with a return value
greater than zero. OPTIND is set to the index of the first non-option argument,
and name is set to ‘?’.
getopts normally parses the positional parameters, but if more arguments are
given in args, getopts parses those instead.
getopts can report errors in two ways. If the first character of optstring is a
colon, silent error reporting is used. In normal operation diagnostic messages
are printed when invalid options or missing option arguments are encountered.
If the variable OPTERR is set to 0, no error messages will be displayed, even if
the first character of optstring is not a colon.
If an invalid option is seen, getopts places ‘?’ into name and, if not silent,
prints an error message and unsets OPTARG. If getopts is silent, the option
character found is placed in OPTARG and no diagnostic message is printed.
If a required argument is not found, and getopts is not silent, a question mark
(‘?’) is placed in name, OPTARG is unset, and a diagnostic message is printed. If
getopts is silent, then a colon (‘:’) is placed in name and OPTARG is set to the
option character found.
Note that:
The leading colon in the option string puts getopts into silent mode; it does not generate any error messages.
The description doesn't mention anything about optional option arguments.
I'm assuming that you are after functionality akin to:
script -ffilename
script -f
where the flag f (-f) optionally accepts an argument. This is not supported by bash's getopts command. The POSIX function getopt() barely supports that notation. In effect, only the last option on a command line can have an optional argument under POSIX.
What are the alternatives?
In part, consult Using getopts in bash shell script to get long and short command-line options.
The GNU getopt (singular!) program is a complex beastie that supports long and short options and supports optional arguments for long options (and uses GNU getopt(3). Tracking its source is entertaining; the link on the page at die.net is wrong; you'll find it in a sub-directory under ftp://ftp.kernel.org/pub/linux/utils/util-linux (without the -ng). I've not tracked down a location at http://www.gnu.org/ or http://www.fsf.org/ that contains it.
#!/bin/bash
while getopts ":a:b:c:d:e:f:" opt; do
case $opt in
a ) APPLE="$OPTARG";;
b ) BANANA="$OPTARG";;
c ) CHERRY="$OPTARG";;
d ) DFRUIT="$OPTARG";;
e ) EGGPLANT="$OPTARG";;
f ) FIG="$OPTARG";;
\?) echo "Invalid option: -"$OPTARG"" >&2
exit 1;;
: ) echo "Option -"$OPTARG" requires an argument." >&2
exit 1;;
esac
done
echo "Apple is "$APPLE""
echo "Banana is "$BANANA""
echo "Cherry is "$CHERRY""
echo "Dfruit is "$DFRUIT""
echo "Eggplant is "$EGGPLANT""
echo "Fig is "$FIG""