I have a couple projects that make up a module, and I want to build them automatically. The module consists of a plain JAR API, an EJB, an EAR, a plug-in and a RCP product, so building it with either Maven or Tycho is not possible. I want to evaluate if it is possible using Gradle.
The last couple days I tried to figure out how that is done, and I'm not sure why there is so little support to build RCP applications using Gradle, especially since Gradle has overtaken Maven on the build automation front.
What I tried:
BuildMonkey - gets it's repositories directly (and unmodifiable) from https://ftp.heanet.ie, which is down
Wuff! - doesn't work with the latest Gradle version
GradlePlugins - for Gradle 0.9, last commit was 8 years ago
DiffPlug - example project leads to NoClassDefFoundError
Is there some great tool I'm missing? Something has to work? Especially considering Tycho isn't in use either. Maybe it's really Eclipse RCP that nobody uses anymore?
This question is similar, but old - and I tried the tools in the answers.
Related
As of Java 11 it is necessary to get JAXB from a separate library, not from the JDK. There are plenty of tutorials on the Web showing how to do that, but they all use Maven. The project I need to fix is an Eclipse RCP application. There does not seem to be an easy to make that work with Maven, as Maven essentially takes over most of what Eclipse would do but doesn't have RCP development capabilities.
Sooner or later Maven gets the required libraries. I would like to find another way to get and use whatever libraries are needed, just without using Maven. It should be possible. I just haven't found it.
Thanks.
I did what I wanted by downloading the needed JARs from https://mvnrepository.com/.
I am a total beginner at maven, I have read about it online but I am still confused how it can be used. I have eclipse Oxygen version installed and when I open projects I can see maven project option is already there. I was even able to create a maven project using YouTube tutorial. But now then I saw popular plugin called m2eclipse but I am not able to comprehend why is it actually used; when my application ran without it.
I am learning maven to get started with spring boot but I am finding it really overwhelming where to begin with, and many of the tutorial sites state to download maven (But maven already comes along with eclipse?)
Please explain.
Apache Maven is a build tool - a tool for compiling the source code of a project into a program that you can run (for example a jar file, or a war file that can be deployed on a Java EE application server). Besides automating all the tasks for building a project, it also gives you a standard way to organize your project and to keep track of dependencies (libraries that your project needs).
Why do you need such a tool?
When you write a small program that consists of one, or maybe a few source files, it's easy enough to compile it by hand on the command line, by directly using the Java compiler javac that comes with the JDK.
But when your project becomes more complex, and you have hundreds or even thousands of source files in multiple modules, it becomes really hard to keep track of everything and cumbersome to compile the files using javac. If your program needs libraries, it becomes even more complex, because you have to make sure that all the libraries are on the classpath, and some libraries need other libraries, which also have to be on the classpath.
A tool such as Maven helps you to compile all the source files in the right order and to keep track of all the libraries. Maven can automatically download libraries from the web and add them to your project, and downloading everything and building the whole project can be done with one simple command such as mvn clean package.
Spring Boot is part of the Spring Framework, which is a huge framework with tons of useful functionality for developing projects in Java. A Spring Boot project typically needs dozens of libraries, and it would be very hard to use if you'd have to keep track of all those libraries by hand - so that's why it uses Maven to manage all of this for you.
A Maven project is configured using a file named pom.xml - in that file, you describe your project and you put a list of libraries that your project needs. When you build your project, Maven will read the pom.xml file and figure out automatically what source files need to be compiled, and what libraries need to be downloaded.
m2eclipse comes preinstalled in Eclipse (at least when selecting "Eclipse for Java developers" or "Eclipse for Java EE developer"), thats why you were able to use Maven by default.
Still you probably want a command line Maven, because that's most likely how it will eventually run on the CI server, sometimes Eclipse Maven installation can produce different result than the command line install.
As I am new to learn either maven or Gradle build tools. Therefore I wonder which one I select to study between maven and Gradle and which one has more requirement and demand in the industry. I want to use these build tools for Spring and Hibernate based projects. Any suggestion would be very helpful.
Thanks
Before this is closed for "not being a good question", I'll get some comments in.
You might want to learn the same thing that most other developers want to learn. Look at the third slide of the following slideware, which shows the results of Zeroturnaround's yearly developer survey. For this set of >2k developers, when asked what technologies they were interested in learning, Gradle was at the top of the list.
You can use either Maven or Gradle to build projects using Spring or Hibernate, but it's useful to point out that both the Spring and Hibernate code bases (not necessarily the applications using them) use Gradle to build their deliverables.
Maven provided the best build solution for quite a few years, but it's difficult to customize a build, and most Maven build scripts are very "noisy". Gradle solves those problems, while providing a smooth migration path from Maven or even Ant.
I am trying to evaluate Gradle as next-gen build tool for some of my future projects.
Steps I've done so far:
I have Java 7 installed on my machine.
Installed Gradle 2.0
Installed Spring Tool Suite 3.6.1, went to dashboard and added support for
Gradle and installed also Groovy-Eclipse package.
Now when I start Gradle projects from scratch or I clone some of the projects from github,
I am not able to get context sensitive help, like Ctrl + Space to autocomplete stuff in
build.gradle file.
I was reading a lot of documentation on net about this, and couldn't find proper answer, so if someone can give me some idea is it working?
Previously I was using Maven, and m2-eclipse, so when I type in pom.xml I am able to do Ctrl + Space which prevents me to make typo mistakes.
NOTE: Just please note that I've enabled Gradle DSL support for my Gradle projects.
Thank You
Gradle's build language is much more dynamic, extensible, and powerful than a Maven POM, and hence it's much harder to develop full IDE support for it. Recent versions of the Eclipse Gradle Plugin have limited editing support, and work is underway to take it to the next level. IntelliJ 14 is already further along, but expect to see further improvements there as well.
I have been in charge for the past 5 years of the development and the maintenance of a GWT project which consists of 6 different WebApps. The project is using GWT 1.5 and is built with ant (for either mode dev/war). These webapps are deployed on apache-tomcat, the production site run version 5.5 whereas we run (for testing) version 7.0.
To emphasize user experience, I would like to migrate the GWT version to a more recent one (of which I have no idea so far); I have read many things about migrating, regarding deprecated APIs, improvments made frome one version to another and I have still structural questions dealing with the new project layout itself.
Currently, the layout is the following:
WebXXX
-src
-net.yyy.webxxx
-common
-client
-server
-public
-Common.gwt.xml
-module1
-client
-server
-public
-module1.gwt.xml
-[...]
-test
-build
-build.xml
-buildModule1.xml
-[..]
-Dependencies(SVN_Externals)
-www
-compile-all-modules.xml
-compile-module1.xml
-WebXXXHosted.xml
-[..]
To explicit things a bit, the fodler Dependencies is a place-holder for linking Workspace sources with an external widgets library. This library is built at compile time (when building all modules or just one within an ant task) and the resulting jar is injected into the module WEB-INF/lib directory. That widget library does use gxt.1.1.1 and gwt-incubator 1.5.
Over the years, writing a new ant task for each new WebApp seemed to be the solution but now that we are also using maven, I am wondering if I must convert the project to a maven project before doing the migration or if I can skip, for now, the maven conversion.
Since I guess maven is not absolutely required and since the project includes several customized ant tasks to have it run (in dev mode), I am also wondering if I could (instead) migrate the related GWT jars in a version which is such that I won't have to rewrite all the UI though I know I will have major replacement to do and extensive tests to run.
Feel free to enlighten me about the way I could go (maven or not, the version of gwt I should migrate to, the related gxt version (if it's still relevant) to use) because I am in complete darkness !
Thanks for all,
Cheers !
Go one step at a time.
Always use the latest version (and migrate ASAP when a new version comes out). That being said, there've been reports of 2.5 and 2.5.1 having a few regressions in GWT-RPC, so if it doesn't work, try using 2.4 (but try 2.5.1 first!)
You'll have to update your GXT dependency too (I have no idea how they deal with backwards compatibility at Sencha and how much it will break your code –or not–; and again try to stay up-to-date)
gwt-incubator is deprecated for long, so be prepared to replace some of the widgets, and in the long run you'll want to totally remove that dependency.
don't move to Maven until after you upgraded GWT, unless upgrading breaks your Ant tasks too much (then try moving to Maven and then upgrading GWT; but 1.5 is a really old version so I have no idea how well it works with Maven).
Re. Maven, GWT will soon use Maven too and will provide an official plugin. Alpha versions of that plugin can be found at https://github.com/tbroyer/gwt-maven-plugin (I've received rather positive feedback for now); or you can use the gwt-maven-plugin from CodeHaus, or simply call the GWT Compiler with the exec-maven-plugin (or the antrun-maven-plugin). As for the project layout, see http://blog.ltgt.net/announcing-gwt-maven-archetypes-project, this is the layout the official GWT plugin will be based on (and again, mostly positive feedback so far).
If you are planning to do both migrate to gwt and maven, I would face first to migrate the existing project to maven. You have to be sure that all dependencies are in maven repositories or you know how to deal with local repositories. Once you have everything mavenized in modules and you can import the projects in eclipse (maybe you need an old gwt plugin) and run all tasks I would try to migrate module by module selecting the appropriate dependencies.
I think updating dependencies with maven is pretty easier than dealing with ant, but of course you could select the other way if you feel more conifrtable.
Anyway, the task of migrating a gwt application from 1.5 to 2.5.1 could be hard. First you have to know how the evolution of gwt to know which issues could come to your app (new widgets interfaces, handlers, etc).
You are depending on gwt-incubator which has been discontinued since some years ago, maybe you have a build which could work with gwt-2.5.1, but probably there are many things which dont work any more. There are some features which have been moved from incubator to gwt like cell-lists, date-picker, etc, so you have to rewrite your code using new stuff in gwt.
Your project depends on an old gxt version, they have made many changes in theirs api, and I think you have to deal with a lot of changes in your code as well.
In summary, mavenizing an ant project is not so difficult and you have plenty of information in the web, but porting a gwt app from 1.5 to 2.5.1 is not a trivial task, if you dont have a good suite of tests it could be harder, so be prepared to spend a lot of time figuring out how to replace old things and to fix issues.