I know that I can pass variables to a Makefile in two ways:
make <target> FOO=bar
export FOO=bar
make <target>
and that both of these will make a variable FOO available in the makefile with value bar.
However, is there a way to require that the variable only comes from the command line? I want the passing of variables to be explicit in order to avoid certain potential overlaps of environment variables, so I want to ensure make only receives the variable if passed from the command line, and to disregard it if it's only set in the environment so that the value it uses must be defined by the user when calling make.
EDIT: I realize after researching it a bit more that environment variables are not actually accessed the way I thought they are, they're actually used within make as ${FOO} so as long as I don't define FOO at any point in the makefile, its only set value will be from the command line (as noted in this answer).
These methods to pass variables to GNU make aren't equivalent.
Variables that come from the environment don't override the assignments in makefile, unless make is invoked with -e option. See variables from the environment. This is because depending on environment variables is poor practice in terms of build reproducibility (someone forgets to set the environment variable and the build is different):
It is not wise for makefiles to depend for their functioning on environment variables set up outside their control, since this would cause different users to get different results from the same makefile. This is against the whole purpose of most makefiles.
Variables that come from make command line do override assignments in makefile, unless override is specified. See the override directive.
Hence, the recommended practice is to explicitly set all your variables to their default values in the makefile unconditionally, so that only the assignments from the command line override them.
As far as I know, there's no difference between ${FOO} and $(FOO), regardless of the way FOO is defined.
If you're using GNU make, there's a function origin that allows you to make the distinction: it will return command line for a variable defined on the command line and environment for a variable exported by the environment (more info in the manual)
with the following Makefile:
foo ?= foo
default:
#echo ${foo}, comes from $(origin foo)
make prints foo, comes from file
make foo=bla prints bla, comes from command line
(export foo=bar; make) prints bar, comes from environment
expanding on #Virgile answer, you could add the following kind of check at the start of the makefile. It is a lot to repeat for each variable you wish to check, although all such checks could reside in a dedicated makefile that is then included from main makefile
foo ?= foo
# check origin
ifdef foo
ifneq "$(origin foo)" "command line"
$(error foo: must come from command line)
endif
else
$(error foo not defined)
endif
default:
#echo ${foo}, comes from $(origin foo)
Related
let's assume the following Makefile:
FOO=1
BAR?=test
BLAH:=$(BAR)
target:
#echo "helloworld"
Is there a way it can show me variables like this (\n or \s) ?
FOO
BAR
BLAH
bonus question:
if it is possible, is there a way to also get external variables?
make target BLABLAH=toto or export BLABLAH=toto; make target
FOO
BAR
BLAH
BLABLAH
You don't say so specifically but because of the syntax I'll assume you're using GNU make. In that case you can use the .VARIABLES special variable:
$(info Variables: $(.VARIABLES))
Note, that make target BLABLBAH=toto does not create an "external variable" (that term is not well-defined so I'm just guessing that by this you mean variables that are inherited from the environment and not set in the makefile). Setting a variable on the command line creates a real make variable and it will be shown in the list above.
Variables obtained from the environment are imported into make as makefile variables and will also appear in the above list.
Note: This question was originally posted as a rant by a now-deleted user, but there was a valid question behind the rant; this is my attempt to provide an answer.
Given the Makefile:
ifeq "$(MAKELEVEL)" "0"
# Override the command-line specification of "foo".
override foo=replaced
export foo
all::
#echo outer: foo is "$(foo)"
#$(MAKE)
else
# Variable 'foo' was "exported" from the top-level Makefile.
all::
#echo inner: foo is "$(foo)"
endif
The expectation is that export foo will cause make to export the value defined in the override declaration. But it doesn't:
$ make -s foo=original
outer: foo is replaced
inner: foo is original
The expectation is probably reasonable, but it turns out that this is not the way Gnu make works. It could well be that the make documentation could be improved to clarify the process, but the hints all seem to be there.
How variables get their values
A variable can be set by the programmer in three ways:
On the command line with a var=value command-line argument
Explicitly in the make file
From the environment
The above list is the normal priority order; the first definition found in the list "wins". However, you can use the override directive to swap the priorities of the first two methods. (You can also use the -e flag to make to swap the priorities of the last two methods. The -e flag is required by Posix, but its use is discouraged and it does not interact will with override.)
How variables are passed to sub-makes
make is very similar to a shell in that the environment is used to pass variable values. If a variable is marked as exported, then its value is placed into the environment for any processes initiated by make, including sub-makes. As with the shell, a variable is marked as exported if its definition came from the environment or if it is explicitly marked as exported with the export directive. Variables are also exported if they were set on the command line.
However, there is another mechanism by which variables on the command-line are passed to subprocesses: the MAKEFLAGS exported variable.. MAKEFLAGS contains (most) command-line options as well as all of the command-line variable overrides. If make finds MAKEFLAGS in the environment, it merges the settings in that variable with the ones actually specified on its command line. That means that command-line variable settings in a make will also take priority in a sub-make.
Since command-line variable settings are passed through the MAKEFLAGS variable, they are not subject to any changes in the makefile. A makefile can unexport or override a variable set on the command-line, but that will only affect the value (or presence) of the variable in the environment; it does not remove or change the value from MAKEFLAGS.
Resolution
So if the intent is to override (or modify) a command-line variable both in the make itself and in the environment of sub-makes, it is necessary to use both an override and an explicit modification of MAKEFLAGS. (As explained in the make manual, MAKEFLAGS is actually recursively composed using the MAKEOVERRIDES variable, so we actually modify that variable.)
ifeq "$(MAKELEVEL)" "0"
# Override the command-line specification of "foo".
override foo=replaced
MAKEOVERRIDES += foo=replaced
all::
#echo outer: foo is "$(foo)"
#$(MAKE) -s
else
# Variable 'foo' was "exported" from the top-level Makefile.
all::
#echo inner: foo is "$(foo)"
endif
And now we get the expected result:
$ make -s foo=original
outer: foo is replaced
inner: foo is replaced
Real-life application: dealing with whitespace
The primary intention of overrides is to allow the makefile to append words to a variable possibly provided on the command line. The example provided in the gnu make manual is insisting that CFLAGS always includes the -g flag, even if it were specified on the make command line:
override CFLAGS += -g
Passing the append through to a sub-make needs a little caution; in particular, the obvious:
MAKEOVERRIDES += CFLAGS=$(CFLAGS) # Don't do this
won't work because the whitespace inside the CFLAGS variable will not be escaped when it is added to MAKEFLAGS; the result will be that MAKEFLAGS will look something like this:
-- CFLAGS=-O3 CFLAGS=-O3 -g
instead of the desired
-- CFLAGS=-O3 CFLAGS=-O3\ -g
If the value assigned to CFLAGS on the command line included whitespace, the whitespace is escaped in MAKEFLAGS. The particular escaping mechanism used is not documented, and Posix only requires that there be some mechanism; apparently, Gnu make uses backslash. It would be possible to manually backslash escape the whitespace, resulting in something like this:
# Don't do this either
MAKEOVERRIDES += CFLAGS=$(subst $(space),\ ,$(CFLAGS))
(The definition and use of space is based on an example in the gnu make manual.)
But it is actually easier to just use an append assignment in MAKEOVERRIDES, which is undocumented but appears to work. It works on the command line, too.
override CFLAGS+=-g
MAKEOVERRIDES += CFLAGS+=-g
Important Note as of make v4.1: A bit of testing revealed that the above stanza will only work if CFLAGS (or some other variable) is actually set on the command-line. I reported this bug as Savannah issue 46013, with a very simple fix in the bug report. In the meantime, if you really want to do this, use the following workaround:
override CFLAGS+=-g
MAKEOVERRIDES += CFLAGS+=-g
# This line is necessary in case there were no command-line overrides.
# In effect, it produces a command-line override, although that value
# will not be passed on to sub-makes.
MAKEFLAGS += dummy=dummy
Update May 19, 2019: Today I was informed that a fix for the bug referenced above has been committed, so it should be fixed in the next gmake release.
First of all, I want to point out that your suggestion to add to MAKEOVERRIDES, is dangerous!
And SHOULD NEVER BE DONE!!
You simply turn a recursive variable into a simple one, you will always get false results, if recursive expansion is done.
I can not believe that you got up-voted for this clearly wrong "suggestion".
And note this:
You can not even fix it with a quoted assignment, like MAKEOVERRIDES += foo=$$(bar)!!!
But, let me return to the main point of your post.
And, with which, I couldn't disagree more.
One simple example would be, if you run the very same makefile, that you have:
This one is copied verbatim, from your post:
ifeq "$(MAKELEVEL)" "0"
# Override the command-line specification of "foo".
override foo=replaced
export foo
all::
#echo outer: foo is "$(foo)"
#$(MAKE) -s
else
# Variable 'foo' was "exported" from the top-level Makefile.
all::
#echo inner: foo is "$(foo)"
endif
And running in any modern version, 4.0 and up:
# Sub-make does NOT get the value from the root-Make's command-line.
# Instead, it "inherits" the value from the root-Make's definition in the Makefile.
$ make -s foo=original -e
outer: foo is replaced
inner: foo is replaced
Now, given your assertion above:
However, there is another mechanism by which variables on the command-line are passed to subprocesses: the [MAKEFLAGS exported variable.][3]. MAKEFLAGS contains (most) command-line options as well as all of the command-line variable overrides. If make finds MAKEFLAGS in the environment, it merges the settings in that variable with the ones actually specified on its command line. That means that command-line variable settings in a make will also take priority in a sub-make.
Since command-line variable settings are passed through the MAKEFLAGS variable, they are not subject to any changes in the makefile. A makefile can unexport or override a variable set on the command-line, but that will only affect the value (or presence) of the variable in the environment; it does not remove or change the value from MAKEFLAGS.
You should get:
outer: foo is replaced
inner: foo is original
In other words, we should get for the sub-make, the value defined on the command-line (original)!
Because, you said yourself:
A makefile can't unexport or override a variable set on the command-line.
So, here, when we empower the environment over the makefile, which means that the makefile has less "power" in the total scheme of things. Right?
Sure, for such a case, you assertion will hold even stronger.
From the docs:
Target-specific variables have the same priority as any other
makefile variable. Variables provided on the command line (and in the
environment if the '-e' option is in force) will take precedence.
Specifying the 'override' directive will allow the target-specific
variable value to be preferred.
So, a simple makefile, like:
# A pattern-specific variable assignment.
% : foo += file
all : x ;
# Target is a double-colon w/o dependencies, so Make will ALWAYS run its commands.
x ::
#echo '$(foo)'
Running, we get:
# Override makefile-level variables, with a command-line assignment.
$ make foo=cmd
cmd cmd cmd
# Set the value in the environment, And tell Make to prefer it over any makefile-level definitions.
$ foo=env make --environment-overrides
env file file
Returning now, to the quote above, from the documentation:
Variables provided on the command line (and in the environment if the '-e' option is in force) will take precedence.
It seems, that using either:
Command-line assignment.
Environment-set variables, AND using -e (--environment-overrides).
Have both the same effect, i.e. overrides the file-level (makefile) variable.
But, the results differ greatly. Remember that the value given in the command-line was: cmd, and the value given in the environment was: env.
Now, compare the values, given for a command-line override vs. an environment override:
cmd cmd cmd (for command-line override).
env file file (for environment override).
So, whereas for command-line, Make repeats the same value, i.e. cmd, 3 times, for environment-override, the situation is different. That is, Make will "repeat" the environment-level value: env only 1 time, and then repeats - none other - than the overridden file-level value: file.
Now, not only is the situation completely different for an "override" from command-line vs. an "override" from the environment, which is strange by itself, the problem here is much bigger.
Since, Make rules to give "priority" for a command-line (or environment) value, why does it insist to append "other" values (as in the case of environment-override, where Make appends "file file"), or in the case of a command-line override (where Make repeats the same value ***3* times). Seriously?
How does it make sense at all? And what is the justification for these inconsistent and strange results?
I believe the answer here is related to the answer to this other question of yours. (And possibly a bug in the env override version.)
The global variables and the target-specific variables are distinct variables.
The cmd cmd cmd result is because when you write %: foo += file make stores that as an addition to the current value of variable foo of the target-specific value of the variable foo which is file.
However, when you set foo on the command line make overrides the value of the target-specific variable foo to be cmd instead of file. So when make concats the variable each time it gets cmd cmd cmd.
That explanation should, I think, get you env env env then and I'm not sure why it doesn't. This could be a bug or it could be some other detail about how env override variables and target-specific variable values work. I'm not sure.
(Check the output of make -p for both these cases to see what I mean about the target-specific variable's value.)
In my makefile I have a variable FOO:
FOO = /path/to/bar
Is it possible to overwrite this variable during the makefile call? Somthing like the following:
FOO=/path/to/foo make all
Specify them as Var=Value before you specify the target, like make FOO=/path/to/foo all.
$ cat Makefile
Foo = asdf
all:
echo $(Foo)
$ make all
echo asdf
asdf
$ make Foo=bar all
echo bar
bar
The ways that variables get assigned values is specified in the How Variables Get Their Values section of the GNU make Manual.
Variables can get values in several different ways:
You can specify an overriding value when you run make. See Overriding Variables.
You can specify a value in the makefile, either with an assignment (see Setting Variables) or with a verbatim definition (see Defining Multi-Line Variables).
Variables in the environment become make variables. See Variables from the Environment.
Several automatic variables are given new values for each rule. Each of these has a single conventional use. See Automatic Variables.
Several variables have constant initial values. See Variables Used by Implicit Rules.
So, as Colonel Thirty Two indicates, you can override variables set in the makefile on the command line.
You can also, if you expect this to be a variable that you want to set persistently, use the ?= assignment and then environment values for that variable will be used.
I am unable to prevent make from communicating any variables to a submake. I've read the manual and I've followed their advice (resetting MAKEOVERRIDES and MAKEFLAGS) but it's still not working has I think it should.
Consider the following prototype Makefile:
${warning $(MAKEOVERRIDES)}
${warning $(MAKEFLAGS)}
${warning $(VAR)}
none:
$(MAKE) -f Makefile MAKEOVERRIDES= MAKEFLAGS= all
all:
echo done!
If I make VAR=10 none, I get the following:
Makefile:2: VAR=10
Makefile:3:
Makefile:4: 10
make -f Makefile MAKEOVERRIDES= MAKEFLAGS= all
make[1]: Entering directory `/home/adriano/sandbox/makes'
Makefile:2:
Makefile:3:
Makefile:4: 10
echo done!
done!
make[1]: Leaving directory `/home/adriano/sandbox/makes'
Meaning that make is communication VAR to the submake. Is this the correct behaviour?
I've tried unexport VAR and bash -c make ... without any luck.
EDIT: I've modified none's recipe to: bash -c "echo $$MAKEOVERRIDES $$MAKEFLAGS $$VAR" ; make ...
This way I found out that VAR is actually being passed through the environment that make creates for the commands to be executed and not through the other variables (the other variables are also passed this way to make).
I think my question now is: how can I create a fresh shell/environment to run my sub make?
EDIT: Someone asked why am I trying to this; I'll try to answer to that here.
I have a "module" which uses a variable named CONFIG. In order to build this module I need to build another partially unrelated "module" which also uses CONFIG, but with a different value. The problem is that when I try to build the "sub-module" CONFIG contains the value of the "super-module." I could specify CONFIG when making the "sub-module" however both modules use many variables with the same name and trying to specify them all would make the modules tightly coupled which is something I cannot afford.
How can this be so difficult...
This is wrong:
none:
$(MAKE) -f Makefile MAKEOVERRIDES= MAKEFLAGS= all
These variables (MAKEOVERRIDES and MAKEFLAGS) are set in the environment by the parent make to be passed down to the sub-makes. Setting overrides on these values inside the recipe won't help, because make has to set the environment for the recipe before it actually starts the commands in the recipe (of course).
You have to override/remove these values in the parent makefile, so that those changes are seen by the parent make before it constructs the sub-make's environment:
MAKEOVERRIDES =
none:
$(MAKE) -f Makefile all
There's no perfect way to do this. However, you can play a trick that will work most of the time:
unexport $(shell echo '$(MAKEOVERRIDES)' | sed 's/=[^ ]*//g')
MAKEOVERRIDES =
The first line tries to unexport all the variables in MAKEOVERRIDES and the second line resets MAKEOVERRIDES. There are a few issues with this. One is that if MAKEOVERRIDES is empty, it will use "unexport" by itself which unexports everything. That can be easily worked around by sticking some bogus variable before the shell function. The other is that if any variable's value contains whitespace, the expansion will consider it a variable to be unexported. That's probably OK, but it's odd.
I can't think of any better way to do it.
You don't really say why you want to do this. Have you considered doing something different, such as running the commands where you want to have a "vanilla" environment using env; for example if you want to run a command with a limited and specific set of env vars, you can run:
test:
env -i PATH='$(PATH)' LANG='$(LANG)' runMyCommand --with --my arguments
Unfortunately some versions of env use - instead of -i; check your man page.
Alternatively, you can try to start a login shell which will re-read the user's shell setup environment from scratch:
test:
/bin/sh -lc 'runMyCommand --with --my arguments'
EDIT: It's difficult because what you're asking to do (restrict the environment of the sub-make) is tricky.
Luckily based on your description, it doesn't seem necessary. Make has a hierarchy of importance for finding variable values. The command line is the highest level (well, there's override but we'll ignore that). After that comes variables set in the makefile itself. And last and lowest comes variables imported from the environment (well, default variables are even lower but we'll ignore that too).
So if your goal is to allow the variables in the sub-makes to not be affected by command line variables given to the upper-level makes, then all this rigmarole of getting the variables out of the environment is not necessary. Variables set in the sub-makefiles will take precedence over the values in the environment. So all you have to do is get rid of the variables set on the command line, which I've already shown how to do above, by setting MAKEOVERRIDES.